This plugin is amazing, the kits in this plugin sound so good. I was a long time EZD2 and superior Drummer user, but this plugin actually sounds better for anything I have used it for, out of the box. Crazy, I just wish more people used it because i would like to trade the kits and sounds the way the plugin was also designed to do. If you make metal, this is way better than EZD, or GGD imo, I have all 3 and this destroys the others. The rooms sound amazing.
Yes, they sound good, but the genre they sound good on is pretty limited, so comparing them to EZ and SD is not really a correct thing to do. Only a porportion of SD and EZ is in the same area. With SD and EZ you get a far more sophisticted and deeper drum software, especially if you rely on pre made grooves. When it comes to sound Perfect D sound good, but IMHO SD sound AS good, so there is really no need to buy Perfect Drums in addition. I would then rather go for one of SD expansions. But if you only stay within the heavier part of rock music, and are able to play drums and full grooves on your keyboard/drum pad, then you might look into this one. I would however like to mention that when it comes to sound the EastWest drum software is hard to beat, however this is also more limited than EZ and SD. So if your are NOT a drummer, and need "help" building a credible groove, I still think EZ would be the best choise, especially cost wise.