Hey, glad you tried the MelAI plugin as well, but this tool is still in pre-alpha phase and in development, so it is expected to be very buggy for now. I do think you have a great idea in combining both tool altough.tatanka wrote: Wed Feb 18, 2026 10:51 pmHi, sorry, no discord here and it seems you have no mail contact as far as I could see.arsenaultk9 wrote: Wed Feb 18, 2026 10:20 pmHey tatanka, I have a Discord channel if you ever need direct assistance here: https://discord.gg/ruPXc9aaDutatanka wrote: Wed Feb 18, 2026 8:12 am EDIT: one time it worked, then again now several attempts and it did NOT work, no idea whats different.
Setup: midi clip on a track, midihumanizer behind it, hit play in the daw, then when clip is finished and drag and drop is blue I drag it to the track, 9/10 with same velocity, in 1/10 velocity is humanized
I am not sure if I miss something, but I play a midi file into the plugin, drag and drop the result and the velocity still is on one level, nothing changed
Do I have to record the played and humanized midi directly from/in my daw, does it not work automatically INSIDE the plugin (that would be very unpleasant) ? Or does it maybe dont work with the demo ?
Otherwise, from what I can understand of your post, here is some info that might help you:
1. You have to play the MIDI segment in your DAW for the MIDI humanizer to take effect. It does not work directly with MIDI files or MIDI tracks in your DAW. So it can be cumbersome, but until the ARA specification works with MIDI, there's no equivalent to Melodyne track awareness for MIDI
2. For 1/10 of the midi only being humanized, it can be a combination of factors.
a) Are your beats only on the quarter and half notes? Then that's normal. This isn't a randomizer, but it takes into consideration beat position for humanization to take effect
b) Is the MidiHumanizer before the VST Instrument? This is important!
c) Is the whole track you're trying to humanize being played in the DAW before you drag it?
If I misunderstood you, don't hesitate to reply or come talk to me on discord where we will be able to trade screenshots, and I can help you in semi-real time.
I have played round with it a little more using mainly midi clips (does not seem to work with it), melodya midi generation tool (works best so far) and your melody AI tool (does not work cause you cant make it start playing from the daw, dragged midi clip does not work as any midi clip, cant drag it into the midi humanizer).
What would of course be great if combination of your two tools would work together in a way (start the playing of the melody AI from the daw or get it into Midi humanizer in some way) or, of course the general best solution if it could work on any simple midi clip played in/from the daw.
To be honest: as all sequencers/generative tools (like hamony bloom, stepic, chord progression generators......) I use have at least randomisation of velocity it would really only make sense for me if it could work on any midi clip produced in whatever way and played into midi humanizer directly from clip in daw.
Or, as I said: would be smart if your two tools could work together
Also, I don't have an email I'd like to share, but if you'd like assistance, could you send screenshots or clips to show me what's going on? That way I'd be in a better position to help you. You can send a private message if privacy is your concern.
, will be putting this up higher on my to-do list.
