SUNO is killer!

[Tiles]

None of the examples would qualify as good.

But they’re all considered good enough, and apparently that’s all that’s needed.

Good is highly subjective anyways. AI-generated music will never please anyone who is fundamentally against AI.

If you get a user error rate of 100 %, maybe the tool is the problem, not the user...

Maybe it’s not the one-click solution everyone is dreaming of. AI still requires you to do your homework, which is why I’m not worried in the slightest. You will still need a musician to make music, even with AI. It just lowers the barriers a bit, much like Music Maker did before, or the introduction of digital DAWs, or the invention of VST instruments.

[ghettosynth]

As expected, no demonstration. Because you're shitting your pants.

[D-Fusion]

[martinjuenke]

I'm still waiting for that killer track. Where is the sheriff?

[martinjuenke]

As expected, no demonstration. Because you're shitting your pants.

[martinjuenke]

As expected, no demonstration. Because you're shitting your pants.

You still don't get it. Do you think that we can't hear the artifacts? You can clearly hear the vocal artifacts in the yodeling track that I posted. It's one of the areas where there are current limitations. It also manifests quite clearly in other rapid large interval shifts in instruments. Suno is not going to replace professional production in most contexts any time soon.

However, that is not what defines its utility to the general public. You sound exactly like the naysayers when MP3s were first coming out. There can really be no debate that uncompressed audio sounds better than low bitrate MP3. That didn't, at the time, stop consumers from listening to low bitrate MP3s.

People are listening to AI music, and they don't care about you, your opinion, or your experience. They don't care what you think about the music or the composition. Only BONES is making any case that he thinks that it's good enough for his music and he is being quite transparent about his own limitations.

So, who are you yelling at? Who do you think is sitting around asking "I hope Zeisner thinks that this is good?"

You're asking the wrong question. Here's the right question for this community. Which of your tracks has over three million plays? If the answer is none, then an AI generated track with only the lyrics "cat cat cat..." is more popular than your music.

Now, maybe you don't care about popularity. That's of course fine, I certainly don't. But, if you think that you're in the "music industry" and that people should "pay you" to make music, then, in fact, you do care about popularity whether you can admit it or not.

Your response to anything is predictable. You hide behind claimed expertise that is not present in the work that you post with noise and bluster, yes, I'm also talking about your "invention." You poopoo anything that you don't like, so nobody expects an honest evaluation from you and they won't post just to fuel your ego. The lack of response isn't because people are shitting their pants, it's because your opinion is being dismissed as that of a troll.

Well said.

[VitaminD]

This explains why it produces more acceptable results. I'm impressed with lyrical phrasing and arrangement on my limited time with it. Instruments have a soft transient almost mushy sound though.

[seangm]

Suno is filler

[ghettosynth]

Suno is filler

It absolutely is, like the overwhelming majority of human produced music.

[seangm]

Suno is filler

It absolutely is, like the overwhelming majority of human produced music.

Not going to argue with you there, most of what I come up with is

[vurt]

Suno is filler

It absolutely is, like the overwhelming majority of human produced music.

as a non human entity, i concur.

[martinjuenke]

Suno is filler

It absolutely is, like the overwhelming majority of human produced music.

as a non human entity, i concur.

The amount of posts you've made is a strong indication that your're an ai bot.

[ghettosynth]

Suno is filler

It absolutely is, like the overwhelming majority of human produced music.

as a non human entity, i concur.

The amount of posts you've made is a strong indication that your're an ai bot.

With THC receptors. Don't ask me about the engineering, that's above my pay grade.

[ghettosynth]

Zicky Zicky is back with a new forum tribute.

[ksandvik]

Some like writing music like filling in spreadsheets...