Looking for a DAW with 'non-linear' workflow
-
- KVRist
- Topic Starter
- 154 posts since 22 Jul, 2012 from Magrathea
.
I haven't used many DAW's until now. (Computer)Muzys in the past and now only a bit of Mulab and i 'skimmed' a tiny bit of Reaper.
My question is two-fold:
I want to work with looped melodic sequences in various tracks of different lenghts that must be looped independently and triggered 'on the fly'. Thus a DAW/sequencer with only a linear timeline is not really suited for this workflow.
Ideal would be e.g.:
Track 1 - seq. 3 bars (set to loop)
Track 2 - seq. 5 bars (set to loop)
Track 3 - record improv of undetermined lenght
Linear DAW's can do this, but one has either to cut-and-past all sequences or 'draw' them out but this doesn't cater for the improv. of undetermined lenght!
Therefore my question is: which DAW (pref. free- or budgetware) has a 'non-linear' workflow?
And secondly; which DAW (linear or otherwise) has the possibility to record in loop mode a sequence of undetermined length as a whole? (e.g. loop-time is 30 sec., recorded sequence is 3 minutes. Just a rough example).
In older days I knew that Muzys had that functionality, but alas Mulab doesn't seem to do this. .
I hope someone can help me and i await your suggestions. . .
S.
I haven't used many DAW's until now. (Computer)Muzys in the past and now only a bit of Mulab and i 'skimmed' a tiny bit of Reaper.
My question is two-fold:
I want to work with looped melodic sequences in various tracks of different lenghts that must be looped independently and triggered 'on the fly'. Thus a DAW/sequencer with only a linear timeline is not really suited for this workflow.
Ideal would be e.g.:
Track 1 - seq. 3 bars (set to loop)
Track 2 - seq. 5 bars (set to loop)
Track 3 - record improv of undetermined lenght
Linear DAW's can do this, but one has either to cut-and-past all sequences or 'draw' them out but this doesn't cater for the improv. of undetermined lenght!
Therefore my question is: which DAW (pref. free- or budgetware) has a 'non-linear' workflow?
And secondly; which DAW (linear or otherwise) has the possibility to record in loop mode a sequence of undetermined length as a whole? (e.g. loop-time is 30 sec., recorded sequence is 3 minutes. Just a rough example).
In older days I knew that Muzys had that functionality, but alas Mulab doesn't seem to do this. .
I hope someone can help me and i await your suggestions. . .
S.
- KVRAF
- 12739 posts since 24 Jun, 2008 from Europe
About part 1 of your question: MuLab can do that! Each sequence can have its own sequence loop, so you can even create experimental polyrhythmic grooves & melodies!
About part 2 of your question: In Muzys we indeed had the Play Room where you could trigger the various compositions (aka arrangements) just like patterns on a drumbox and all was recordable into a new fully editable composition.
That functionality will be reincarnated into MuLab be it in a totally new and better way. Already working on the plans of it.
About part 2 of your question: In Muzys we indeed had the Play Room where you could trigger the various compositions (aka arrangements) just like patterns on a drumbox and all was recordable into a new fully editable composition.
That functionality will be reincarnated into MuLab be it in a totally new and better way. Already working on the plans of it.
-
- KVRAF
- 8802 posts since 7 Oct, 2005
This is cool I will keep my eye on MuLabmutools wrote:
That functionality will be reincarnated into MuLab be it in a totally new and better way. Already working on the plans of it.
-
- KVRAF
- 1836 posts since 29 Mar, 2013
OrigamiSlarti wrote:I haven't used many DAW's until now. (Computer)Muzys in the past and now only a bit of Mulab and i 'skimmed' a tiny bit of Reaper.
My question is two-fold
Sorry couldnt help it.....
Beauty is only skin deep,
Ugliness, however, goes right the way through
Ugliness, however, goes right the way through
-
- KVRist
- Topic Starter
- 154 posts since 22 Jul, 2012 from Magrathea
.
Hi Jo, thanks for your reply! .
You had the choice of keeping the looped recording, or make new parts on new tracks of it or keep the recording in one extended (e.g. 2 min.) part!
That function is not in Mulab anymore afaik.
Hi Jo, thanks for your reply! .
Yes it is possible but you have to draw out the looped parts over the timeline, which does not cater for recordings of undetermined lenghts.mutools wrote: About part 1 of your question: MuLab can do that! Each sequence can have its own sequence loop, so you can even create experimental polyrhythmic grooves & melodies!
No, I meant the functionality in Muzys that you could record in loop mode and the recording could be extended for the full recording time (e.g. loop 30 secs, recorded sequence 2 mins).mutools wrote: About part 2 of your question: In Muzys we indeed had the Play Room where you could trigger the various compositions (aka arrangements) just like patterns on a drumbox and all was recordable into a new fully editable composition.
