Is dance music real music ?

[stillshaded]

It's only reel music if you run it through a tape machine.

[highkoo]

Even discussing this is ridiculous.

[incubus]

Fun stuff!

Subtopical question: What music constitutes art?

Art Music:

"There have been continual attempts throughout the history of popular music to make a claim for itself as art rather than as popular culture, and a number of music styles that were previously understood as "popular music" have since been categorized in the art or classical category. According to the academic Tim Wall, the most significant example of the struggle between Tin Pan Alley, African American, vernacular and art discourses was in jazz. As early as the 1930s, artists attempted to cultivate ideas of "symphonic jazz", taking it away from its perceived vernacular and black American roots. Following these developments, histories of popular music tend to marginalize jazz, partly because the reformulation of jazz in the art discourse has been so successful that many people today will not consider it a form of popular music.

In the second half of the 20th century, there was a large-scale trend in American culture in which the boundaries between art and pop music became increasingly blurred. Beginning in 1966, the degree of social and artistic dialogue among rock musicians dramatically accelerated for bands who fused elements of composed music with the oral musical traditions of rock. During the late 1960s and 1970s, progressive rock bands represented a form of crossover music that combined rock with high art musical forms either through quotation, illusion, or imitation. Progressive music may be equated with explicit references to aspects of art music, sometimes resulting in the reification of rock as art music.

While progressive rock is often cited for its merging of high culture and low culture, few artists incorporated literal classical themes in their work to any great degree, as author Kevin Holm-Hudson explains: "sometimes progressive rock fails to integrate classical sources ... [it] moves continuously between explicit and implicit references to genres and strategies derived not only from European art music, but other cultural domains (such as East Indian, Celtic, folk, and African) and hence involves a continuous aesthetic movement between formalism and eclecticism."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art_music

You could have just said "as long as it's not dream theater"

[goldenanalog]

You could have just said "as long as it's not dream theater"

But Isn't Jordan a Classical Wizard? And his Wizardry Classical?

[incubus]

I like DT personally, but in small doses.

@Rudess: Well, we've hacked off every conceivable limb of his years ago