Plug-ins, Hosts, Apps,
Hardware, Soundware
Developers
(Brands)
Videos Groups
Whats's in?
Banks & Patches
Download & Upload
Music Search
KVR
   
KVR Forum » Hardware (Instruments and Effects)
Thread Read
Kemper vs Line6 "Dream Rig" (was: Which tube guitar pre?)
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6  Next
polaris20
KVRian
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 7:45 am reply with quote
Hink wrote:
polaris20 wrote:
Hink wrote:
polaris20 wrote:
zerocrossing wrote:
So... I've come to the conclusion that I don't think I'll be happy half assing this endeavor. I'm going full ass! Laughing

Do I go Kemper or pod hd500/dt25/Randall iso cab? It'll probably never leave my studio.


Never leaving your studio? Then I'd go either Kemper or an AxeFX, and then an FRFR cab for jamming. The Randall is just going to sound too boxy, and when it comes to recording both the Kemper and Axe kill.

I love my POD HD500 too, and if you don't want to drop the coin on the first too, it's a really good option as well. I'm not personally convinced that a "real tube power amp" is going to be that discernable in a recording these days. The modelers (IMO) have gotten that good.

I play a Mesa DC-5, but generally I spend most of the time plugged into the HD for recording.


I dont know about the Randall cab but my Jet City ISO cab is not boxy at all Shrug


I didn't like either one of them, tbh. But to each their own, I guess. I found them to be a lot of fuss for little to no return over just using a Palmer PDI-09 or a speaker impulse.

If I were hell bent on recording my exact amp's tone, I'd continue using the amp into a load, then to RedWirez impulses, or perhaps check out the new Torpedo Live.


one of my amps has a line out that is post power transformer and if you disconnect the speaker a dummy load goes across the speaker out. So it gives you power tube distortion as well, into IRs and works very well. I also have a Weber Attenuator with a line out though I'm not thrilled with the line out (Eric has made an interesting suggestion though that could change that). The palmer looks interesting but tbh the torpedo live is more to my liking and surely on my list.

BTW the line out like on my amp is actually a very easy mod (but without the dummy load, you would still need something for that) for almost any tube amp. Weber sells a kit but one has to wonder if the kit is really needed as we are not talking about a lot of parts. It's not an fx loop, it's a line out that takes some of the speaker out signal and knocks it down.

Still the iso cabs has it's place and I love it, I still want to build one with adjustable baffles and user configurable acoustic foam (using velcro). I have the plans all drawn up, just waiting not to be lazy and go to my friend's house to cut the wood...which means maybe next year at my rate of speed HiHi


I use a direct box that goes between the cabinet and the power amp, so it's capturing the tone of the power amp in addition to the pre.
^ Joined: 12 Mar 2005  Member: #61213  
Hink
Rad Grandad
- profile
- pm
- e-mail
- www
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 9:20 am reply with quote
polaris20 wrote:
Hink wrote:
polaris20 wrote:
Hink wrote:
polaris20 wrote:
zerocrossing wrote:
So... I've come to the conclusion that I don't think I'll be happy half assing this endeavor. I'm going full ass! Laughing

Do I go Kemper or pod hd500/dt25/Randall iso cab? It'll probably never leave my studio.


Never leaving your studio? Then I'd go either Kemper or an AxeFX, and then an FRFR cab for jamming. The Randall is just going to sound too boxy, and when it comes to recording both the Kemper and Axe kill.

I love my POD HD500 too, and if you don't want to drop the coin on the first too, it's a really good option as well. I'm not personally convinced that a "real tube power amp" is going to be that discernable in a recording these days. The modelers (IMO) have gotten that good.

I play a Mesa DC-5, but generally I spend most of the time plugged into the HD for recording.


I dont know about the Randall cab but my Jet City ISO cab is not boxy at all Shrug


I didn't like either one of them, tbh. But to each their own, I guess. I found them to be a lot of fuss for little to no return over just using a Palmer PDI-09 or a speaker impulse.

If I were hell bent on recording my exact amp's tone, I'd continue using the amp into a load, then to RedWirez impulses, or perhaps check out the new Torpedo Live.


one of my amps has a line out that is post power transformer and if you disconnect the speaker a dummy load goes across the speaker out. So it gives you power tube distortion as well, into IRs and works very well. I also have a Weber Attenuator with a line out though I'm not thrilled with the line out (Eric has made an interesting suggestion though that could change that). The palmer looks interesting but tbh the torpedo live is more to my liking and surely on my list.

