Some Chord Progression Stuff

Chords, scales, harmony, melody, etc.
Post Reply New Topic
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

Hi there,

As the original thread got somewhat convoluted (even if it does have some nice information in it, you can still find it here), I thought I'd start with a fresh one.

However, here's the original question.
No name wrote:Ok, I haven't really yet understood still how to really use chords in music. Suppose I should get into that some time :hihi: :roll: :lol: . Anyways, what I propose we do here is simple, and will help many folks.

Give an example of a chord progression. Note which Key you are in, which progressions you use, and then make a small snippet of music using the progression. I think this would help a lot of us grasp how to implement chords into their music.

So any takers?
Ok, a bit late, but let's see.
First off: You're asking how to implement chord progressions into your music. The answer is: You don't!
No, stop! Of course you do, but you may not start like that. Let's have a look at the "typical" songwriter approach - I'm not saying you should be working as a typical songwriter, but the approach is making much sense, at least IMO.
It's usually like this: At one point in time, you may pick up a guitar and some friend will show you the most essential chords in open position. Then you just fool around with them, probably playing a bunch of wellknown songs that are all written using nothing else but those rather simple chords (and believe me, there's tons of them). All of a sudden a nice melody/hook might come to your mind, and there's your tune.
Yes, when fooling around with those chords without playing any tune, there's quite some trial and error involved. But that's all fine! A lot of great tunes are written using just that very trial and error approach.
And, even if I'm not a "native" piano/keyboard player at all, I assume it's rather similar on those instruments. You may just start to fool arond with the white keys only.

However, to give you more of a trial and less of an error approach, it might be good to know a few fundamentals. These include (note that this is a personal list, nothing of global value):
- Which notes are in a given scale/tonality.
- How to build the "basic" chords using nothing else but notes of that given tonality.
- How to actually play those chords and their inversions.
- How to probably "expand" these chords, by using "color" (or "option") notes.

In addition, it's really a great thing to know about intervals. Their names and things such as "how many halftones are involved in a major 3rd". Believe me, it makes communication a LOT easier.

I won't concentrate too much on all these, you can find some good information in other threads on this very theory forum. JumpingJackFlashs introduction to music theory is an excellent source to get back to, should you have any problems with understanding certain theoretical terms.
And you may of course just ask, in case something's unclear.

Alright, for a start, I'd like to cover a few things about the major scale and the chords involved.
A major scale is always build like this:

1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - j7 - 8 (which is the octave, with that things start to repeat)

Now, this, by itself, doesn't tell you much, if anything. If you already know intervals, it should tell you something already, though. However, let's fill this up with concrete note names, for a start, in the key of C (even if I sort of hate to always use that key).

C - D - E - F - G - A - B - C

As you may see, that's all the white keys on your piano/keyboard. Or in your piano roll.
It is, however, a great idea to not only remember this scale as "oh, all white keys" but rather stick to the "formula" behind it, which is why I wrote that one down first. After all, you want to be able to play in all keys.
The formula given is using standard interval names, so you may really want to look them up.
Another way to remember whatever scales structure is to keep the involved steps from one note to the next in mind.
In case of our major scale (which is what we'll be dealing with for now), it's:

1 + WT = 2 + WT = 3 + HT = 4 + WT = 5 + WT = 6 + WT = j7 + HT = 8

WT = wholetone (two halftone steps)
HT = halftone (one halftone step)

Please note: Interval "indexes" aren't consistent throughout all styles, so you may, for instance, find 3+ and 3- for major and minor thirds. You may as well find M3 or m3 instead. The approach I'm using is indexing them as they will be indexed in a chord symbol, so a major third gets no additional indexing whereas the minor third will get a 3min.
The same goes for chord symbols and their representations using capital roman numbers. I will stick to the system most jazz/rock/pop musicians agree upon, which might at some places be known as the Berklee system. And which is as well what you'll find in things such as the "New Realbook".
Unfoertunately, there's still no general, worldwide agreement on this, but I find the system I'm using to be rather accurate and easy to understand.

Ok, please, if something is unclear so far, don't hesitate to ask - or look things up in other threads of this theory forum.
Fwiw, you may also want to download the ravenspiralguide, which is a really good read on these basic subjects:
http://www.ravenspiral.com/ravenspiralguide.pdf

Ok, on to chord building.
Now, all the fuzz about scales and intervals - why?
Because that's the raw material our most often used chord progressions will build upon. In case we don't use any other material but the notes from one scale (or better: in one key), we call things "diatonic" (= strictly part of a given key). Those diatonic chord progressions are the main thing you'll find in the sort of music most of us western folks should be familiar with.
There's styles going further away from it, there's heavily modulating (going from one key to another) music and whatever, but most of what we are familiar with is usually based on diatonic chord progressions. So that's what I will concentrate on. And that's also why one should really know the notes of a given key/scale.

