Maybe there is a way to fix the AI problem!? (Let's talk about how we can handle this sh*t)
Anything about MUSIC but doesn't fit into the forums above.
Moderator: KVR Moderators (Main)
Maybe there is a way to fix the AI problem!? (Let's talk about how we can handle this sh*t)
2025-10-26T06:51:36+00:00
Ok, so I've been having a hard time seeing what AI can do (especially the generative and transformative kind like SUNO).
And I got really frustrated and depressed over the outcome of IT being pretty decent till good over time, and having to compete against it, if not now, then in the future.
I started becoming depressed because it's becoming harder and harder to tell what's AI and what's not.
And so I started looking in the first major entertainment industry that fell victim to robots/AI: chess.
Every chess player in the world knows they can't beat Stockfisch. And so they use it as a training tool and learning resource.
And truth is, that people still watch tournaments because they root for people and the thrill of seeing their favourite player win or lose by a mistake.
And so I started thinking what is really bugging us all in the first place:
It's that companies make money from our work, using our music as training data for their business without our consent!
But that also gives us a solution to the problem: treating training data like samples/session musicians.
And what I mean by that is using "Band-in-a-Box" as an example.
For those that don't know, "Band-in-a-box" is an automatic, flexible backing track creator using pre-programmed and pre-recorded files by session musicians (they hired them).
But the short drift aside. Here's my idea:
Let's have generative AI companies flag the data used in a song and make prompters agree to be responsible for properly crediting them (as data songwriters/data session musicians ?) or pay the data originators a buyout sum (similar to ghostwriters or ghostproducers, etc.).
That way, everyone responsible gets paid more fairly and has more oversight over their art and what's done with it.
Plus, that way we get the rights to stop certain productions and songs that use our stuff for songs we don't agree with.
So what are your ideas and thoughts about it?
(I actually tried to send SUNO an email to suggest this to them, but I have no hope that it will reach them...)
PS. This is a repost since I accidentally posted it in "Getting Started"
Starbright
https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=398679
- GRRRRRRR!
- 17690 posts since 14 Jun, 2001 from Somewhere you're not!
- Contact:
- addled muppet weed
- 111238 posts since 26 Jan, 2003 from through the looking glass
- Contact:
Return to “Everything Else (Music related)”
Jump to
- The Main Forums
- ↳ KVR Studio Manager
- ↳ Getting Started (AKA What is the best...?)
- ↳ Instruments
- ↳ Effects
- ↳ Hosts & Applications (Sequencers, DAWs, Audio Editors, etc.)
- ↳ Guitars
- ↳ Mobile Apps and Hardware
- ↳ Soundware
- ↳ Samplers, Sampling & Sample Libraries
