MIDI Mapping in Live - no MIDI port selection???
- KVRian
- Topic Starter
- 648 posts since 20 Jul, 2009
Hi guys
Although I've been using Ableton for quite some time, it's only now, when I need to use multiple MIDI ports for MIDI mapping to various parameters, that I notice Live cannot discern the MIDI ports when doing the MIDI mappings. It only sees the MIDI channel and the note/CC.
So if, for example, I have two MIDI keyboards, and I want to use one of them to trigger clips and the other one to play synths, I have to set them to output on different MIDI channels, otherwise when I start playing synths I'll be triggering the clips as well, although each of them is on a different MIDI port, obviously.
Am I missing something here? Or this is the way Live works and it's impossible to select also the MIDI port, not only the MIDI channel when doing the mappings?
Although I've been using Ableton for quite some time, it's only now, when I need to use multiple MIDI ports for MIDI mapping to various parameters, that I notice Live cannot discern the MIDI ports when doing the MIDI mappings. It only sees the MIDI channel and the note/CC.
So if, for example, I have two MIDI keyboards, and I want to use one of them to trigger clips and the other one to play synths, I have to set them to output on different MIDI channels, otherwise when I start playing synths I'll be triggering the clips as well, although each of them is on a different MIDI port, obviously.
Am I missing something here? Or this is the way Live works and it's impossible to select also the MIDI port, not only the MIDI channel when doing the mappings?
- KVRian
- Topic Starter
- 648 posts since 20 Jul, 2009
If by that you mean the "I|O" button that shows/hide the In/Out section for every track, then yes, I have that showing, but I don't quite see how that helps when doing the MIDI mapping.
-
- KVRist
- 132 posts since 16 Dec, 2011
I guess he ment that in the I/O-section you can select only one controller as input-type for a track (instead of 'All Ins') -> see example belowKTlin wrote:If by that you mean the "I|O" button that shows/hide the In/Out section for every track, then yes, I have that showing, but I don't quite see how that helps when doing the MIDI mapping.
As example, you can set the I/O-input like this:KTlin wrote:So if, for example, I have two MIDI keyboards, and I want to use one of them to trigger clips and the other one to play synths,
Track 1 - Drums : input = keyboard 1
Track 2 - Synth : input = keyboard 2
Midi-keyboard-2 only triggers the assigned track 2.
- KVRian
- Topic Starter
- 648 posts since 20 Jul, 2009
Thanks. Unfortunately it seems I didn't make myself clear enough, and I apologize.
So let me try again, and let's say:
Keyboard 1 (set to output MIDI on channel 1) is MIDI mapped to trigger clips in Session View (clips from different tracks). For example, every note (key) on this keyboard will trigger a different clip.
Keyboard 2 (set to output MIDI on the channel 1 as well) is used to play a synth on, let's say, track 10. Although this track is set to receive MIDI only from keyboard 2, the problem is that this keyboard will also trigger clips because it's set to the same channel as keyboard 1 (although on a different MIDI port).
What can be done is to disabled the Remote Control from the Keyboard 2, so all the MIDI data from it will only be used to play the synth and not to trigger clips. But this is an option just in some cases, because, if Keyboard 2 has knobs and faders and you would like to assign them to control different parameters in a certain synth, then the Remote Control should be enabled.
So let me try again, and let's say:
Keyboard 1 (set to output MIDI on channel 1) is MIDI mapped to trigger clips in Session View (clips from different tracks). For example, every note (key) on this keyboard will trigger a different clip.
Keyboard 2 (set to output MIDI on the channel 1 as well) is used to play a synth on, let's say, track 10. Although this track is set to receive MIDI only from keyboard 2, the problem is that this keyboard will also trigger clips because it's set to the same channel as keyboard 1 (although on a different MIDI port).
What can be done is to disabled the Remote Control from the Keyboard 2, so all the MIDI data from it will only be used to play the synth and not to trigger clips. But this is an option just in some cases, because, if Keyboard 2 has knobs and faders and you would like to assign them to control different parameters in a certain synth, then the Remote Control should be enabled.
-
- KVRian
- 1107 posts since 31 Oct, 2002 from the high desert
You were completely clear the first time, people just don't bother to pay attention.
Only solution has to do with enabling/disabling "remote" in the MIDI settings, but like you said, that may limit things more than you'd like.
Only solution has to do with enabling/disabling "remote" in the MIDI settings, but like you said, that may limit things more than you'd like.
-
- KVRist
- 132 posts since 16 Dec, 2011
Aural Chaos wrote:You were completely clear the first time, people just don't bother to pay attention.
No need to apologize. From the example in your first post I just assumed you only use one keyboard (which has controls ) to trigger things ...KTlin wrote:So if, for example, I have two MIDI keyboards, and I want to use one of them to trigger clips and the other one to play synths ...
Thanks. Unfortunately it seems I didn't make myself clear enough, and I apologize.
.. but in this case: Yeah, it's like Aural Chaos posted: enabling/disabling remoteKTlin wrote:... because, if Keyboard 2 has knobs and faders and you would like to assign them to control different parameters in a certain synth, then the Remote Control should be enabled.
Not sure if it might be also possible to make a user remote script for the knobs/faders of the second keyboard. (using it as a control surface to trigger things and enable it under Midi-Port to play notes)) ??
http://www.macableton.com/hardware-midi ... ripts.html
http://createdigitalmusic.com/2009/07/a ... s-control/
Last edited by solger on Tue Jan 22, 2013 5:29 pm, edited 3 times in total.
- KVRian
- Topic Starter
- 648 posts since 20 Jul, 2009
Thanks a lot guys for your input. No problem if some of you misunderstood what I was saying. I appreciate that you're trying to help anyhow.
I'm gonna check that. I'm not very familiar with the user remote scripts.solger wrote:Not sure if this might also work, if you make a user remote script for the knobs/faders of the second keyboard (using it as a control surface to trigger things and enable it under Midi-Port to play notes)??