I wish there was a beginner sub-category, but I thought I'd ask anyway.
Say you have a few MIDI files labeled by key.
MIDI_TEMPO_C.mid
MIDI_TEMPO_Cm.mid
MIDI_TEMPO_F.mid
Easy enough, understood.
But what would the following represent in terms of key?
MIDI_TEMPO_C-G.mid
MIDI_TEMPO_F#-Gb.mid
A hybrid of keys that work musically together? C & G, F# & Gb, etc.
Thanks in advance.
Key represented as C-G ?
- KVRist
- 152 posts since 11 Jan, 2013
-
- KVRian
- 880 posts since 26 Oct, 2011
There's no way to tell without looking at the midi files. Maybe it's saying that first key is C which is modulated then to G. Maybe it's saying C chord which then goes to G chord. If it's the latter, then you have couple options for the key; it could be C or it could be G.
F#-Gb makes things even more confusing, because those two notes are enharmonic. If you're in the key of F#, then you're in the same key as Gb, because these two are enharmonic tones. Likewise, the chord F# is the same thing as the chord Gb. Kind of anyway.
So whatever midi files you have, there's no way to help you with those without being able to look at them.
F#-Gb makes things even more confusing, because those two notes are enharmonic. If you're in the key of F#, then you're in the same key as Gb, because these two are enharmonic tones. Likewise, the chord F# is the same thing as the chord Gb. Kind of anyway.
So whatever midi files you have, there's no way to help you with those without being able to look at them.
- KVRist
- Topic Starter
- 152 posts since 11 Jan, 2013
I appreciate you taking a look & giving it a shot! Can you view the attached photos clearly? I had to open each in a new tab. First is F#-Gb, second C-G.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
- KVRAF
- 6370 posts since 8 Jun, 2009
The F#-Gb one is as Functional described: just enharmonic equivalents. It’s the only note in the file, just spread across octaves.
The C-G one has a misleading name as it uses the notes from just a C major chord - C, E and G - where you might expect it to be a C and G major chord, one after the other from the name.
The C-G one has a misleading name as it uses the notes from just a C major chord - C, E and G - where you might expect it to be a C and G major chord, one after the other from the name.
- KVRian
- 736 posts since 19 Sep, 2007 from Germany
I think the creator of that MIDI files chose that names to show in which scales that notes are working. The first MIDI file works in the scales F# and Gb, which is like the others also written enharmonic. And the second file works in the scales C and G. They would also work in some Minor scales, but like the notes placed in that MIDI files, the sequences are looking more "Major" and the possible chords in the C-G file are also Major chords.
www.musicformer.de
(one of the new online projects)
(one of the new online projects)