In general, chord building inside a scale/key is really easy. You can build up a chord on any degree of a scale. And the basic principle behind it is easy as well: You just take any note of a given scale and put other notes on top of it in thirds (that's one of the reasons why you should be familiar with intervals...). In praxis, this means that you take a note and build up using every other note.
For instance, in the key of C, our C chord would be like: C - (skip D) - E - (skip F) - G.
C-E-G being the resulting chord.
This principle is open to expansion. We could add further thirds on top of it - even until we're using all the notes of the given key. For our C chord, it could look like this:
C-E-G-B-D-F-A
Before you head over to your keyboard to try this, stop! It usually doesn't make much sense to use all notes of a given key on one chord. In fact, it would even sound weird (there's something called "forbidden" notes - don't take that literally, but stick to it for a start).
What we usually stick to in "general chord building" is the first 3 or 4 steps. Even if this is a blatant generalisation, a lot of classical music is based on 3 part chords, whereas a lot of jazz/pop stuff is based on 4 part chords. At least the theoretical principles behind them are (so, that doesn't mean you couldn't just use any chord in any style - just the explanations behind things are a bit different).
Once it comes to actual examples, I will stick to the 4 part system and its possible extensions. Oh well, I will actually start with 3 part examples...

Anyways, once we expand our 3 part chord to a 4 part one, our C chord in the key of C would look like this:
C-E-G-B

Note: The four parts of our chord so far are called: root, third, fifth and seventh. They are often described by numbers: 1, 3, 5, 7.
In case we don't use the 7th, the chord is a plain triad. Whether you'll be using triads or 7th chords is largely depending on the style you're after.
In addition, as briefly shown above, the principle of putting further notes (in 3rd intervals) on top of what we already have, can be expanded, so we would have to deal with 9ths, 11ths and 13ths as well. But we won't do that just now.
For most explanatory things, triads or 7th chords are doing a sufficient job.

Now, the next thing we can (and should) do is to analyze the resulting chord.
It's got a major 3rd and a major 7th in it, so it's a Cmaj7 chord.

Then, the next thing to proceed with is doing the same for all available notes of our scale.
So we may just build a chord on the D. Following our "skip every other note" formula, it'd look like:
D-F-A-C
When analyzing it, we will find out that it has a minor 3rd and a minor 7th. So the chord name is Dmin7.
A note: I *should* probably explain the nomenclature of chord namings right now ("why is the min 3 mentioned in the chord symbol?", "why does the major 7 have an index?", "how comes only the flatted 5th is mentioned in a chord symbol?" - things like that), but as said, you will most likely find the explanation elsewhere. If you look at whatever explanation of intervals, things will defenitely become a lot more clear. I don't want this post to become more of a monster than what it already appears to become.
In addition, some things might as well become a lot more understandable once I post some examples.

Ok, let's proceed with our diatonic chords. We would now do the same thing for each note in our scale. In the key of C we would end up with a list like this:

C-E-G-B = Cmaj7
D-F-A-C = Dmin7
E-G-B-D = Emin7
F-A-C-E = Fmaj7
G-B-D-F = G7
A-C-E-G = Amin7
B-D-F-A = Bmin7/b5

As we don't want to stick to the key of C for the rest of our lives, just as with whatever scale formula, it's a nice idea to put this into a more formulaic pattern as well. Which would be like:

Imaj7
IImin7
IIImin7
IVmaj7
V7
VImin7
VIImin7/b5

Ok, I will make a break with the explanatory stuff here and start with some "practical advice".
What is all that stuff so far good for?
Well, we do now have a picture of what sort of chords to use in a given key. Sure, for now it's just major keys, but a whole lot of these things also apply to minor keys - I'd say that around 90% of minor key progressions can easily be treated as "derivatives" from major keys.

Alright, what to do now? A few things:

1) Learn to play (or program) the various chords. You may want to start with triads (3 part voicings, leaving out the 7ths) instead of going for the full 4 part thing instantly. The reason being that they're easier to figure out on most instruments and that their sound is probably more "clear" as well.

2) Try to play all those triads in all three "inversions". In case you don't know what inversions are, it's really no biggie, you just arrange the 3 notes differently. So, our C triad in socalled root position would be "C-E-G". The first inversion would bring the C on top, so it'd be "E-G-C". Second inversion would then be "G-C-E". These inversions are extremely important when it comes to chord progressions, as you most likely want to avoid larger jumps.

