A general rambling question about Sonar from a nonSonar user

Audio Plugin Hosts and other audio software applications discussion
Post Reply New Topic
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

I got e-mail from Cakewalk today about Sonar6. (I dunno how...I don't remember signing up for anything from them...)

Anyways...I actually quite liked the look of it. I thought I'd just get a little bit more info if for nothing else than personal interset, and, you never know, I might one day buy a second host just for a bit of choice. Also I get sick of the host slagging recently. I can appreciate something I don't use can't I? :roll:

Anyway...first off - I quite like the overall look of Sonar. The equivalent to the inspector thingy at the left. That looks like an improvement on Cubase to me. It seems to show pretty well all the things you need without all the extra clicking. I hope Cubase4 has headed in that direction (cos I'll be buying it soon).

The mixer...again, a nice look to it, although nothing radically different to almost any host really. Hourses for courses.

Then I clicked on the image on the first product page, and noticed the Vintage Channel thingummy. It say Kjaerhus on it (a very nice GUI too, by the way. I wish Cubase plugins went more for that type of GUI). It's got Eq, a comp and probably other things I missed. Is it a similar type of comp to GCO1, GUP1 and similar Eq to their GEq? Or is it a complete rewrite for Cakewalk. In fact...I went back just now to look, and saw the mid-side stuff and de-esser. Is it the GAC then? Seems like a very good tool to have.

Personally, I think having Kjaerhus licensed plugins in your host is a good selling point. Are there other Kjaerhus plugins included?
# AudioSnap™ Multitrack Audio Quantize

# AudioSnap suite of tools includes:

* Non-destructive audio quantize
* Lock multiple tracks into the same groove
* Apply seamless tempo changes to audio
* Convert audio beats to MIDI
* Slip-stretch clips to a new time or length
* High-quality time stretching algorithms including iZotope Radius™, Percussion Mode, more
Weeeell...most of that stuff I've already got access to, but the fact they've introduced audio to midi can't be anything but good. TBH, it's little things like that that could possibly make me buy it. (I'm not getting into any stupid either/or host war here...if I actually considered it, it would be more to use it as an external audio editor, mangler, fiddle-about-with-things app that I then transfer back to my more familiar surroundings to construct a song with).

From the look of most of the new features, there's nothing there that's make me want to swap from Cubase to Sonar, but sometimes, a different way of making the building blocks adds to inspiration. I suspect I could happily play around in that environment.

So...what other plugins are in there that might interest me? (I know that's a vague question that nobody but me could know the answer to...)...so more like, what plugins interest you that use Sonar?

And apart from that...simply...well done Cakewalk. It looks nice. I probably will continue happily using SX2 until I get C4, but it's good to see how well some other devs make their hosts, as well.

Any other specific points of difference that I might not know about? (As I said, most of the features are already in Cubase, but there are probably others not mentioned on the blurb page...there was a "customer requested" full feature list - but I certainly don't want to sign up for other spam from Cakewalk).


Oh...one other thing. Is there a demo? I used Cakewalk Pro Audio 8 or 9 (can't remember which) that came as a freebie with my soundcard a few years back. I like some, disliked some. But I got to know it reasonably well. But...one thing that stuck in my memory was how bloody difficult it was when I got rid of it and upgraded to SX2. I found Cakewalk stuff littered around the registry and hidden all over the place. It took several registry cleaners to clear it when I moved on. If I loaded a demo, that is a concern. Have they streamlined their uninstall stuff (although I suppose that's a moot question...if you're a loyal Sonar user, you won't have uninstalled it, eh? :dog: )


So general queries only really. I just wanted a thread to exist from a non-user to show appreciation. And I seriously would consider having 2 hosts to play around in. For a while I had the demo of Tracktion1 on my DAW and I very nearly bought it. At the time there were some specific benefits that Cubase didn't have, but somehow, Tracktion just didn't click with me...probably more to do with what I saw as midi-weakness I suppose, and a GUI that really turned inspiration off in me.

How much is Sonar6 from new, anyway? If it's the price of Cubase...weeeeeeell, that'd be one extravagance too far probably.
But even on a plugin count - if I include the synths, the Kjaerhus plugin, maybe other FX etc that I'd want...it might be a cost-effective way of buying more plugins, and as a bonus, things like audio->midi (which I still miss in Cubase).


Sorry for the ramble. :?

Post

I'll try to provide some insight:

Only one Kjaerhaus plugin unfortunately. Its only a new GUI for cakewalk , but is equivalent to the GAC-1 (channel insert w/ compressor). Other plugs are the Psyn 2 synth, REX player, Pentagon 1, and some Roland GM stuff. There is also Pristine Space convolution reverb (very nice).

