What’s your go-to plate reverb for snare ?

[Funkybot's Evil Twin]

So yes, Arturia’s model is a hybrid convolution model, confirmed on Gearspace by none other than Martin from Arturia.

Now, with that in mind, go back and read what I originally wrote that you jumped in to counter.

[jamcat]

I didn’t counter what you wrote, (unless you were trying to use that quote to dispute it is a convolution hybrid.) I took it as confirmation that it is. However, Martin’s post and the use of convolution both seem to dispel any notion that Arturia’s plate is based on physically modeled wave propagation and the KPT equation paper from Physical Audio.

Also, it seems we already had this identical debate about Valhalla Plate 15 months ago in this very thread, with the same results as this latest rehash.

[TechHaus]

Let's do it again in 15 months fellas, yeah?

[jens]

Arturia’s plate is a convolution hybrid, not a physical model. So, no, it’s not based on the 2019 plate physical modeling research paper ICA2016-559, which was authored by the developers at Physical Audio.

Look who's wrong again...

It's indeed not based on that plate research paper, but just because because the DSP-programmer who did the Rev-Plate 140 actually published his own thesis on plate modelling.

Kevin Arcas

PhD - Engineer at Arturia- Senior Researcher
[...]

On the DSP department my work is focused on developping new algorithms for sound generation and transformation for virtual synthesizers and audio effects. Sometimes that concerns Arturia designs as Pigments synth and sometimes the objective is the emulation of legendary vintage hardware as Rev-Plate 140 (physical modeling of a plate reverb) or Chorus DimensionD (virtual analog).

https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Kevin-Arcas

Yes, it uses convolution, but only because the full model he developed would be too CPU heavy, so they found a way to come up with some kind of hybrid that they say is the next best thing after the model which he developed first and which they have fully working in-house. The convolution is based on their own model rather than being some IRs they got from a real plate.


You really ought consider to stop talking out of your arse one of these days. If you don't know enough about something just keeping your mouth shut is your best option. No amount of silence can make you ever look as pathetically wannabe-knowledgeable as your posts regularly do.

[whassup]

But does it sound like a plate?