As an example: Let's assume we want to move from a C to an F.
The C in root position would be "C-E-G", the F in root position would be "F-A-C". Going from one chord to the other would require a 5 halftone jump. Sure, we can do that, but very often it just won't sound too well. So, instead of just jumping around, we would probably still use the C in root position, but take a look of what would be the closest F inversion. As there's even a common note (the C), our closest F inversion would be "C-F-A", which would be the second inversion. Actually, you don't even have to know which inversion is which, as soon as you know the notes in whatever chord, you can just try to achieve the smallest possible movements between two chords.


3) Play "random" diatonic triads. The only rule here: Stick to one key.
Make sure you check out all possible inversions, so there's minimal movement between the individual voicings.

4) Repeat steps 1-3 with 4 part voicings. This is going to be more tricky. Some inversions won't sound as good as others, you need one more finger, the notes in whatever chord are harder to remember and the sound will probably not be as clear.


I will end this post here and proceed with the next one in a bit, hopefully showing some of the most often used chord progressions that can be covered with what we have so far (I already have some examples ready but need to bounce them down and export the MIDI files).

Oh, and sorry for the rather lengthy explanatory stuff, you may not necessarily need all that, but I thought I should write it down as some sort of quick'n'dirty reference.
Last edited by Sascha Franck on Wed Feb 28, 2007 3:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.
There are 3 kinds of people:
Those who can do maths and those who can't.

Post

Good one, Sascha.

Post

Sascha, respect! Very useful info.

o.

Post

Overflow wrote:Sascha, respect! Very useful info.

o.
Yes thankyou.

The other thread did have some good stuff but I kind of got lost reading the other "bits".

I enjoyed both however ;)

Nev
I span the genres, they call me the genre spanner.

Post

:tu: It was very kind of you to do this! I thought all of your information was very clear and concise. My problem now is that, for some reason i'm noticing that when people describe chords in a given key, they never do the minor keys. I understand that major is easier because it is all white keys, but i'm not so sure what to do when it comes to the whites and blacks. I read on musictheory.net about chords in a minor key, and while I can understand it pretty much, all the terminology I see just drowns me and I get lost. I can't think of any off the top of my head, but I devote myself to reading during all the free time I have, but shopping around for info from different sites on the net causes me a lot of confusion due to the fact that everyone uses different ways to describe the same thing. I'll explain where i'm stuck at right now at this point.

I'll sit down at my keyboard and i'll use chords. It literally stops right there and i'm left playing something boring, like I,IV,V (in the key of C) so it just doesn't sound good, it sounds boring. I don't really know where to go from there to be honest, and then I hear people talking about how you can do endless things with that progression. It baffles me how you could get so much variety out of that. I'm just confused on the nature of chords really, do they all have to be played at the same time, or do they always have to be just arpeggios and block chords, how do you "imply" a chord? I read up on harmony too, and they keep saying to look at the music in vertically. It's all quite a lot to take on, especially when i'm still trying to figure out how chord progressions in minor keys work.

There are just bits and pieces i'm missing, and it holds me back because they are necessary pieces.
"You are going to let the fear of poverty govern your life and your reward will be that you will eat, but you will not live."

Post

I really need to practice more too, especially inversions. I don't know why I never practice inversions as much as I need too. Usually when I practice I get caught up on trying to play "fur elise" at least once without destroying it :Lol: I'm bound to get it all right eventually though! I keep messing up and practicing and practicing (though i'm getting better!) on it, and I tend to drift off there. Would you say that perhaps buying sheet music of some more famous pop/rock tunes would help me? By playing, and analysing the music(which is another thing I should be doing more often)?
"You are going to let the fear of poverty govern your life and your reward will be that you will eat, but you will not live."

Post

No name wrote::tu: It was very kind of you to do this! I thought all of your information was very clear and concise. My problem now is that, for some reason i'm noticing that when people describe chords in a given key, they never do the minor keys.
[...]
There are just bits and pieces i'm missing, and it holds me back because they are necessary pieces.
Please give me a bit of time. Yes, almost business as usual, I will indeed proceed with some major key examples, but I sort of promise that it will defenitely help you with minor progressions as well. Besides, there's some of the most often used minor progressions already contained in our major scale "environment".

I just thought it would be kind of logical to start with the easier elements at first. And as said, understanding them *will* get you into minor progressions a lot quicker.
I'm afraid that for now (well, for the next few posts), you will have to stick with some folk-ish major stuff :shock:
There are 3 kinds of people:
Those who can do maths and those who can't.

Post

No name wrote:Would you say that perhaps buying sheet music of some more famous pop/rock tunes would help me? By playing, and analysing the music(which is another thing I should be doing more often)?
I'm not sure. Really, unfortunately, I think you gotta decide by yourself.
Personally, I never spent much time playing and analyzing others tunes (until I was sort of forced to, during studying and playing in cover bands), but some people swear by it.
There are 3 kinds of people:
Those who can do maths and those who can't.

