Except the fewer controls something has, the easier it is. It's why I hesitated to get The Legend. I couldn't help think "Who would buy libraries for something with 3 oscillators, a filter and not a lot else?"spacekid wrote:The thing is that it still takes designing with sounds to put together the multis. You just aren't going from a wide open synth and designing from scratch..selecting and molding those selections with what you are given is still sound design...you're just being a bit of a purist and forgetting that everything, even purist synths, have their limitations..this one just has different limitations. Just because it doesn't pass the synth purist test, doesn't mean it's bad.wagtunes wrote:Well, then in that case, we might as well just call anything that has a filter and an LFO a synth and call it a day. Problem is, with so loose a definition, it doesn't really help somebody who may come here for synth recommendations for a "traditional" VA, wavetable, granular or whatever synth. We might as well, at that point, just toss in Nexus and any other "playback engine" into the mix as long as it has some kind of control over the sound and isn't just static like playing back a piano sample that can't be changed at all.Teksonik wrote:You guys are simply not getting it....there are things you can do with Syntronik that you can't do with a MiniMoog......like make it sound like an SY-99.wagtunes wrote: Except, and I'll take the simplest example I can come up with, given the actual Minimoog and Syntronik's Minimoog, there are things you can do on the real one that you simply can't do with Syntronik's because the controls aren't there. End of story.![]()
Stop focusing on what it can't do and embrace what it can do. I'm making some great patches using it's 4 OSCs (Layers) and a little bit of creativity........(some of that is needed).![]()
Is this the most powerful synth in existence ? Of course not but like I said it's tons of fun and capable of a surprising range of sounds that will expand if IK ever releases more Instruments.
These were never advertised as 1:1 Emulations although I'd love to get 1:1 Emulations of all those synths for $70.
But if I come here saying I am looking for a new "synth" that I can design a sound library for because programming the synth takes some skill and not everybody wants to spend the time to do that, are you really going to throw Syntronik into that mix and recommend I get it? I mean do you really think I could sell even ONE Syntronik library?
So we have to have some way of making distinctions or this all becomes meaningless.
Especially to sound designers.
But son of a gun. Out of 48 released libraries, it's my 12th best selling one. Shocked the hell out of me. But still, it's considered a traditional synth and maybe that, and the fact that it's a legit Minimoog emulation makes the difference.
Probably, to prove my point, I should have gotten Syntronik for the prerelease price, made a library for it, put it up for sale, and watched how NOBODY bough the library given that all you can really do is combine layers in different ways.
Doesn't necessarily prove whether it's a synth or not, but certainly, for my purposes anyway, would have proved that getting it would have been a total waste of money from a business standpoint.

