Tonic chord at 5th bar (tried adjacent position - no change) is not imported,
but other chord is...
(Not such problem dropping in Waveform, FL Studio, or Sekaiju midi editor)
EDIT: It was late when I discovered this, but went back this am. It happens dragging the mid file of that progression. So here that is to test with.
Sundog Drag drop weird Error
-
musicdevelopments musicdevelopments https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=223336 - KVRAF
- 6014 posts since 9 Jan, 2010
You are right. But the way chord analysis works I see the reason why this happened. The 'chord' before the 5th bar is not a real chord, it consists of only F#3, C#4, F#4. The program does not assign 2-note chords, so it joined the notes with notes in the next container to form a sensible chord (III6).
I think a special 'chord import' mode has to be added which does not try to do all sorts of combinations with the notes just like for real phrases to guess the chord; when notes explicitly describe the chords, just like in this case.
Thanks,
Attila
I think a special 'chord import' mode has to be added which does not try to do all sorts of combinations with the notes just like for real phrases to guess the chord; when notes explicitly describe the chords, just like in this case.Thanks,
Attila