Bob Geldof - A musical appreciation ...

Anything about MUSIC but doesn't fit into the forums above.
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

What with Sir Bob's comedy appearance in this month's Future Music mag ("F****G MACHINES" etc) and the reissue of the Boomtown Rats' best work, I thought it time to offer up some appreciation.

(I'll be surprised if anyone else on here concurs, but that's another story!)

Bob's magnificent work for Africa has paradoxically clouded his musical achievements, to a level where his whole musical credibility is based around THAT song. A great song of course, but for reasons of redemption, I'll skip it here. (If you don't know the song in question, good, lets' skip it)

The record shows: - Despite being a martyr to self effacement - Bob Geldof was a very good songwriter, and an excellent frontman of a great rock/pop band. For three years - 1977-1980, The Rats were THE top pop band in the UK. (Really). And hey, that was in the days when record sales really WERE significant!

Riding into town on the back of the New Wave movement, the Rats first hit the charts with 'Mary Of The 4th form', a punky abrasive tune that was the lead off single from their highly anticipated debut album.

That eponymously named first album was a class offering featuring incendiary, cleverly structured - and yet still, fundamentally pop - songs, such as 'Mary', 'Looking After No.1' and the seminal 'Joey', a tune that ranks among in my personal top 10 to this day.

Then came their best compiled work. 'Tonic For The Troops' was the first album I ever bought. An album loaded with excellent tracks, many of which were hit singles, the pick of the bunch being Bob's 'Born To Run' pastiche (juxtapositioned to the mean late 70s streets of Dublin) 'Rat Trap'. A great song, with a dynamic, mature structure/arrangement that puts the infantile contributions of today's chart hogging pop/rockers - McFly, Busted et al, to total and absolute shame.

I still recall Bob's TOTP appearance, when it hit number one .. miming that fab sax hook with a silver candelabra!

Patently a seasoned Dublin pub band, (they spent a few years doing covers) the Rats' musical merits shine all through these two recordings. The dynamics of the twin guitars, the unorthodox and quirky song arrangements, the cute harmonies, solid, catchy melodies and Johnny Fingers' lovely "icing sugar" piano swirls.

Live, also, they were brilliant. (If you could ever get in to see them that is) with two clever and manic guitarists, a solid rhythm section, a classically trained, pyjama clad keyboard player, all fronted by a crazy 8 foot tall punky Dubliner, with a penchant for falling off speaker stacks, playing dead ...then jumping up to sing the next verse.

The Rats had three years of critical and chart acclaim. Producing a half decent third album, before the New Romantics and their synths finally pushed them aside. (They produced the odd decent single later, but by that time no-one was listening)

I dug out 'Tonic' again recently and still found it to be an uplifting vibrant album, with the sound of real musicians, warts n all, playing great pop songs, all dirtied up on good old 2" analogue tape. (Yes, you can really HEAR it on this record) So, yeah, Bob was/is more than a 'saint' .... he was a F*****G inspiration, and ' tis about time that was recognised.
Cheers Bob!

Image
http://chrisamusic.bandcamp.com/
"It's square to be hip"

Post

I used to be in a band that covered "She's so modern" and "Nice and Neat".

My personal fave, though was "Go, Man, Go".


The Rats rocked in their day, no doubt about it.

Post

They were terrible.

Post

Here in the USA, I think they only had one hit song. I Don't Like Mondays, from the album The Fine Art of Surfacing. (I hope that wasn't the one you are wanting to avoid mentioning.) I liked that song well enough to seek out the album and order it. I'm probably the only person in my county that owns a copy of that album.

While you're listing his history, don't forget that Bob also played the lead role of "Pink", in Pink Floyd's movie The Wall. That was a real thrill to see in the theatre, with the large screen and over huge sound system. It's a pity that I've never made it to a Floyd concert. They were my absolute favorite band, when their album The Wall came out. It was certainly interesting to see Bob's version of In The Flesh? in that movie.


take care,
McLilith

Post

I'm with you Chris.
I think he's a decent bloke who's used his priveliged status to highlight a problem and it's left a lasting legacy.
He seems to be a loving and caring dad as well.

Basically, a regular guy with a heart. Rather that than some bling-draped poseur.

Post

nuffink wrote:They were terrible.
See, tht's just lazy. Everyone's entitled to their own opinion of course, but, maybe you could offer some reasons on why you think they were "terrible"?
http://chrisamusic.bandcamp.com/
"It's square to be hip"

Post

Manc Chris wrote:
nuffink wrote:They were terrible.
See, tht's just lazy. Everyone's entitled to their own opinion of course, but, maybe you could offer some reasons on why you think they were "terrible"?
They wrote cuntishly terrible songs and performed them like a bunch of no-talent c**ts. Add in uncle bob's reptillian personality ("OIM FOCKIN' ANGRY, ME!"), and that twat in pyjamas, and terrible is letting them off gently.
I assumed you were taking the piss, since I've never met anyone, let alone a musician, who admitted to liking them.
Glad to see you have the courage of your convictions.

Post

nuffink wrote:They wrote cuntishly terrible songs and performed them like a bunch of no-talent c**ts.
And that's them at their best.
Add in uncle bob's reptillian personality ("OIM FOCKIN' ANGRY, ME!"), and that twat in pyjamas, and terrible is letting them off gently.
Too true.
I assumed you were taking the piss, since I've never met anyone, let alone a musician, who admitted to liking them.
Ditto.
Glad to see you have the courage of your convictions.
I reckon people should be convicted for liking them.

Sorry Chris, but to my ears they were truly terrible.
RIP Black Tom and Beckett. They weren't just cats, they were MY cats, the best cats ever.

Post

nuffink wrote:
Manc Chris wrote:
nuffink wrote:They were terrible.
See, tht's just lazy. Everyone's entitled to their own opinion of course, but, maybe you could offer some reasons on why you think they were "terrible"?
They wrote cuntishly terrible songs and performed them like a bunch of no-talent c**ts. Add in uncle bob's reptillian personality ("OIM FOCKIN' ANGRY, ME!"), and that twat in pyjamas, and terrible is letting them off gently.
I assumed you were taking the piss, since I've never met anyone, let alone a musician, who admitted to liking them.
Glad to see you have the courage of your convictions.

Jesus, that's a bit over the top innit?

All bollocks too. I totally stand by my 'convictions' and you, in my opinion are wrong. Still, we all have different tastes eh?
http://chrisamusic.bandcamp.com/
"It's square to be hip"

Post

Manc Chris wrote:Jesus, that's a bit over the top innit?
Look up. Ian B wants to put you in jail for liking them.

Post

nuffink wrote:
Manc Chris wrote:Jesus, that's a bit over the top innit?
Look up. Ian B wants to put you in jail for liking them.
Whereas I would like to put YOU in jail for liking Britney Spears. See?
http://chrisamusic.bandcamp.com/
"It's square to be hip"

Post

:lol:

Post

nuffink wrote:
Manc Chris wrote:Jesus, that's a bit over the top innit?
Look up. Ian B wants to put you in jail for liking them.
You're wrong there nuffink, no jail would be involved. It would be a capital offence :hihi:
RIP Black Tom and Beckett. They weren't just cats, they were MY cats, the best cats ever.

Post

Ian B wrote:It would be a capital offence :hihi:
That's a bit harsh. Do you want to shoo, ooo-oo-oo, oo-oot. The whole day down?

Post

Ian B wrote:Sorry Chris, but to my ears they were truly terrible.
Maybe you should get some new ears then?
Maybe some platinum ears?


Oh no, that's been done already. :hihi:

Post Reply

Return to “Everything Else (Music related)”