The newest features that I find worthy that may be unique are:

1. ACT Active Controller Technology - lets you make presets so one control surface can instantly be mapped to any soft synths or sequencer parameters controls without reassigning any controls.

2. Color Customization - almost everything in Sonar is able to be colored the way you want.

3. Menu customizeable - All drop down menus including the main application menus and right click menus can be customized to show only what you decide.

4. Toolbar customization - All toolbars can show only the buttons you decide.

5. Isotope Radius time stretch (300$ by itself) is a very nice algorithm set for stretching audio with or without pitch shifting.


The rest is mostly stuff thats small or has been around in previous versions or that I know every host probably has, although there are a ton of small workflow features that are new that may be unique too. The price for new customers is pretty high for the producer version (which has all the bells and whistles). IF you are a previous registered Cakewalk customer there is a discount, and again if you own a previous version of Sonar. Upgrades cost 99$-199$ a year depending on options for a previous Sonar owner, so once you buy in its pretty cheap.

Hope thats useful info. I for one cannot afford to maintain 2 hosts at this time :(

EDIT: On price, I think if you buy a cheap Cakewalk product like music creator (don't know what it does and don't care for this purpose) at around 30 US$, you can buy into Sonar 6 producer as an upgrade for 349 US$ extra.

D.

Post

Sonar 6 doesn't appear to have a demo out yet. The Sonar 5 demo is available at http://www.cakewalk.com/Support/kb/kb2005298.asp but that probably doesn't help you right now.

You can also snoop the Sonar forum at http://forum.cakewalk.com/tt.asp?forumid=5

Doug
Logic is a pretty flower that smells bad - Spock, in "I, Mudd"

For a good time click http://www.belindabedekovic.com/video_fl_en.htm

Post

Well, that's all useful stuff so far. Thanks.
5. Isotope Radius time stretch (300$ by itself) is a very nice algorithm set for stretching audio with or without pitch shifting.
That's useful info...I've not heard the Isotope time stretch, but I probably should check it out. The algorithms in Cubase are good, but from a perfectionist point of view, I wouldn't choose to use any of them for precision stuff. Last time I time stretched a fairly straight forward drumloop (only by 4 or 5%)...overall it sounded OK, but in the fine detail, I just wasn't happy with the bass end - everything got kind of boxy at the bottom, although the mids and tops were fine and dandy. The whole thing somehow needed tuning after I'd stretched - the bass started to become too prominent (and almost "musical" if that's the right word) in the 90-130Hz range. It wouldn't fit in with musical channels unless I tuned it up or down... :?

So that is a plus that might help make it worthwhile.

And the other tip about buying a cheap Cakewalk product and cross-grading to Sonar. That's a good idea. I'll check it out.


And...no demo. A shame, but I suppose I should be used to that - none with Steinberg at all... :( . I can demo Sonar5. Is 5 that much different from 6 (at least in terms of general workflow and looks? It should give me a general idea I presume.

Post

kritikon wrote: And...no demo.
Yet. There will be one.
Is 5 that much different from 6 (at least in terms of general workflow and looks? It should give me a general idea I presume.
The big difference 'obvious' differences (for most plugin users anyways) I think would be the new Synth Rack and ACT controller stuff. They kind of replace the old functionality (rather than supplant it the way AudioSnap does).
An idiot on Set Theory:
"In some cases there is an object called red that contains everything that is red. In much the same way a pot is a plate."

Post

Is there some side-by-side comparison chart between different versions of Sonar (producer and studio), as there is one between Sonar Studio and ProTools LE? I can't seem to find one anywhere in Sonar's pages, and I have had too little sleep to go through each product's page and make the chart myself :? :wink:
If you can't beat your computer at chess, try kick-boxing.

Post

cimoc ; there's a page of 'Producer Only' features

http://www.cakewalk.com/Products/SONAR/Exclusives.asp
An idiot on Set Theory:
"In some cases there is an object called red that contains everything that is red. In much the same way a pot is a plate."

Post

Checking now... thanks a lot!
If you can't beat your computer at chess, try kick-boxing.

Post

Hi Kritikon

I think it makes good sense to have more than one main app, it gives you so much more in options, I guess it's expensive at first but once you are able to upgrade it can be very cost effective.

I've found Cakewalk to give more "Bang per buck" since I joined them with Sonar 2 and never upgraded Cubase since VST to SX2 and always gone for Sonar upgrades, I've waited for Cubase 4 to come out for comparison and find again for me Sonar 6 has the edge….. In the future things can change and maybe it will be Steiny's turn to get my cash with Cubase 5.

If you shop around you are able to get some great cross-grade deals.

Post Reply

Return to “Hosts & Applications (Sequencers, DAWs, Audio Editors, etc.)”