You had the choice of keeping the looped recording, or make new parts on new tracks of it or keep the recording in one extended (e.g. 2 min.) part!
That function is not in Mulab anymore afaik.
-
- KVRist
- Topic Starter
- 154 posts since 22 Jul, 2012 from Magrathea
bibz1st wrote:OrigamiSlarti wrote:I haven't used many DAW's until now. (Computer)Muzys in the past and now only a bit of Mulab and i 'skimmed' a tiny bit of Reaper.
My question is two-fold
Sorry couldnt help it.....
- KVRAF
- 8680 posts since 9 Jan, 2004 from leroyaumeuni
#1
That is Live (and Bitwig I guess)
#2
I'm sure you can do that in Live as you can 'unroll' a loop recording.
That is Live (and Bitwig I guess)
#2
I'm sure you can do that in Live as you can 'unroll' a loop recording.
My other host is Bruce Forsyth
-
- KVRist
- Topic Starter
- 154 posts since 22 Jul, 2012 from Magrathea
You're probably right. Sadly I do not consider Live budgetware. (Maybe Live Essentials?) I'm just a hobbyist on social benefits .spaceman wrote:#1
That is Live (and Bitwig I guess)
Maybe Bitwig indeed now that it has finally (almost) materialized (and I heard there will be a 'free' version)
That's what I meant! .spaceman wrote:#2
I'm sure you can do that in Live as you can 'unroll' a loop recording.
-
thecontrolcentre thecontrolcentre https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=76240
- KVRAF
- 35171 posts since 27 Jul, 2005 from the wilds of wanny
Sounds like you want Live ... maybe Intro or LE version if you're on a budget. They come up regularly in the marketplace at $20 - $50 ...
-
- KVRist
- Topic Starter
- 154 posts since 22 Jul, 2012 from Magrathea
How does that work? Purchasing via the marketplace?thecontrolcentre wrote:Sounds like you want Live ... maybe Intro or LE version if you're on a budget. They come up regularly in the marketplace at $20 - $50 ...
-
- KVRAF
- 2802 posts since 31 Aug, 2011
Its a while ago, but i think Orion pretty much worked like that.
Rather than a traditional timeline arrangment you have a 'sequences arranger' (or pattern sequencer) where you chain together blocks of sequences/patterns. With loop enabled you should able to record live audio of any length while the sequences just keep looping.
Trial Version: Here
Rather than a traditional timeline arrangment you have a 'sequences arranger' (or pattern sequencer) where you chain together blocks of sequences/patterns. With loop enabled you should able to record live audio of any length while the sequences just keep looping.
Trial Version: Here
- KVRAF
- 8680 posts since 9 Jan, 2004 from leroyaumeuni
Just look out for a copy for sale on the market place forum here, and if you find one, arrange a sale with the seller and pay via Paypal. As with any online sale, check credentials first if possible (there's a feedback thread for instance), don't buy from people with zero or very few posts who never seem to have interacted on KvR with any meaning, etc.Slarti wrote:How does that work? Purchasing via the marketplace?thecontrolcentre wrote:Sounds like you want Live ... maybe Intro or LE version if you're on a budget. They come up regularly in the marketplace at $20 - $50 ...
Live can be download only, so just a license transfer will be needed.
My other host is Bruce Forsyth
-
thecontrolcentre thecontrolcentre https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=76240
- KVRAF
- 35171 posts since 27 Jul, 2005 from the wilds of wanny
It's a private deal between you and the seller. Usually payment by PayPal.Slarti wrote:How does that work? Purchasing via the marketplace?thecontrolcentre wrote:Sounds like you want Live ... maybe Intro or LE version if you're on a budget. They come up regularly in the marketplace at $20 - $50 ...
http://www.kvraudio.com/forum/viewtopic ... 3&t=395823
http://www.kvraudio.com/forum/viewtopic ... 3&t=403022
Last edited by thecontrolcentre on Thu Feb 13, 2014 2:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- KVRist
- Topic Starter
- 154 posts since 22 Jul, 2012 from Magrathea
Pretty pricey also!ENV1 wrote:Its a while ago, but i think Orion pretty much worked like that.
Rather than a traditional timeline arrangment you have a 'sequences arranger' (or pattern sequencer) where you chain together blocks of sequences/patterns. With loop enabled you should able to record live audio of any length while the sequences just keep looping.
Trial Version: Here
What you're describing is what i'm after!
(Once in a sale i picked up Cakewalk Project5 which also seems to work that way. Only i'm told it doesn't work with Windows 7 (32) . )