Resolving Minor Progressions

Chords, scales, harmony, melody, etc.
Post Reply New Topic
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

I've had always a soft spot for Minor Harmony/Progressions, but resolving them can be a pain in the arse :D

I'm always looking for better/different ways of resolving minor progs, and this is what i have come up with so far (using Am as an example) ...

Em - Am (v - i)
Has a charm to it but sounds weak as piss.

E7 - Am (V7 - i)
Always "works" for obvious reasons but every man and their dog knows what is coming.

Dm - Am (iv - i)
Plagal, has a nice haunting ring to it but can sound very weak.

D7 - Am (IV - i)
Sounds too "sunny" and "Santana" for my tastes, i rarely use it.

G#dim7 - Am (#VIIdim7 - i)
Has the same effect as example 2, although can sound a bit "spicier".
Using the other 3 subs makes no real difference (Bdim/Ddim/Fdim)

G7 - Am (VII7 - i)
Sounds "primitive", but still sweet. Enigma did this with "Sadness" way back when IIRC.
I particularly like to use it following VI ie FMaj - G7 - Am - Am, but this eventually will want to resolve to its relative Major ie CMaj, which then "steals" the key because it is "stronger".

Bb7 - Am (bII7 - i)
Sounds either Phrygian, or "Jazzy" (b5 sub), depending on context



Another weird one i pinched from Bach:

Bm - C#m - Am - Am

The Bm is the v/V, and the C#m is the relative of V7, so its easy to see why it works, even though its chromatic.



Does anyone have any other weird wacky ways of resolving minor keys?
I need a few new tricks :D
Prestissimo in Moto Perpetuo

Post

Bb/A E7sus4 Am (the suspension is deliberately not resolved)
Bm11 E7 Am
Bm7b5/F E7sus4 E7 Am
Fadd9 D7/E E Am
C/D Em7 Am7
C/D F/G Am7
Dm7 Em7 Am7
C|E7 Bb|E7 Am7 (polychords - C|E7 = play C major over E7)
Bb9 Cadd9/E Em7 Am
Am/E Fdim/E Ebdim/E E7 Am
Bm7 Dm Esus4 E Am

Post

Nice :)

E7sus4 - Am is a surprise. I cant believe i never thought of that.
Making it E7sus4/A - Am (or even Esus4/A - Am) gives it a nice "modal" quality.

Your 4th example reminds me of this old chestnut:

F - D7/F# - G - E7/G# - Am


I also like the sound of F/G - Am ... never plugged that one in before.
Prestissimo in Moto Perpetuo

Post

Cat Stevens in "Sitting"

D - F - Am

Old Version:

New version:

Post

Melkor wrote:I've had always a soft spot for Minor Harmony/Progressions, but resolving them can be a pain in the arse :D

I'm always looking for better/different ways of resolving minor progs, and this is what i have come up with so far (using Am as an example) ...

Em - Am (v - i)
Has a charm to it but sounds weak as piss.

E7 - Am (V7 - i)
Always "works" for obvious reasons but every man and their dog knows what is coming.

Dm - Am (iv - i)
Plagal, has a nice haunting ring to it but can sound very weak.

D7 - Am (IV - i)
Sounds too "sunny" and "Santana" for my tastes, i rarely use it.

G#dim7 - Am (#VIIdim7 - i)
Has the same effect as example 2, although can sound a bit "spicier".
Using the other 3 subs makes no real difference (Bdim/Ddim/Fdim)

G7 - Am (VII7 - i)
Sounds "primitive", but still sweet. Enigma did this with "Sadness" way back when IIRC.
I particularly like to use it following VI ie FMaj - G7 - Am - Am, but this eventually will want to resolve to its relative Major ie CMaj, which then "steals" the key because it is "stronger".

Bb7 - Am (bII7 - i)
Sounds either Phrygian, or "Jazzy" (b5 sub), depending on context



Another weird one i pinched from Bach:

Bm - C#m - Am - Am

The Bm is the v/V, and the C#m is the relative of V7, so its easy to see why it works, even though its chromatic.



Does anyone have any other weird wacky ways of resolving minor keys?
I need a few new tricks :D

Im going to have a play with these later, thanks.
Aspiring Producer of Deep/Tech House

Check out my original music and random mixes here - https://soundcloud.com/paul-harris-42

Post

Ahh these look like chord substitutions

Em --- Am

This could be expanded by going

Em F#/ Bm/ E7/ Am

I added a modulation in the middle by using dorian mode.


Em G7 C Bm Bb7 Am

This modulates to C in the middle and then steps down to Am

There are an infinite array of ways. Much of this is modal too I guess. Take the chord you're starting on and put it into different modes and see where that takes you. Modal Jazz baby

Post

Everything in context.

One doesn't have to justify melody to harmony. Reaching outside the key boundaries can open up dissonant tensions. One can move either from dissonance melodically to connoissance. Or Consonance to dissonance. If you are always afraid of breaking some rule your music will quickly become boring to you. Explore the expressive (meter, dynamics, timing) and don't be afraid to color outside the lines.
Dell Vostro i9 64GB Ram Windows 11 Pro, Cubase, Bitwig, Mixcraft Guitar Pod Go, Linntrument Nektar P1, Novation Launchpad

Post Reply

Return to “Music Theory”