BTW the line out like on my amp is actually a very easy mod (but without the dummy load, you would still need something for that) for almost any tube amp. Weber sells a kit but one has to wonder if the kit is really needed as we are not talking about a lot of parts. It's not an fx loop, it's a line out that takes some of the speaker out signal and knocks it down.

Still the iso cabs has it's place and I love it, I still want to build one with adjustable baffles and user configurable acoustic foam (using velcro). I have the plans all drawn up, just waiting not to be lazy and go to my friend's house to cut the wood...which means maybe next year at my rate of speed HiHi


I use a direct box that goes between the cabinet and the power amp, so it's capturing the tone of the power amp in addition to the pre.


well that's what Eric suggested I do with my Weber Minimass attenuator, that Weber makes more of a difference than most people understand. Probably why my iso cab doesn't sound like garbage or boxy, you see it has one little feature that makes all the difference in the world. It has a 3db/6db treble boost (or no boost of course), Other Webers allow you to attenuate the highs separate from the lows (labeled Low/mids and Mid/high) and if I turn that off it's not very good sounding at all (of course that is a bit relative because I'm use to it with the boost). That's the problem with using youtube for demos (which I also do a lot), you're stuck listening to someone else's techniques, the key lies in knowing what you can do something about and what you can't.

If an iso cab sounds too boxy it's my firm belief that the blame should be put on the player and not the cab. Not to sound like I have a big head or anything but if I am not happy with my sound I'm hard on myself because I have failed. I think ZC said it all without even knowing it when he said he liked the Rivera iso cab the best, of course it sounded better...unlike the randall and jet city it has accommodations for two mics. When I mic my 4x12 I use two mics, Dean has a warehouse full of mics in front of his cab and his cab has 4 different speakers. susiwong has a similar set up, you see it's not the jet City that sounds bad or the Rivera that sounds good, it's about taking the time to work out the best configuration.

I'm fortunate because I have no dreams or deadlines, I have all the time in the world to experiment and the knowledge I pick up along the way is more important to me than a song. I learn from trying different things, I learn things from my mistakes and most often I learn things by mistake because I get results I didn't expect.

Miking is just one technique that is not as simple as it sounds and I'm sorry but sims still have not imho nailed this, just because you can move and choose mics in sims is not enough. So if you go with a live rig you have to be prepared to spend a lot of time working on just that. One thing is beam blocking, I am going to build a round grill to go over the speaker in the iso cab so I can tape it with duct tape. When you said that the Jet City sounded boxy I chuckled because one of my issues with it is the "ice pick to the head" effect, not boxy. I could buy a Weber Beam Blocker cheap but with it it's all or nothing. With my 4x12 I have tried different patterns of tape on the grill, different sizes and of course different placement of the pieces of tape and get many different tones. (SRV did this a lot) The iso cab does what I want, it keeps the outside noise out and keeps the noise level down so I dont bother others, that's what I wanted when I bought it...how it sounds is in my hands and my hands only.

So yeah, there are a lot of techniques and some people want to flip a switch, select a preset and maybe do some tweaking and that's all well and good. People are going to hear a cab, an amp, a guitar or whatever and think "that's how it sounds". I am a craftsman from head to toe and I look for what I want from a piece of gear and what I can do to modify it better to my liking. (having a strong background as a machinist helps, there are times in a shop you will spend more time building a jig that you will destroy just to do one operation than it takes to do the operation itself so you start off thinking this way) The only results that matter are the results that matter to me and what I am after, not what other people like. I really enjoy that part of playing and it has always been a part of who I am, and the end of the day I can "own" my sound Smile
----
I never learned anything from being right Hink 2012

RIP Reason L. and Ian B
^ Joined: 05 Sep 2003  Member: #8838  Location: New England U.S.A.
hibidy
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 4:56 pm reply with quote
Nothing to see here, just an in so I can remember to look at this later.
^ Joined: 20 Dec 2005  Member: #91716  
Hink
Rad Grandad
- profile
- pm
- e-mail
- www
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 6:12 pm reply with quote
Question
----
I never learned anything from being right Hink 2012

