why is it hard to write good music?
-
- KVRian
- Topic Starter
- 514 posts since 8 Oct, 2005
Today we have almost every music instrument and recording tool available, and while I hear a lot of great music productions being posted, it's too often the music composition is just so-so.
Performing is made easier for instruments using midi. Recording is easier. This exposes the one thing our PC's can not do for us, writing the music. Writing a good song, or instrumental work, with a great melody and song structure etc is truly the hardest part.
So is writing great music more a craft or a talent?
Performing is made easier for instruments using midi. Recording is easier. This exposes the one thing our PC's can not do for us, writing the music. Writing a good song, or instrumental work, with a great melody and song structure etc is truly the hardest part.
So is writing great music more a craft or a talent?
Last edited by Mike777 on Wed Jul 11, 2018 1:49 pm, edited 2 times in total.
-
el-bo (formerly ebow) el-bo (formerly ebow) https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=208007
- KVRAF
- 16369 posts since 24 May, 2009 from A galaxy, far far away
No! It's simple. There is a differenceMike777 wrote:Performing and recording is now easy
-
- KVRAF
- 3089 posts since 4 May, 2012
It is as hard to write good music as it is to know yourself.
-
thecontrolcentre thecontrolcentre https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=76240
- KVRAF
- 35168 posts since 27 Jul, 2005 from the wilds of wanny
It takes talent, and most people don't have it. Anyone can buy a football, but there's only one Ronaldo (for example).
Last edited by thecontrolcentre on Wed Jul 11, 2018 1:16 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- KVRAF
- 6113 posts since 7 Jan, 2005 from Corporate States of America
How is "performing now easy"?
Also, there's no accounting for taste. What one person considers "good music" is often disliked by another.
Also, there's no accounting for taste. What one person considers "good music" is often disliked by another.
- dysamoria.com
my music @ SoundCloud
my music @ SoundCloud
-
- KVRAF
- 35430 posts since 11 Apr, 2010 from Germany
Yeah. Creative talent. TBH, i quite struggle on that. Never was overly creative, already in school.thecontrolcentre wrote:It takes talent, and most people don't have it.
-
- KVRAF
- 15517 posts since 13 Oct, 2009
Has someone defined "good music." Seems like that's where you want to begin a discussion like this. Then again, I'm 80% through killing a bottle of pinot all by myself, and, well, I'm a lightweight when it comes to alcohol. So, yeah, I could be wayTF off base.
-
- KVRian
- Topic Starter
- 514 posts since 8 Oct, 2005
I will rephrase that. Performing is easier then before because we can edit in midi. Except when playing a real instrument, then performing next as difficult as composing.Jace-BeOS wrote:How is "performing now easy"?
-
- KVRAF
- 2945 posts since 23 Dec, 2002
Good is highly subjective but I know what "good" means to me... For every one song that I consider good enough to bring to full production there are at least 5 to 10 ideas that are just not ready or never will be. Sometimes you need a lyric, a story, a hook , a chord change and it can elude you. I've taken songs really far that I believe in only to discard them when i realize that they aren't cutting it.. on the other hand I have stubbornly refused to give up on an idea and have had it work out. It is always work for me... mixed in with some inspiration and happy accidents - but mostly work.
-
- KVRAF
- 15517 posts since 13 Oct, 2009
Gotta size with Jace here, I don't think that performing is "easier", in fact, I would argue that, if anything, standards and expectations are much much higher. What passed for performance in the sixties would be laughed at today.Mike777 wrote:I will rephrase that. Performing is easier then before because we can edit in midi. Except when playing a real instrument, then performing next as difficult as composing.Jace-BeOS wrote:How is "performing now easy"?
-
- KVRian
- Topic Starter
- 514 posts since 8 Oct, 2005
True. That's why I rephrased what I said- if using midi, then it's easier then before. Otherwise, performance standards are higher today.ghettosynth wrote:Gotta size with Jace here, I don't think that performing is "easier", in fact, I would argue that, if anything, standards and expectations are much much higher. What passed for performance in the sixties would be laughed at today.Mike777 wrote:I will rephrase that. Performing is easier then before because we can edit in midi. Except when playing a real instrument, then performing next as difficult as composing.Jace-BeOS wrote:How is "performing now easy"?
- KVRAF
- 4881 posts since 4 Aug, 2006 from Helsinki
I agree with all the above.
Plus, there's in addition to the change in technology and music busines, there's one important think, which separates us from those who started writing music in the 50-70's. And that's the audience.
