Carpenters Vs. Zappa

Anything about MUSIC but doesn't fit into the forums above.
Post Reply New Topic
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

PatchAdamz wrote:This one always makes me smile
The Helsinki towels mystery does the same for me :D

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4_bFACz5Sh8

Post

Numanoid wrote:
PatchAdamz wrote:This one always makes me smile
The Helsinki towels mystery does the same for me :D

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4_bFACz5Sh8
Gotta love it!

Check out this short interview, the interviewer suggest Frank write some "acceptable" lyrics, then dissects "Jazz Discard Party Hats"..

Very funny.....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0w0sY8g2BbE
Last edited by PatchAdamz on Thu Jul 16, 2015 8:36 pm, edited 2 times in total.

Post


Post

PatchAdamz wrote:then dissects "Jazz Discard Party Hats"..

Very funny.....
Indeed, especially as she is called Butcher :hihi:

Post

Tiny sick tears, the cookie jar, the eating hole, the ice box, the box of milk, and The End makes this a laughaton :hihi:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifx6TXRk7n4

Post


Post

I think Nik Kershaw had listened quite a bit to Zappa's Jazz from Hell, as he made this tune

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMYeSt3PUc8

Sad that it could only be a b-side, what a masterpiece :love:

I would be delighted if anybody could point me in the direction of better 80's fusion

Post

BTW: I just realized the obvious link between Bob Dylan and Carpenters

Zimmermann = Carpenter :D

Post

Numanoid wrote:BTW: I just realized the obvious link between Bob Dylan and Carpenters

Zimmermann = Carpenter :D

Your thinking of The Captain & Tennille and Mr. Spock.

Leonard Nimoy recites poetry while the Captain & Tennille play Elton John:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJvkTYKcLqc

Post

My original comment about Zappa not being an arranger was purely conjecture - I don't know his processes and he may have spent an enormous amount of time arranging. But if he was arranging purposefully he didn't seem to be working towards anything traditional in terms of structure and instrumentation - if anything he often seemed to be "anti-arranging"; I imagine him thinking "that's exactly what they're expecting - let me mess that up". As opposed to the more "How do I make these instruments work together more harmoniously? What can I do to the structure of this piece to have better dramatic impact."

Whatever the case, "Dyna Moe Hum" is not "Yesterday". Which is perfectly fine.

The Carpenters, on the other hand, could have made that a hit. :)

Post

JoeCat wrote:My original comment about Zappa not being an arranger was purely conjecture - I don't know his processes and he may have spent an enormous amount of time arranging. But if he was arranging purposefully he didn't seem to be working towards anything traditional in terms of structure and instrumentation - if anything he often seemed to be "anti-arranging"; I imagine him thinking "that's exactly what they're expecting - let me mess that up". As opposed to the more "How do I make these instruments work together more harmoniously? What can I do to the structure of this piece to have better dramatic impact."

Whatever the case, "Dyna Moe Hum" is not "Yesterday". Which is perfectly fine.

The Carpenters, on the other hand, could have made that a hit. :)
I dont buy this "anti-arranging" stuff. For the "rock artist" he had untypical deep roots in the traditional scoring (although self-taughed). The output wasn't far away from Edvard Varese or e.g. Debussy who he admired. Zappa just mixed different genres but his sense of form and method was in the classical music, every single part was well planned.

Post

Harry_HH wrote:
JoeCat wrote:My original comment about Zappa not being an arranger was purely conjecture - I don't know his processes and he may have spent an enormous amount of time arranging. But if he was arranging purposefully he didn't seem to be working towards anything traditional in terms of structure and instrumentation - if anything he often seemed to be "anti-arranging"; I imagine him thinking "that's exactly what they're expecting - let me mess that up". As opposed to the more "How do I make these instruments work together more harmoniously? What can I do to the structure of this piece to have better dramatic impact."

Whatever the case, "Dyna Moe Hum" is not "Yesterday". Which is perfectly fine.

The Carpenters, on the other hand, could have made that a hit. :)
I dont buy this "anti-arranging" stuff. For the "rock artist" he had untypical deep roots in the traditional scoring (although self-taughed). The output wasn't far away from Edvard Varese or e.g. Debussy who he admired. Zappa just mixed different genres but his sense of form and method was in the classical music, every single part was well planned.
My point being it may well be purposeful, but not traditional, in the way Debussy was not. So point taken.

Post

Harry_HH wrote:
JoeCat wrote:My original comment about Zappa not being an arranger was purely conjecture - I don't know his processes and he may have spent an enormous amount of time arranging. But if he was arranging purposefully he didn't seem to be working towards anything traditional in terms of structure and instrumentation - if anything he often seemed to be "anti-arranging"; I imagine him thinking "that's exactly what they're expecting - let me mess that up". As opposed to the more "How do I make these instruments work together more harmoniously? What can I do to the structure of this piece to have better dramatic impact."

Whatever the case, "Dyna Moe Hum" is not "Yesterday". Which is perfectly fine.

The Carpenters, on the other hand, could have made that a hit. :)
I dont buy this "anti-arranging" stuff. For the "rock artist" he had untypical deep roots in the traditional scoring (although self-taughed). The output wasn't far away from Edvard Varese or e.g. Debussy who he admired. Zappa just mixed different genres but his sense of form and method was in the classical music, every single part was well planned.
Not to mention that his arrangements have been performed by countless orchestras/conductors including:

London Symphony Orchestra
Columbus Symphony
ProMusica Chamber Orchestra
Pierre Boulez
Ensemble Modern
Peter Rundel

And sited by many conductors as important works.
Apparently he was working "toward" something.. :)

Post


Post

Zappa thinking "that's exactly what they're expecting - let me mess that up". As opposed to the more "How do I make these instruments work together more harmoniously? What can I do to the structure of this piece to have better dramatic impact."
Really? I think this reactionary notion is projection. Frank Zappa wrote a terrific amount of beautiful music.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9oBTsOU6TG4

FZ as based in people's pedestrian expectations is just wrong.
He considered real composing a hobby which he supported by "it's time to get back to touring with the R&B act".

an arrangement of traditional Doo-Wop: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6xeBsnrFvzc
and here's his arrangement of Ravel's Bolero:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NQ1JamXxd8g

Post Reply

Return to “Everything Else (Music related)”