I don't disagree one bit. It's got to be demoralizing. But there is a growing number that, while we feel bad for the demoralizing situation, see time after time where businesses have left people without the ability to use their purchased products. If there was a third-party escrow-type company that developers could work with that would provide perpetual keys for software after the business is gone, there would be little concern over challenge/response authentication. Challenge/response authentication has become quite seamless these days--some developers have even taken to calling their software "Serial number" or "Keyfile" authorization, because the rest of the process has become automatic. The problem is, that is quite deceptive, since the root of the problem is not resolved:Uncle E wrote: Thu Sep 19, 2024 12:22 am As true as that all is, it’s got to be demoralizing on their end. They’re the good guys, offering a lot for nearly free. A better world would reward that behavior.
One should be able to take the software installer and serial/keyfile off of a backup drive and be able to install and authenticate the software on a new machine--even after the company is gone.
Once developers have figured out how to solve the above problem while still keeping the crackers from releasing it for free, then the problem will be solved. Like I said, most paying users don't mind the authentication, as long as it doesn't punish the honest more than the pirates.
