Continuous Music Quiz

Anything about MUSIC but doesn't fit into the forums above.
Post Reply New Topic
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

hakey wrote:Might giving the answer also invoke Godwin's Law?
Erm.... not as I understand it.

Right then....

Steve Priest:
In one performance of "Blockbuster" on Top of the Pops, Steve Priest incited much controversy with a tongue-in-cheek appearance on stage clad in Nazi regalia.
http://www.thesweetband.com/steve.html

Vivian Stanshall:
Like so many rock musicians of the Sixties, he became a heavy drinker and drug user and went on many binges with Keith Moon in the Seventies, the most infamous being when they dressed as Nazi officers and toured around the East End, causing shock and dismay.
http://www.iankitching.me.uk/music/bonzos/viv.html

Siouxsie Sioux:
During World War II England had been under constant attack from the Nazis, and because the English had to fight German attack on their own soil Nazism became a symbol of evil in their culture - to a much larger extent than here in the US. During the late 70s many young Brits who were not alive during World War II found it easy to shock the older generation with Nazi imagery. People their parents' age had been around to see Hitler drop bombs on their homes, and the younger generation had no sense of what it was like to live in war time. But using Nazi imagery proved to be the biggest fashion mistake of Siouxsie Sioux's life. It had gone over well when she had come out on stage, topless, with a swastika painted on her chest in a London pub (notably with Sid Vicious on drums). It wasn't about to go over as well elsewhere.

In 1976 Siouxsie Sioux went with the Sex Pistols to mainland Europe for their tour. When in France, Siouxsie underestimated the importance of Nazi symbolism in the country. France had been torn apart by the war, forced to live under the tyrannical rule of both Nazi Germans and the collaborators, the Nazi French, also known as the Vichy Republic. And unlike the punks of England, the punks of France still felt the sting of Hitler's whip, even thirty years later. When a French punk (whose identity was never discovered) caught sight of foreigner Siouxsie Sioux walking around his hometown with a black armband emblazoned with the Nazi swastika, he took it upon himself to show the girl that she had made the wrong decision. Although the Frenchman's cowardly act of beating up a girl in her mid-twenties displayed nothing but a deep personal insecurity, it should act as a warning: if you're going to play with sacred symbols, be prepared to pay a price.
http://www.truepunk.com/tag/siouxsie-sioux/

Post

The Fex wrote:
hakey wrote:Might giving the answer also invoke Godwin's Law?
Erm.... not as I understand it.
Well, strictly speaking, Godwin's Law refers to comparisons with the Nazis, but in common usage it can now just mean any mention of Hitler or the Nazis in a thread:
One of the most famous pieces of Usenet trivia out there is "if you mention Hitler or Nazis in a post, you've automatically ended whatever discussion you were taking part in". Known as Godwin's Law

Post

hakey wrote:
One of the most famous pieces of Usenet trivia out there is "if you mention Hitler or Nazis in a post, you've automatically ended whatever discussion you were taking part in". Known as Godwin's Law
I don't know who you're quoting, but that's just silly.
Godwin's law applies especially to inappropriate, inordinate, or hyperbolic comparisons of other situations (or one's opponent) with Hitler or Nazis or their actions. The law and its corollaries would not apply to discussions covering genocide, propaganda, early 20th century eugenics (racial superiority) or other mainstays of the Nazi Germany, nor, more debatably, to discussion of other totalitarian regimes, since a Nazi comparison in those circumstances is appropriate. Whether it applies to humorous use or references to oneself is open to interpretation, since this would not be a fallacious attack against a debate opponent.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_Law

Post

The Fex wrote:
hakey wrote:
One of the most famous pieces of Usenet trivia out there is "if you mention Hitler or Nazis in a post, you've automatically ended whatever discussion you were taking part in". Known as Godwin's Law
I don't know who you're quoting, but that's just silly.
Silly, or not, (Godwin's Law isn't meant to be taken seriously is it?) I was quoting it as an example of common usage.

Anyway, you understood what I was getting at - that the answer would contain references to the Nazis ... unless, that is, you'd already worked it out :)

Post

hakey wrote:(Godwin's Law isn't meant to be taken seriously is it?)
Not really. Godwin's Law actually just states that "As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1." Which, if you think about it, doesn't really mean much. Even so, the principle that an online discussion has outlived its usefulness as soon as the contributors start calling each other Nazis is a very good one, IMO. The common usage you refer to, OTOH, is bollocks.
hakey wrote:Anyway, you understood what I was getting at - that the answer would contain references to the Nazis ... unless, that is, you'd already worked it out
No, you told me the answer.... if it is the answer....

Post

Fex, as a fellow pedant I feel your pain. No need to keep on quoting Godwin's Law verbatim - I get it. In fact, if you look in one of my above posts I wrote:
strictly speaking, Godwin's Law refers to comparisons with the Nazis
so you're only telling me something I already knew. ;)

Post

Well, it was you who mentioned Godwin's Law.
Bloody Nazi.

Post

:hihi:

Post

Are you going to ask a question, or should we wait for robojam to confirm?

Post

Best not jump to conclusions - though it seems likely that it's the right answer.

In the meantime I'll see if I can come up with a question.

Post

The Fex (Summary of post) wrote:They were all criticized for wearing Nazi symbols in public
Correct!

Post

In fairness, I think we should give it to hakey.
Or he'll get in a strop and invade Poland again.

Post

I'm fine with that
and I'm sure the Poles are too

Post

A picture question.

Image
Image
Imageic

I'm looking for a rhythm composer (and an explanation ;) ).

Did somebody mention 'The War'?

Post

808 State?

Post Reply

Return to “Everything Else (Music related)”