Inadvertent Theft

Chords, scales, harmony, melody, etc.
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

vurt wrote:i once inadvertantly stole a ferrari :oops:
I know what you mean. One day I accidently had inappropriate relations with a squirrel.

Post

Presumably if this happens it means you've got writers block? Time to take a break methinks!

Post

yellowfever wrote:Presumably if this happens it means you've got writers block? Time to take a break methinks!
Well, I haven't noticed a correlation with writer's block. It happened a couple of times on my current project where I've felt like I'm in the groove.

It is kind of frightening to think everything I write is actually incidental music from some episode of Gilligan's Island I saw in 1967.

:-o

Post

I had someone accuse me of stealing a melody when it was my own, I know it was my own too for a fact.
my music: http://www.alexcooperusa.com
"It's hard to be humble, when you're as great as I am." Muhammad Ali

Post

How about inadvertent borrowing instead?
We escape the trap of our own subjectivity by
perceiving neither black nor white but shades of grey

Post

eduardo_b wrote:How about inadvertent borrowing instead?
you try telling the judge that :cry:
:ud:

Post

eduardo_b wrote:How about inadvertent borrowing instead?
[Igor]A great composer steals, the lesser composer borrows.[/Stravinsky]

Post

vurt wrote:
eduardo_b wrote:How about inadvertent borrowing instead?
you try telling the judge that :cry:
But your honor! I thought I was borrowing my cousin's Datsun! How was I know to know it was't across town locked in someone else's garage?
noise and beats: Negutyv Xeiro do people actually click these?
gearlust: Roland JP-8000, too much/not enough eurorack
machinecode by: u-he, Bitwig, Fabfilter, NI, et al

Post

Inadvertent theft, borrowing, whatever you want to call it, happens all the time in the Arts. Luckily for most of us it mostly only becomes an issue for those who are successful. In their case as someone already pointed out, there is usually quite a bit of forgiveness, especially if they are indeed talented and deemed to be creative artists.

Charlie Chaplin reportedly once woke up in the middle of the night and in a moment of creative inspiration composed Jose Padilla Sanchez' "La Violetera" which ended up as one of the main themes for his movie "City Lights". Given his popularity and the worldwide success of what is sometimes considered his best film, it was highly unlikely that no one would notice. Yet that didn't ruin his career nor the reputation of the wonderful film. I guess you gotta be careful, though, about anything that's done as a result of the inspiration coming from dreams. Perhaps that's also true about ideas that come to us when we are under the influence of certain substances. :hihi:

Post

ATS wrote:I had someone accuse me of stealing a melody when it was my own, I know it was my own too for a fact.
you're John Fogerty aren't you?

i knew it!! :o

Post

jancivil wrote:
eduardo_b wrote:How about inadvertent borrowing instead?
[Igor]A great composer steals, the lesser composer borrows.[/Stravinsky]
its weird how many people quote that without actually understanding the difference or that it doesnt mean "wholesale copying of the greats" ;)
:ud:

Post

Apparently every musical phrase had been used a few centuries ago and we all just regurgitate stuff that's already been written and forgotten with time. I don't know whether that would hold up in court though. Can't be as bad as 'ice ice baby' though can it? really? You must be really under pressure.

Apparently 32% of statistics are made up. Apparently an inconclusive conclusion is the only true conlusion because uncertainty is the only certainty. Certainly.

John

Post

audiosabre wrote:Apparently every musical phrase had been used a few centuries ago and we all just regurgitate stuff that's already been written and forgotten with time. I don't know whether that would hold up in court though. Can't be as bad as 'ice ice baby' though can it? really? You must be really under pressure.

Apparently 32% of statistics are made up. Apparently an inconclusive conclusion is the only true conlusion because uncertainty is the only certainty. Certainly.

John
I forgive your unintelligable reply because of the rhinestone-studded swankiness of your handle: audiosabre. Yeah!

Post

Aroused by JarJar wrote:I forgive your unintelligable reply because of the rhinestone-studded swankiness of your handle: audiosabre. Yeah!
LOL, how very kind of you, sir :D

John

Post

jancivil wrote:[Igor]A great composer steals, the lesser composer borrows.[/Stravinsky]
By that logic Andrew Lloyd Webber is a great composer... :scared:

Post Reply

Return to “Music Theory”