Post

Maybe i'm just trying too absorb too much too fast here. I know this stuff takes time, but it's hard not to rush it sometimes, because there is usually other things on down the line you want to learn, but you have to walk before you run though. I'm going to practice with the major some mor eint he mean time as you suggested.
"You are going to let the fear of poverty govern your life and your reward will be that you will eat, but you will not live."

Post

No name wrote:Maybe i'm just trying too absorb too much too fast here. I know this stuff takes time, but it's hard not to rush it sometimes, because there is usually other things on down the line you want to learn, but you have to walk before you run though. I'm going to practice with the major some mor eint he mean time as you suggested.
Keep going. It'll all fall into place with a rush at some point. Then it'll have been worth the struggle.
Image
Now with improved MIDI jitter!

Post

No name wrote:for some reason i'm noticing that when people describe chords in a given key, they never do the minor keys. I understand that major is easier because it is all white keys, but i'm not so sure what to do when it comes to the whites and blacks.
To keep things simple: stick to the white keys and use A as the root/tonic instead of C. That's a standard minor scale.

If you come across a certain key in the scale you don't like, just try weather any adjacent black one is any better. Et voila: you have a personal scale. Note down the intervals and you can look up the proper name of that scale.

NB: pentatonic scales (consist of only five notes) are very usefull also, e.g. A C D E G A. Excellent to play blues riffs etc. Other notes get used in the chords, but you have the tendancy to get back to these five notes.
We are the KVR collective. Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated. Image
My MusicCalc is served over https!!

Post

No name wrote:Maybe i'm just trying too absorb too much too fast here. I know this stuff takes time, but it's hard not to rush it sometimes, because there is usually other things on down the line you want to learn, but you have to walk before you run though. I'm going to practice with the major some mor eint he mean time as you suggested.
I find this book quite useful, for me anyways:

How to Write Songs on Keyboards: A Complete Course by Rikky Rooksby

I hear some good things about one or two other books of his.

Nev :)
I span the genres, they call me the genre spanner.

Post

Good job. :tu:

Post

Nev wrote:
No name wrote:Maybe i'm just trying too absorb too much too fast here. I know this stuff takes time, but it's hard not to rush it sometimes, because there is usually other things on down the line you want to learn, but you have to walk before you run though. I'm going to practice with the major some mor eint he mean time as you suggested.
I find this book quite useful, for me anyways:

How to Write Songs on Keyboards: A Complete Course by Rikky Rooksby

I hear some good things about one or two other books of his.

Nev :)
This is the second time someone has mentioned this book, maybe i'll look it up and see what it has. Thanks.

Speaking of creating my own personal chords..here is something I just missed with that sounds excellent to my ears.

I'll use numbers to show which chords I hit first.

1.A,C,E
2.G,B,D
3.F,A,C
4.E,G#,B

It's all major until I get up to that last one, and i'm not sure why it leads back to I so well, but it sounds wonderful to my ears. I know it is a major chord.
"You are going to let the fear of poverty govern your life and your reward will be that you will eat, but you will not live."

Post

No name wrote:
Nev wrote:
No name wrote:Maybe i'm just trying too absorb too much too fast here. I know this stuff takes time, but it's hard not to rush it sometimes, because there is usually other things on down the line you want to learn, but you have to walk before you run though. I'm going to practice with the major some mor eint he mean time as you suggested.
I find this book quite useful, for me anyways:

How to Write Songs on Keyboards: A Complete Course by Rikky Rooksby

I hear some good things about one or two other books of his.

Nev :)
This is the second time someone has mentioned this book, maybe i'll look it up and see what it has. Thanks.

Speaking of creating my own personal chords..here is something I just missed with that sounds excellent to my ears.

I'll use numbers to show which chords I hit first.

1.A,C,E
2.G,B,D
3.F,A,C
4.E,G#,B

It's all major until I get up to that last one, and i'm not sure why it leads back to I so well, but it sounds wonderful to my ears. I know it is a major chord.
Yeah it's quite good. It's pop/rock based but obviously it can be applied to other genres. Their is also a guitar based version which is supposed to be ok as well.

On a side note I bought the Melody book too, and to be honest no where near as helpful for me.

I also find nutchords and both the chordsapces quite useful for playing with and working things out, oh and the scale and chord plugins in Live6 make it (too) easy for me as well.

I really need to do what your doing and sit down and play, play,play. I salute you sir for sticking at it. :)

Nev
I span the genres, they call me the genre spanner.

Post Reply

Return to “Music Theory”