Technically, the Beat-thing is a "Zampler RX sample set". But what bothers me is that it's from a well established Magazine and that they have the catch phrase "want more, get our mag".metamorphosis wrote:Agreed, as per the competition rules, these two entries should be discarded.Compyfox wrote:So many cool tools with this years Developer Challenge.
HOWEVER... two things stand out to me that kind of annoy me:
1) why is the BEAT Magazine part of the challenge with a sample set for their BEAT OWN Zampler, and why do they write "more on their magazine discs"?! This feels kind of like a slap in the face. Especially if they'll get into the top tiers.
2) Not that I don't like stuff by Wavesfactory, but wasn't there a Kontakt freebie years ago from whomever that did exactly that?!
In fact - it was from Wavesfactory themselves! viewtopic.php?t=380147
Your entry must be an original creation made by you (your team / crew / company / family). Of course you may reuse code / modules / development frameworks, but the actual plug-in / application / sound library should be a new, original creation, not just an obviously cut-down subset of a program you have already written.
m@
And the Wavesfactory thing was previously released as Kontakt sampleset only. To this is a custom VSTi this time around. Think of BPB's "Clap" collection which is also available in pure sample form and VSTi. So that (the Snare Buzz VSTi) is a grey zone. But still not cool to revive a 5 year old thing as "challenge entry"
Thing is - we can criticize it - but I don't think that these two things won't be discarded/disqualified. Hooray for rules and fair price distribution (another thing that kind of annoys me with this year's challenge).