RIP Reason L. and Ian B
^ Joined: 05 Sep 2003  Member: #8838  Location: New England U.S.A.
hibidy
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 6:35 pm reply with quote
I just discovered the thread, want to look at it later, don't want to forget......but not in the mood to deal with it currently Very Happy
^ Joined: 20 Dec 2005  Member: #91716  
zerocrossing
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 7:02 pm reply with quote
hibidy wrote:
I just discovered the thread, want to look at it later, don't want to forget......but not in the mood to deal with it currently Very Happy


Damn it, why isn't Hibidy ever in the mood? HiHi
----
Zerocrossing Media
http://www.zerocrossing.net
4th Law of Robotics: When turning evil, display a red indicator light. ~[ ●_● ]~
^ Joined: 26 Jun 2006  Member: #111565  Location: San Francisco Bay Area
zerocrossing
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 7:37 pm reply with quote
wasi wrote:
Just go out and play them to death. As in a very long time and on several occasions, not just half an hour, once. Ask if you can borrow one for a gig or something.

I'm personally sceptical the Kemper can live up to its price tag out in the wild, it seems like a hot-rodded amp plugin from a purely consumer perspective (who cares what the tech behind it is). Line6 makes great and affordable stuff and it may be the best of bost worlds (or as close as you can get), as opposed to the best of one world with the Kemper...

It's also what you feel comfortable with using. Too many options can leave you frustrated (yeah, no kidding).


While it's true that as you get to a certain price point there's a point of diminishing returns, you also get what you pay for. Also, nothing is perfect and there is always compromise, As you might know, I've been a pretty big proponent of modeling software... well, hardware too if you consider the fact that I ditched real amps years ago due to flexibility reasons. I'm not sure what my first amp modeler actually was... I think an ART SGX2000. I even managed to get some great sounds out of it... but that might be the nostalgia talking. HiHi Anyway, I've been though a lot of high-tech guitar gear including stuff from Line6, though I must admit I never fell in love with the distortion stompbox modeler... the yellow one from years ago... I did love the Vox Tonelab though. That seemed to be a more "natural" sound to me.

But even the Vox had issues. So-so effects that didn't sync to a MIDI clock made me to to a Boss VF-1 (who's amp modeling was piss poor) for it's pretty decent digital effects. I was pretty happy...

I had no good bass solution and that's what led me to Amplitube SVX. Love God I still love the way that software sounds. The rest of it too. I only almost all their models at this point, though I have to admit the Jet City stuff didn't do much for me. Shrug YMMV as Susi Wong would say.

But Amplitube is a compromise as is an HD500. Frankly I've been listening to a TON of Line6 demos lately and IMO they do nothing that isn't available in Amplitube or S-Gear in terms of quality. Don't get me wrong, they're capable of sounding very good. I consider Amplitube and S-Gear top of the line in terms of software amp models.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcJ-uxfPTAE&feature=relmfu

But I doubt I'd ever be fooled into thinking it was an actual tube amp. I went with the Kemper because in all honesty the very first time I heard the demos something "snapped" in me that I didn't hear in any other amp modeler including the very expensive Axe FX. In fact, I'll go as far as to say that the Pod HD500/DT combo blows away the Axe FX.

So I'm not just wowed by some new tech or I would have been gaga for the Axe FX. I wasn't. Still don't see what the big deal is. Even when I had a chance to play with one in person I thought, "That sounds good." When I heard the Kemper demos I thought, "HEY! That sounds like a good amp!" (I also thought this about the DT25/HD500, though to be fair it is a real tube amp with digital help) Note I used the word "like." I'm fully aware that in the right conditions most of us wouldn't even be totally fooled by the Kemper... but I think it's as close as we'll get without using a system that pushes AC out of tubes into a box with a speaker. And trust me, if I found an iso cab that was fairly priced that I liked the sound of, I would have gone HD500/DT25, which btw, is more expensive than the Kemper. But the Kemper has one thing on it's side and that's it's small and totally silent.

