Amen to that.trappist wrote:That's about it......what more can ya' say?As for fat or thin, who cares ? If you're happy with the sound it produces, and if that sound works well in your mix, then all is well.
Another thing that perhaps people never stop to consider is that you need contrast and balance. If you have all "phat" items in your mix then it gets to be a big mess. Just as in a painting you would have elements that are done in more detail and with more saturated colors, vs. less detail and less saturated colors, etc. to create dimension, so too you need this kind of contrast in your sounds if you want some things to stand out. Even in a Pre-Raphaelite painting has this, lol.
A correlation from fiction writing/drama would be main characters vs. secondary characters, etc.
So, in my humble opinion I believe that both are essential components. I personally don't agree that the Wavestation is thin. If it's thin to you then I take that as a reflection of your programming skills. Granted, I don't expect it to sound exactly like an Oberheim OB-8 or something either. But there is a lot that can be done with the elements that are present in order to create some pretty warm sounds. I think some of the presets reflect that.
The D-50 is a pretty cool synth too. Back in the day it was a very tough decision regarding WS vs. D50 as I could only afford one at the time.
And the Wavestation was not intended as an all in one workstation. They had the M1 and T-series synths to cover that. When the Wavestation first came out so many people "cried" about the drums and lack of piano (if I remember correctly) that they came out with the EX version to try and alleviate that.
Anyway... the original quote says it best. If you like the sound of the WS, cool. If you don't like it, move along. If you click on the Instruments link in the upper righthand corner you will see that there are a TON of choices out there. Choose what works best for you and for the music YOU do, not what some magazine ad or bunch of blokes on some forum tells you.