Well, I'm not Torgo, but I'll take a crack at your question and then he can chime in next time he's here. (We need a bump back to the first page anyway.)scatman84 wrote: One particular thing which nobody has yet touched in terms of Free sounds is Guitars ! Both Acoustic and electric......
I am a keyboardist.....so I am always after realistic Guitar samples...So has anybody tried SR's Guitar samplTank Expansions ? both Acoustic and electric ? Are they worth spending the 2 'Bonus' product coupons ?
Torgo, what do you have to say about Guitar Expansions ?
Thanks !
I have both of the Xpansions from last year's group buy. I'm a guitar player, so I don't use them a whole lot, but I bought them to use in places where I want some kind of a melodic line that I can't play myself (I'm definitely more of a rhythm player than a lead guitar player - no Eddie van Halen solos here!). You get a lot of variety in the kinds of sounds offered, and if you're skilled at programming your parts in the SampleTank interface (something I'm still working on) you can get some nice sounds through layering different guitars together on the same channel. The electric guitar libraries respond really well to the built-in effects, as well as running them through amp sims like Amplitube and Guitar Rig.
These have the same limitations that most guitar libraries do - how realistic your parts end up being depends a lot on how you program and play the parts. If you're looking to recreate a Steve Vai solo electric guitar piece then you'll probably have better luck with a Kontakt library that uses extensive scripting, like the Orange Tree sample sets. But if you're looking for something to use to layer parts to sit in a mix and doesn't take up a lot of memory they do the job nicely.
In my opinion, they're both solid libraries - not flashy (although in the hands a more skilled programmer than me they could be!), but good, solid bread-and-butter libraries. I'm not sure what else you have in terms of guitar samples, but I think given the price they're a good deal.
