Granular Elements library is awesome!
It's the most useful of any libraries that came along with a granular synth so far imo. I love it!
Granular Elements library is awesome!
From 2016... Interesting to see how the synths have evolved during the years (some more than the others).fmr wrote: Tue Oct 04, 2016 6:21 pmWhat's the competition? Let's see:chk071 wrote:What's the competition? I see Avenger. Nexus won't count, as it doesn't feature a fully-fledged synthesis section.Spitfire31 wrote: Personally, I might be tempted at $149, max. Pay another 100 bucks on top? No way. There's plenty of competition around and it's likely to increase.
UVI Falcon (this actually is no competitor - it kills any competition)
Waldorf Nave
Synapse DUNE 2
Tone 2 Icarus
Wolfgang Palm synths
NI Massive
Xfer Serum
Waves Codex
I think we can also include Blue II, to be fair, although this one isn't exactly a wavetable synth.
And if you go for just the EDM sounds, then this list grows exponentially. I don't even count Avenger because it still doesn't exist, but that's another absurdly priced synth.
The conclusions drawn here might warrant some further consultation by a lawyer before you rush into a court (and I am not one, so this is certainly not legal advice, just a layman interpretation). The ECJ case in question was about Oracle seeking an order against UsedSoft. The court concluded that due to first sale doctrine, such a request is invalid: UsedSoft can continue to do whatever it was doing.the.new.me wrote: Sun Sep 20, 2020 2:14 pm it's not my business, don't care, but that EU LAWS can force software company to transfer the licence is a fact and no need to dislike me because of that, dislike EU for that![]()
This.mystran wrote: Mon Sep 21, 2020 1:55 pmAs a layman, I have no idea if any subsequent rulings by any given court have clarified the issue, so please seek legal advice. I just want to point out the dangers of drawing too many conclusions beyond what was explicitly stated in the ruling.
It's the same with Amazon and Steam. So tell me, why all of these mega corporations with branches within the EU do not allow license transfers? Linking the UsedSoft decision from 2012, which is a very different case compared to the current matter, is clearly not suited to clarify the issue. Follow the trials related to Steam and you see why!https://support.image-line.com/action/k ... se?ans=105
[...]
Apple, Google and Microsoft do not allow the transfer of App purchases between customer accounts in the EU, or anywhere world-wide. We believe the situation is similar to our case as Apps are sold with Lifetime Free Updates. The sale of a lifetime updated app directly impacts on the developers ability to maintain their income, since there is no chance of upgrade purchases.
Thanks. Glad to hear that!collider wrote: Sun Sep 20, 2020 2:32 pmGranular Elements library is awesome!
It's the most useful of any libraries that came along with a granular synth so far imo. I love it!
![]()
And you aren't amauter when you know nothing yourselfstarflakeprj wrote: Mon Sep 21, 2020 3:49 pm Yeah, I'm so tired of these amateurs pointing out, every now and then, that it's illegal not to allow license trsnsfers within the EU, when they know nothing. It's impossible to compare the cases as a layman, or even as an individual lawyer.
I don't know if they are only stupid, or just trying to threat in some way (probably stupid).
Anyway, @Parawave, just keep it clear in your EULA, and make the EULA available for reading on your site, and don't mind the imbecills complaining.
About big companies: steam actually was ruled to allow, but as all things with a law are not that easy, valve appealed. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.engadg ... esold.htmlparawave wrote: Mon Sep 21, 2020 2:46 pmThis.mystran wrote: Mon Sep 21, 2020 1:55 pmAs a layman, I have no idea if any subsequent rulings by any given court have clarified the issue, so please seek legal advice. I just want to point out the dangers of drawing too many conclusions beyond what was explicitly stated in the ruling.
As we all are not laywers, making any final judgements is hardly possible.
The situation is not as clear as you might think.
We take the same stance as Image Line. They have this nice summary:It's the same with Amazon and Steam. So tell me, why all of these mega corporations with branches within the EU do not allow license transfers? Linking the UsedSoft decision from 2012, which is a very different case compared to the current matter, is clearly not suited to clarify the issue. Follow the trials related to Steam and you see why!https://support.image-line.com/action/k ... se?ans=105
[...]
Apple, Google and Microsoft do not allow the transfer of App purchases between customer accounts in the EU, or anywhere world-wide. We believe the situation is similar to our case as Apps are sold with Lifetime Free Updates. The sale of a lifetime updated app directly impacts on the developers ability to maintain their income, since there is no chance of upgrade purchases.
Can we put aside the topic?
Thanks. Glad to hear that!collider wrote: Sun Sep 20, 2020 2:32 pmGranular Elements library is awesome!
It's the most useful of any libraries that came along with a granular synth so far imo. I love it!
![]()
Still as a layman, I took a very quick look at the actual ruling (not all of it though, it's 74 pages) using Google translate and it doesn't seem obvious at all whether the situation is similar enough to draw any conclusions whatsoever (except maybe in terms of some specific T&C clauses being ruled invalid, but anyone living in EU knows that the consumer rights are pretty strong when it comes to such things), because the case seems to be at least partially about Valve placing restrictions on what can be sold and when on the marketplace that it already operates. What else it might be about, I don't know.the.new.me wrote: Mon Sep 21, 2020 4:01 pm About big companies: steam actually was ruled to allow, but as all things with a law are not that easy, valve appealed. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.engadg ... esold.html
Actually there are not really any 'EU' laws, only 'Directives', each member state country is 'directed' to make certain things a law in their own country through there own legal system. For example, in the UK something is only law if a 'Statutory Instrument' is passed, the EU cant make it law and impose it on the UK.the.new.me wrote: Sun Sep 20, 2020 2:14 pm it's not my business, don't care, but that EU LAWS can force software company to transfer the licence is a fact and no need to dislike me because of that, dislike EU for that![]()

I can't speak for Omnisphere, as I've never tried it, but Rapid is very differently structured compared to ANA2.5Lives wrote: Fri Sep 25, 2020 4:19 pm If I already have Ana 2 and Omnisphere (multi-layer wavetable synths), what will Rapid bring to the table for me? In the demo, I like the OSC FX options, which is something different from the other two, but what else?
I have Omnisphere, I find Rapid far easier to build a patch that has 8 'interacting' layers (feed fx through from one layer to another etc). I like the granular in rapid, again, one of the easiest to use and hard to get a bad sound. Rapid is just a joy to patch- and it looks better than Omnisphere. Don't get me wrong, I love Omnisphere, but I tend to tweak pre-sets rather than program from scratch...rapid I could (and wanted to) dive in and make from 'Init'5Lives wrote: Fri Sep 25, 2020 4:19 pm If I already have Ana 2 and Omnisphere (multi-layer wavetable synths), what will Rapid bring to the table for me? In the demo, I like the OSC FX options, which is something different from the other two, but what else?
Submit: News, Plugins, Hosts & Apps | Advertise @ KVR | Developer Account | About KVR / Contact Us | Privacy Statement
© KVR Audio, Inc. 2000-2026