By bduffy
On 15th May 2006 Version: 1 & 2 Read all reviews by bduffy
6 of 12 people found this review helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes | No |
| |
GUI
Sound
Features
Docs
Presets
Support
VFM
Stability | I've been meaning to review Kontakt for some time now; it's only been my sampling workhorse for 4 years now! :lol: I've been a little reluctant to because my final chapter with Kontakt is yet unwritten, as the upgrades to Kontakt have really changed the software that I initially purchased so much that I'm thinking of leaving Kontakt. But more on that soon.
After demoing as many samplers as I could, I decided on Kontakt. Kontakt had an excellent feature list and format support and I really liked the dedicated browser, instead of HALion's and VSampler's page-by-page method. I liked how everything could be in one place, and the GUI was just gorgeous, living up to Native Instruments' reputation. Some people thought the fonts were too small, but I never had a problem with that.
Even though it's always a little intimidating learning a new sampler, I found it pretty easy to get up and running with Kontakt. The way it worked seemed to make sense to me, and it did a good job of importing my soundfonts, AKAI and Gigasampler patches. Kontakt was my pathway to a larger, better sampling world and I was really enjoying it. Kontakt wasn't working very well in SONAR at this time, but we're talking about the very first incarnation of DXi, so it was a very buggy format. Luckily, I switched to Cubase during this time, and Kontakt worked FLAWLESSY in Cubase. Sadly, that would change soon.
The manual that came with Kontakt was pretty basic and incomplete. There are things you can do with Kontakt that simply aren't listed in there. I'm not sure if the manual is updated now, but you usually have to go online and look up addendums and tutorials to find out about newer features. They probably should have offered at least a newer, inclusive pdf download so the information could be read offline, all in one place. Luckily the NI Forums are great for asking and learning.
The library that came with v1.0 was not very well received by anyone. Personally, I did not care; I was buying this strictly for the sampler, but it doesn't reflect so well on a cutting-edge company like this when the samples are 3rd-rate. Smartly, NI released a wonderful library with Kontakt 2 - a good consolation considering the upgrade price!
Now here's where things get tricky. What I've found over the lifespan of Kontakt is that the race to incorporate new features and meet the myriad of demands from the market has really messed up what was initially a very stable piece of software. Like I said earlier, Kontakt v1.0 up until v1.1 worked very smoothly in Cubase. But with each successive update, basic features would start disappearing and eventually the interface would start behaving oddly. It seemed to me that whenever they tried to advance Kontakt as a standalone, Gigastudio-style application, the VST version got buggier. Soon I could not use the mousewheel anymore (haven't been able to for over 2 years now), a crucial time-saver for browsing samples and stacked instruments. Kontakt now stole the spacebar from Cubase, forcing me to click around just to stop or play, and I experience weird mouse-slowdowns - to this day - when loading large instruments, closing the UI or clicking on folders in the browser.
I wrote NI copiously reminding them that basic functions are missing/corrupting. I got mystified responses; well mannered, but not useful. This is with one $79 upgrade already under my belt; to this day, I don't know why this upgrade (which didn't fix anything) was paid.
So a year or two later they released Kontakt 2 to the tune of $200 CAD. Now the sampler is so radically different that I can barely use it. I would think that it would be great if you've never used K1, but for now it's very confusing. Not to mention the new Kontakt Mixer has not been hooking up properly with the Cubase mixer. As of this writing, a new 2.1 update was just released that is resulting in most stereo outputs winding up as dual-mono in the VST Mixer. And still, after all this time, my mouse still slows down and some nice, basic features are still missing. So I will probably move on to something else, if I can find something that will match the features.
That's not to say "don't get Kontakt", I'm just warning any potential buyers: the emphasis has been on adding new features, not stabilizing Kontakt. But this is working very well for many users, and I'm sure if I'd started on Kontakt 2 instead of spending years with Kontakt 1, I'd be a lot happier. It is a very, very powerful sampler, lots of fun to work with, plus Kontakt has succeeded in stealing the market from HALion, and is now a standard issue format for sample libraries. I really like the draggable FX in Kontakt 2, the keyboard shortcuts are excellent and overall the K2 interface looks even better and is more clear and easy to work with.
So definitely make this the first sampler you check out. But I would take special note of customer feedback and see what people with similar setups are using. |
|