Honestly, the Computer Music/Musicradar reviews are among the worst in the industry.Numanoid wrote:Kind of amazing that Computer Music can give it 10/10 rating if such problems exist in the release versionSoundplex wrote:It's not about whining because there are some bugs. Some can't even open the plugin without problems. Others have to quit using it due to these circumstances. There are many things that won't work well and should have been fixed before releasing and selling a product...
I mean how thoroughly did the review it, and do they check that a product works out of the box on more than one format (I hope they do).
Doesn't mean they were paid to give good reviews. However, it is very very common that specialized magazines like this or SOS get most of their revenue from advertisement. I wouldn"t be surprised that the next CM magazine has full page advertisements for Avenger. In which case the magazine feels obliged to give at least a decent review, else the company being reviewed will withdraw advertisments the following months. That is to say, if the product is complete garbage, it will get a 5/10 instead of the 2/10 it really deserves. If it's barely okay it will get a a 7/10, etc. Magazines need to keep at least fair relations with the advertisers to survive. That's how it works. You can see that in video games magazines, audio and video magazines, etc.
Hence, if you want fairly unbiased reviews, look for magazines with no advertisements from the companies being reviewed.
Now did CM have zero issues when doing their test ? I don't know, but it might be possible, given the beta testers didn't report most of them either.