MilesParker wrote: Mon Nov 10, 2025 8:45 pm
I was looking at the white/clear surface, mostly because I'm cheap and also I worry that I won't see the lights as well. OTOH, there is not denying that the black surface looks so much cooler, which you know ... is important too.
I had the exact same thoughts -- so I decided to try both white and black speed bumpys and compare to original surface that comes with LinnStrument ... see pic.
.
Linnstrument Speedbumpy Surface Comparison 20251027.jpg
.
My thoughts:
- Black and White Speedbumpy 128 units feel and play exactly the same.
- Black looks best IMO and looks best to most friends I've shown comparison.
- Black is harder for player to see lights than white or original (dimmer but readable).
- Black hotdog version is harder to read the setup menu readouts (numbers and words)
- Black photographs better than others, which may be important if you're photographing / doing performance videos that are non-tutorial. However viewer won't see played note your finger covers (see my alternate solution earlier in this thread).
- White Speedbumpy looks very similar to original. With a casual glance you wouldn't even notice it was an aftermarket change from original by looks.
- White Speedbumpy and Original Surface is far superior than Black for visual feedback.
- White costs less. There are additional processing steps to create black surface (painting, coating) adding to the cost difference.
- Original surface is great. I bought multiple LinnStruments based on Roger's original surface.
- Speedbumpy offers better user control of Y axis which is the most significant reason I'd buy a Speedbumpy surface.
- Speedbumpy feels like a thick bass string and better orients me tactile-wise for playing the LinnStrument. Playing it percussively feels like a pad.
- Either Speedbumpy is easier to track finger location when not looking, especially playing hanging LinnStrument with strap.
My personal conclusions:
- My favorite of 3 surface options for the LinnStrument 128 is the White Speedbumpy. It provides improved performance while retaining the visual feedback and looks of the original. White is my preference as a player and have purchased several for all of my 128 units.
- I have one black surface I plan to use when playing with a strap where I'm not looking at it but others can see it.
- Note: while installation is fairly easy, I wouldn't want to be swapping surfaces on a unit regularly other than for a special occasion.
I have had an opportunity to demo the new "soybean" surface prototype for the 200 note unit and it is fantastic. I plan to use Speedbumpy surfaces on all 5 of my LinnStruments when white 200 note version is available.