Newbie question: Eradicating loop clicks
-
- KVRist
- 478 posts since 22 Nov, 2004 from Alexandria, VA
I'm brand new to sampling, and have been inspired by eXT to use it's built-in sampler.
Of course, I'm getting a nasty click with the loops in a sample I'm trying to create.
What's the trick with getting rid of these?
Many thanks,
Fox
Of course, I'm getting a nasty click with the loops in a sample I'm trying to create.
What's the trick with getting rid of these?
Many thanks,
Fox
-
- KVRAF
- 2495 posts since 18 May, 2004 from ATL-USA
The trick is cutting the loop at zero crossings. This means that you make your cuts where the wave is crossing over the middle line. You usually have to zoom in all the way!
I usually also add a small fadeout. You can sometimes get by with a small fadeout alone, but it is always better to take the time and cut at zero crossings (some hosts have snap enabled for zero crossing- not sure about ext though).
I usually also add a small fadeout. You can sometimes get by with a small fadeout alone, but it is always better to take the time and cut at zero crossings (some hosts have snap enabled for zero crossing- not sure about ext though).
Anti-aliasing is for "synthmonk%ys".
-
- KVRAF
- 2582 posts since 24 Apr, 2003 from Canada
The easiest way is to use an app that creates crossfaded loops (especially for stereo files which are nearly impossible otherwise). wavelab, soundforge, and some others do it...
-
- KVRist
- 465 posts since 13 Oct, 2002
If you feel like spending $40, Seamless Looper from Zero-X (http://www.beatcreator.com/) is very effective.
-
- KVRist
- Topic Starter
- 478 posts since 22 Nov, 2004 from Alexandria, VA
'Preciate the help. Seamless looper looks interesting.
-
- KVRist
- 64 posts since 16 Apr, 2005 from right here with red eyes
I just tried extreme sample convertor for this and it blew me away.
it allows you to drag perfect loop points very easy.
i have used a few apps but i need to test this more but at this point the ease of clean loops was impressive
crossfading in apps like soundfore only work on certain files . I would not crossfade unless you can't get a loop by normal methods. but yes crossfading is needed on some sounds.
Radjo
it allows you to drag perfect loop points very easy.
i have used a few apps but i need to test this more but at this point the ease of clean loops was impressive
crossfading in apps like soundfore only work on certain files . I would not crossfade unless you can't get a loop by normal methods. but yes crossfading is needed on some sounds.
Radjo
-
- KVRAF
- 3191 posts since 20 Sep, 2004 from Atlanta
Radjo wrote:I just tried extreme sample convertor for this and it blew me away.
it allows you to drag perfect loop points very easy.
i have used a few apps but i need to test this more but at this point the ease of clean loops was impressive...
ya know THAT's right
I've not tried them all, but ESC is pretty user friendly. I've started tagteaming SF with ESC and its pretty quik work to put together some sharp sounding loops...
-
- KVRist
- 333 posts since 2 Sep, 2003 from Brazil
Any discontinuity in the waveform can cause a click (or thump or whatever). Zero crossing can be part of the solution, but not always. Even if you use zero-crossing, differences in the wave inclination before/after the crossing will cause the click. That's why in general you should look for the most similar possible waveforms before/after your loop points (including amplitudes). Crossfading is a trick to mask discontinuities but sometimes results in objectionable side-effects.
Looping is not an easy task for some very common sounds like voices, strings, effected pads, etc. I've been using Zero-X SL with some good results; it is worth the price IMO but will not solve all your looping problems. I need to check ESC for this (I've been using it for convertion only - very good app).
Looping is not an easy task for some very common sounds like voices, strings, effected pads, etc. I've been using Zero-X SL with some good results; it is worth the price IMO but will not solve all your looping problems. I need to check ESC for this (I've been using it for convertion only - very good app).
-
- KVRer
- 24 posts since 24 Feb, 2006
I agree that all of the afore-mentioned are handy utilities, but imo these utilities should not be used to mask the fact that one is still learning how to make loops. In the long run, you will be much better off if you first learn/experiment building your loops yourself. Once you gain a more intuitive understanding of how looping artifacts are generated, what technique serves the loop under different circumstances, you'll be in far more control of your music than you will by simply chasing the latest utilities and throwing cash at them.
