Pashkuli: PMN (Plain Music Notation)

[Pashkuli]

Well, when this happens I take some time to figure out what's happening and try to understand how that was written. So thanks for pointing out where it comes from

Does not help at all. Clarinet line by itself seems ok. A bit amateurish but ok.
Piano is absolute self-indulgent wanking. Sounds out of context, gibberish.

[shawshawraw]

Does not help at all. Clarinet line by itself seems ok. A bit amateurish but ok.
Piano is absolute self-indulgent wanking. Sounds out of context, gibberish.

Who wanted to help?? Drama in your head??

[vurt]

Well, when this happens I take some time to figure out what's happening and try to understand how that was written. So thanks for pointing out where it comes from

Does not help at all. Clarinet line by itself seems ok. A bit amateurish but ok.
Piano is absolute self-indulgent wanking. Sounds out of context, gibberish.

not a fan then?

[Erisian]

Piano is absolute self-indulgent wanking. Sounds out of context, gibberish.

Projection!

[Synthack]

Well, when this happens I take some time to figure out what's happening and try to understand how that was written. So thanks for pointing out where it comes from

Does not help at all. Clarinet line by itself seems ok. A bit amateurish but ok.
Piano is absolute self-indulgent wanking. Sounds out of context, gibberish.

Honestly i'd much rather play a piano with it's simply CDEFGAB keys than learn your "genius" system.

I think at this point you are pretty much just here to troll people who don't agree with you.

[Pashkuli]

Who wanted to help?? Drama in your head??

The audio, I mean. Does not help much to get it written as it is written but in my score software.
I use MuseScore, Notion 6 and Overture. Even with some image to score recognition it gives dumb results. Those double sharp with additional sharp = 3 sharp.
This is idiotic, honestly.
It does not help me recreate it in a score program.

[Pashkuli]

Honestly i'd much rather play a piano with it's simply CDEFGAB keys than learn your "genius" system.

I think at this point you are pretty much just here to troll people who don't agree with you.

Agree about what? There is nothing to agree. It is all in plain sight.
Do not forget to throw away the black keys. Black keys do not matter.

My system is not genius. It is plain and simple. Some say this (plain and simple) is the hallmark of being genius.
Your CDEFGAB is special case, one sided, favouring and imposed system.

[Synthack]

Honestly i'd much rather play a piano with it's simply CDEFGAB keys than learn your "genius" system.

I think at this point you are pretty much just here to troll people who don't agree with you.

Do not forget to throw away the black keys. Black keys do not matter.

My system is not genius. It is plain and simple. Some say this (plain and simple) is the hallmark of being genius.
Your CDEFGAB is special case, one sided, favouring and imposed system.

Honestly i hope your system fails.

I'll be taking the time honored tradition of learning music the way Mozart learned and his contemporaries. In fact you're arrogance has encourged me now more than ever to learn regular music theory and the piano.

[shawshawraw]

The audio, I mean.

This I agree. The piano recording was too drowned in reverb while this piece demands clarity.

3 sharps is inevitable to represent that embellishment. I'm not a fan either but once it's understood it's understood. And F#/Gb is the most difficult key on keys anyways. (unless playing rhythm!! )

[Erisian]

Honestly i hope your system fails.

It will. That's guaranteed.

[Pashkuli]

Honestly i hope your system fails.

If you think you will be alive to see it getting momentum... that is not going to happen.
It will be re-discovered probably at the end of this century, maybe early next century.
We won't be alive.

[Pashkuli]

The audio, I mean.

This I agree. The piano recording was too drowned in reverb while this piece demands clarity.

3 sharps is inevitable to represent that embellishment. And F#/Gb is the most difficult key on keys anyways. (unless playing rhythm!! )

Difficult to play on a standard piano or difficult to write\read as a score key signature?

[shawshawraw]

Difficult to play on a standard piano or difficult to write\read as a score key signature?

Difficult to jam with friends!!

[Pashkuli]

Anyone willing to help?
No matter how I try to fit a note\rest... the last low bar is always incomplete?
And how do I even insert a sharp next to a double sharp already present?
This "standard music notation" is such a joke.

Max Reger - incomplete.jpg

here is the original from screenshot (scanned .pdf)

Max Reger - ORIGINAL.jpg

[Pashkuli]

Just found another "masterpiece" of standard music notation from a gibberish "opus" of this individual...
Johann Maximilian Reger, commonly known as Max Reger – German composer and academic teacher. He was a musical director at the Leipzig University Church, as a professor at the Royal Conservatory in Leipzig, and as a music director at the court of Duke Georg II of Saxe-Meiningen.

Right...
Imagine a person like myself having to apply for a new music notation to such a representative of the music education authority. Waste of time. Expectedly his music is not even close to become mediocre.
But is abundant with accidentals, so he must be super well musically educated. Right...

Max Reger - Symphonic Fantasia.jpg