User Reviews by KVR Members for Music Creator
Music Creator is Cakewalk's replacement for the older Cakewalk Express, a light version of whatever is their main sequencer product at the time. In the times of Sonar, it is MC.
This program is very poorly supported. I suspect Cakewalk's rationale for that is its very low price compared to Sonar, but that is really just an excuse. It's simpler than all that: if you are not going to support a product -- don't put it on the market. There is a major MIDI bug in MC4 4.2.2 (latest as of Dec '07) which tech support simply will not deal with. The bug makes it of limited use as a VST/VSTi host. The bug is, if loaded into MC4 VST/VSTi's do not listen to MIDI patch(program) changes. Program changes recorded on MC4 tracks will be transmitted by MC4 via whatever MIDI out is assigned, but any loaded VST/VSTi's ignore them. Cakewalk is not forthcoming in any way about fixing this bug, so, if you have any plans to use patch changes at any time, this program is not a wise investment.
All the other features I have used seem to function correctly. But as complex as the Sonar program is (and this program is essentially Sonar) it's hard to tell what I might have missed. If another bug is located, the only thing I can count on is I'm on my own. So if you're looking at budget sequencers, I would not recommend this one to anyone who is concerned about long-term support. There are realistic alternatives. Look at them. Search KVR for sequencers by price and try them first.
This program is very poorly supported. I suspect Cakewalk's rationale for that is its very low price compared to Sonar, but that is really just an excuse. It's simpler than all that: if you are not going to support a product -- don't put it on the market. There is a major MIDI bug in MC4 4.2.2 (latest as of Dec '07) which tech support simply will not deal with. The bug makes it of limited use as a VST/VSTi host. The bug is, if loaded into MC4 VST/VSTi's do not listen to MIDI patch(program) changes. Program changes recorded on MC4 tracks will be transmitted by MC4 via whatever MIDI out is assigned, but any loaded VST/VSTi's ignore them. Cakewalk is not forthcoming in any way about fixing this bug, so, if you have any plans to use patch changes at any time, this program is not a wise investment.
All the other features I have used seem to function correctly. But as complex as the Sonar program is (and this program is essentially Sonar) it's hard to tell what I might have missed. If another bug is located, the only thing I can count on is I'm on my own. So if you're looking at budget sequencers, I would not recommend this one to anyone who is concerned about long-term support. There are realistic alternatives. Look at them. Search KVR for sequencers by price and try them first.
Latest 1 review from a total of 1
Discussion: Active
Posts displayed newest at the top
Replies to posts run old to new below the parent
Posts displayed newest at the top
Replies to posts run old to new below the parent

Discussion
Please log in to join the discussion