- ↳ Hardware (Instruments and Effects)
- ↳ Modular Synthesis
- ↳ Sound Design
- ↳ Production Techniques
- ↳ Music Theory
- ↳ Computer Setup and System Configuration
- ↳ DSP and Plugin Development
- ↳ DIY: Build it and they will come
- ↳ Music Cafe
- ↳ Sell & Buy (+Special Offers, Deals & Promos)
- ↳ KVR Experts
- ↳ KVR Developer Challenge 2023
- ↳ Everything Else (Music related)
- ↳ Off Topic
- ↳ Off Topic Classics
- ↳ Machine Learning and AI for Music Creation
- Official Company Forums
- ↳ 2getheraudio
- ↳ accSone
- ↳ Acon Digital
- ↳ AcousticsampleS
- ↳ AcousModules
- ↳ Agitated State
- ↳ AIR Music Technology
- ↳ AMG
- ↳ Ample Sound
- ↳ Antares Audio Technologies
- ↳ Apisonic Labs
- ↳ APU Software
- ↳ apulSoft
- ↳ AriesCode
- ↳ Arts Acoustic
- ↳ Arturia
- ↳ Audjoo
- ↳ AudioSpillage
- ↳ Audiority
- ↳ Best Service
- ↳ Big Tick
- ↳ Bitwig
- ↳ Controller Scripting
- ↳ Blue Cat Audio
- ↳ Cherry Audio
- ↳ CWITEC
- ↳ Embertone
- ↳ energyXT
- ↳ Eventide
- ↳ Expert Sleepers
- ↳ forward audio
- ↳ Future Audio Workshop
- ↳ FXpansion
- ↳ g200kg
- ↳ Harrison Mixbus
- ↳ HG Fortune
- ↳ Homegrown Sounds
- ↳ HoRNet Plugins
- ↳ Ilya Efimov Production
- ↳ Image Line
- ↳ Impact Soundworks
- ↳ Indiginus
- ↳ Insert Piz Here
- ↳ Ju-X
- ↳ Kirk Hunter Studios
- ↳ Kirnu
- ↳ Kong Audio
- ↳ Krotos
- ↳ Kuassa
- ↳ KV331 Audio
- ↳ LennarDigital
- ↳ Les Productions Zvon
- ↳ Liqube Audio
- ↳ Loomer
- ↳ LVC-Audio
- ↳ Maizesoft
- ↳ Manytone Music
- ↳ Media Overkill (MOK)
- ↳ MeldaProduction
- ↳ Mellowmuse
- ↳ MIDIMood
- ↳ moForte
- ↳ Mozaic Beats
- ↳ mucoder
- ↳ MusicDevelopments
- ↳ Tips & Tricks
- ↳ MusicLab
- ↳ MuTools
- ↳ New Sonic Arts
- ↳ NUSofting
- ↳ Oli Larkin Plugins
- ↳ Orange Tree Samples
- ↳ patchpool
- ↳ Photosounder
- ↳ PlugInGuru
- ↳ Polyverse Music
- ↳ Precisionsound
- ↳ Premier Sound Factory
- ↳ Psychic Modulation
- ↳ Realitone
- ↳ Resonance-Sound
- ↳ Reveal Sound
- ↳ Roger Linn Design
- ↳ rs-met
- ↳ S3A: Spatial Audio
- ↳ SaschArt
- ↳ Smart Electronix
- ↳ sonible
- ↳ SonicBirth
- ↳ Sonic Reality / eSoundz.com
- ↳ Soundiron
- ↳ SPC Plugins
- ↳ Sugar Bytes
- ↳ TAL Software
- ↳ Tokyo Dawn Labs
- ↳ Tracktion
- ↳ Tweakbench
- ↳ u-he
- ↳ u-he Linux support
- ↳ UJAM
- ↳ United Plugins
- ↳ VAZ Synths
- ↳ Virharmonic
- ↳ xoxos
- ↳ XSRDO - SynthCraft
- ↳ ZynAddSubFX
- Site Stuff
- ↳ Site Stuff
- Archived Forums
- ↳ AlgoMusic
- ↳ easytoolz
- ↳ Elevayta
- ↳ Hollow Sun
- ↳ LinPlug
- ↳ Muse Research and Development
- ↳ Shuriken
- ↳ SoHa Sound Design
- ↳ Soniccouture
- ↳ Topten Software
- ↳ Valhalla DSP
- ↳ CK Modules & VST
- ↳ Sennheiser AMBEO
- ↳ Muon Software
- ↳ Westgatesounds.net
- ↳ Squaredheads
- ↳ Sonigen
- ↳ CFA-Sound
- ↳ Back In Time Records
- ↳ Livelab.dk
- ↳ Skytopia
- ↳ audioD3CK
- ↳ Inspire Audio
- ↳ Krakli
- ↳ Drumdrops
- ↳ Futucraft
- ↳ OverTone DSP
- ↳ RaXnTraX
- ↳ solar3d-software
- ↳ Signaldust
- ↳ Soundemote
- ↳ ReleaseLab (Powered by Artist Expansion)
- ↳ Wolfgang Palm
- KVR Forum index
- All times are UTC
- Delete cookies