The babyboomers created one big, rather homogeneous cosumer cohort.
The "youth culture" was rather new thing, and rock/pop increased feeling of togetherness. The pre-tv babyboomers was a huge consumer force.
The fragmentation started, of course, a long time ago, and today we can't talk about culture of uniform taste in the same cohort.
The challenge of writing (and performing) good music is today exactly the same, as earlier.
But the change to develop the skill, to grow up as a writer/performing artist is more difficult, there aren't enough audience, who grows up with you, who are willing to "pay your living" while you are developing yourself.
Lennon-McCartney were't that great writer in the first 3 years time (1959-61), when they wrote together (and separately). And if you listen to the Beatles Decca audition tapes, the band didn't sound that great.
But they were giving (thanks to Brian Esptein, George Martin, and babyboomers) time to develop - and that they did!
If I should name one thing, which separates L&M and the Beatles from million other bands, it is the DEVELOPMENT. To be able to develop yourself, you need, talent, of course, but you need a change, time and motivation.
How motivated you are - with your unlimited DAW universe, 1034 plugins and virtual instruments, bedroom studio and all the music of the world available?
Plus, there's in addition to the change in technology and music busines, there's one important think, which separates us from those who started writing music in the 50-70's. And that's the audience.
The babyboomers created one big, rather homogeneous cosumer cohort.
The "youth culture" was rather new thing, and rock/pop increased feeling of togetherness. The pre-tv babyboomers was a huge consumer force.
The fragmentation started, of course, a long time ago, and today we can't talk about culture of uniform taste in the same cohort.
The challenge of writing (and performing) good music is today exactly the same, as earlier.
But the change to develop the skill, to grow up as a writer/performing artist is more difficult, there aren't enough audience, who grows up with you, who are willing to "pay your living" while you are developing yourself.
Lennon-McCartney were't that great writer in the first 3 years time (1959-61), when they wrote together (and separately). And if you listen to the Beatles Decca audition tapes, the band didn't sound that great.
But they were giving (thanks to Brian Esptein, George Martin, and babyboomers) time to develop - and that they did!
If I should name one thing, which separates L&M and the Beatles from million other bands, it is the DEVELOPMENT. To be able to develop yourself, you need, talent, of course, but you need a change, time and motivation.
How motivated you are - with your unlimited DAW universe, 1034 plugins and virtual instruments, bedroom studio and all the music of the world available?
-
- KVRAF
- 6425 posts since 22 Jan, 2005 from Sweden
Everything created with a heart - will probably find an audience somewhere in this internet global world.
We have an expression for many swedish artists "BIG IN JAPAN"-thingy. Locally and even otherwise in neighbour countries they could not care less. So expression symbolizes this fenomena more than actually talking about Japan in particular.
The difficulty with "good music" is that you get tired rather soon on certain music, while some that will be an aquired taste is what I found is the goto in the long run. Hit music is often "good music" that wear off rather quickly.
I'm not a hiphop/rap genre guy at all - does not get any of that genre almost. But one track that really get me every time is Eminem "loose yourself" or whatever it is called. It take it's time to build to a climax and there is no way to guard yourself against it - you get reeled in. Really brilliant track.
So the formula might be to catch people with the guard down - and then build up and reel in. Sounds simple doesn't it
We have an expression for many swedish artists "BIG IN JAPAN"-thingy. Locally and even otherwise in neighbour countries they could not care less. So expression symbolizes this fenomena more than actually talking about Japan in particular.
The difficulty with "good music" is that you get tired rather soon on certain music, while some that will be an aquired taste is what I found is the goto in the long run. Hit music is often "good music" that wear off rather quickly.
I'm not a hiphop/rap genre guy at all - does not get any of that genre almost. But one track that really get me every time is Eminem "loose yourself" or whatever it is called. It take it's time to build to a climax and there is no way to guard yourself against it - you get reeled in. Really brilliant track.
So the formula might be to catch people with the guard down - and then build up and reel in. Sounds simple doesn't it
Last edited by lfm on Wed Jul 11, 2018 2:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- KVRAF
- 9077 posts since 28 May, 2005 from Netherneverlands
Agreed. Motivation it such an important factor.. And focus (perhaps translated to "less is more", for some people)! Probably about 75% motivation/focus and only about 25% talent required.Harry_HH wrote: How motivated you are - with your unlimited DAW universe, 1034 plugins and virtual instruments, bedroom studio and all the music of the world available?
I should know as I lack either of them.
No band limits, aliasing is the noise of freedom!