You're right, my bad; I read this in a rush and just saw "executable binary" minus the "component" part.
But it's really here nor there regarding what appeared to be your original claim that Kontakt and/or things used inside it are "expansion libraries" and not plugins. Kontakt is indeed a plugin, as are the instruments used within it.
You also said an orchestral library "isn't a plugin unless it also comes with its own executable binary component that runs inside a host environment." Hello, that describes most if not all orchestral libraries. Again some may have a stand-alone version and so technically not a "plugin," but since you're talking about the same app, is often loosely referred to as such.
Typical reaction by someone who can't handle someone challenging their assertions. "You disagree with me...so you're a troll!" How lame.Nevertheless, judging by the threads you are starting, this is also starting to look like trolling.
Nope.Broader term? You've (most likely intentionally) got this backwards.
Not sure I follow what you're saying, or you think I'm trying to say, so I'll try once more, using examples:Yes, there are also other plugins than virtual instruments , but in the context you are framing this in, a "virtual instrument" is a term that can be used of a plugin itself, or it can be something like a set of samples and a bit of structural description, intended to be used as input data in something that executes, reads that structure, and plays back the data in a controlled fashion. And so on.
- Valhalla Vintage Verb: plugin.
- Native Instruments Massive synth: plugin.
- Spitfire Albion One: plugin.
- Kontakt: plugin.
- Collection of sfz sound files: not a plugin.
Don't look now but you're doing the same thing. Enjoy hypocrisy much?Also, ask yourself, is this really relevant to the actual thread? Why are you pursuing this line of thought so intently?
I've started a thread or two that were obviously (to most at least) just joking around and having some fun. God forbid every thread not be some intense discussion. Maybe the question you should be asking is why are you wound so tight? Maybe you need to get out more?Why are you, at the same time, starting those weird no-value threads? Don't you think all that sort of posting does is mostly just adding noise?
That all said, you're right that this is sidetracking the topic so my bad there as well.
I've spent about $200-300 total on plugins over the years. That includes Kontakt. Luckily I got into this just as plugins were getting both a lot better and a lot cheaper (mostly). I've really been on a "let's see what's out there and what it can do" mission for years and just starting to get out of the exploration phase mostly and more into narrowing down what I want to use and learning them more.