And, without having to spend over $2k on the DT25/HD500/SilentSister combo, I actually have enough scratch left over to augment it with an HD500, which I've pretty much decided I'm going to grab.
----
Zerocrossing Media
http://www.zerocrossing.net
4th Law of Robotics: When turning evil, display a red indicator light. ~[ ●_● ]~
^ Joined: 26 Jun 2006  Member: #111565  Location: San Francisco Bay Area
zerocrossing
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 7:40 pm reply with quote
Hink wrote:

congrats ZC, I hope you love it (I'm sure you will) Smile


Thanks sir! Maybe I'll break into your studio in the night and profile all your amps like some sonic guitar tone Vampire. Laughing
----
Zerocrossing Media
http://www.zerocrossing.net
4th Law of Robotics: When turning evil, display a red indicator light. ~[ ●_● ]~
^ Joined: 26 Jun 2006  Member: #111565  Location: San Francisco Bay Area
hibidy
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 7:53 pm reply with quote
zerocrossing wrote:


So... (drumroll please!) I went with the Kemper. I just ordered one from www.jrrshop.com. Exciting! I'm pretty sure this is the most expensive guitar tech I've ever owned including both my Steinbergers. (got them used)


I hate you

Quote:
Here's how I came to my conclusion....


gas gas gas gas gas gas gas gas..........
^ Joined: 20 Dec 2005  Member: #91716  
zerocrossing
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 8:40 pm reply with quote
hibidy wrote:
zerocrossing wrote:


So... (drumroll please!) I went with the Kemper. I just ordered one from www.jrrshop.com. Exciting! I'm pretty sure this is the most expensive guitar tech I've ever owned including both my Steinbergers. (got them used)


I hate you

Quote:
Here's how I came to my conclusion....


gas gas gas gas gas gas gas gas..........


That's it. I'm officially resigning as president of the Hibidy fan club. Scared
----
Zerocrossing Media
http://www.zerocrossing.net
4th Law of Robotics: When turning evil, display a red indicator light. ~[ ●_● ]~
^ Joined: 26 Jun 2006  Member: #111565  Location: San Francisco Bay Area
hibidy
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 8:46 pm reply with quote
Troll
^ Joined: 20 Dec 2005  Member: #91716  
hibidy
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 8:47 pm reply with quote
On a serious note I can't wait to hear what you have to say about it.

My thing is I'm so solitary I have nobody to go profile Laughing So it would be all about the profiles provided.
^ Joined: 20 Dec 2005  Member: #91716  
Uncle E
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
- e-mail
- www
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 9:16 pm reply with quote
hibidy wrote:
Nothing to see here, just an in so I can remember to look at this later.

You can subscribe to threads on the bottom left of this page.
----
Redeem the 10% "FORUM" and 15% "GROUP" coupons at:
^ Joined: 21 Nov 2000  Member: #92  Location: Orange County
hibidy
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 9:32 pm reply with quote
Does a subscription mean getting spammed with emails? I know for example you can't UNSUBSCRIBE from a thread in the literal term so not sure what the advantage is (other than saving one post, it's different on other forums as far as I can tell)

I use the "all my forum posts" for checking on what is going on, it's where my bookmark takes me.
^ Joined: 20 Dec 2005  Member: #91716  
Uncle E
KVRAF
- profile
- pm
- e-mail
- www
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2012 9:48 pm reply with quote
zerocrossing wrote:
I went with the Kemper because in all honesty the very first time I heard the demos something "snapped" in me that I didn't hear in any other amp modeler including the very expensive Axe FX. In fact, I'll go as far as to say that the Pod HD500/DT combo blows away the Axe FX.

So I'm not just wowed by some new tech or I would have been gaga for the Axe FX. I wasn't. Still don't see what the big deal is.

Totally agree on the Axe FX. I had the latest one and sold it within a month. None of the patches came anywhere near giving me the experience of standing in front of an amp.

When I first played the Kemper, it was immediately after playing the Burriss Royal Bluesman. I was totally blown away by the Royal Bluesman's dynamics, it's probably the most dynamic tube amp I've ever played (Deluxe Reverb clean to cranked 18W Marshall grind by simply adjusting pick attack). So, when I discovered the dynamics knob on the Kemper and was able to dial in nearly the exact same dynamics control out of it (plus, with a much wider tonal selection available with those dynamics), I was sold.
----
Redeem the 10% "FORUM" and 15% "GROUP" coupons at:
^ Joined: 21 Nov 2000  Member: #92  Location: Orange County
All times are GMT - 8 Hours

Printable version
Page 4 of 6
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6  Next
Display posts from previous:   
ReplyNew TopicPrevious TopicNext Topic
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Username: Password:  
KVR Developer Challenge 2012