White noise reverb idea ...
-
- KVRian
- 769 posts since 2 Apr, 2005
This might just be a really dumb idea, but I would like to know if anything exists already, or if this would work ...
Seems to me that some reverbs and white noise have a lot in common. You can use samples of white noise in a convolution reverb.
Imagine a reverb plugin that functions rather like a compressor side chain. Imagine an incoming sound, like a snare drum. This would create an envelope similar in shape to the snare sound, and with controlable Attack, Threshold, Ratio and Release.
Then - imagine this is used to control two freerunning white noise generators. Two for stereo. EQ or filters to shape the sound.
I suspect this would sound remarkably like a dense smooth reverb, and might be very musical. Especially if the frequency spectrum was also factored into the envelope control. Maybe like a multiband compressor.
Been done?
Seems to me that some reverbs and white noise have a lot in common. You can use samples of white noise in a convolution reverb.
Imagine a reverb plugin that functions rather like a compressor side chain. Imagine an incoming sound, like a snare drum. This would create an envelope similar in shape to the snare sound, and with controlable Attack, Threshold, Ratio and Release.
Then - imagine this is used to control two freerunning white noise generators. Two for stereo. EQ or filters to shape the sound.
I suspect this would sound remarkably like a dense smooth reverb, and might be very musical. Especially if the frequency spectrum was also factored into the envelope control. Maybe like a multiband compressor.
Been done?
-
- KVRAF
- 12235 posts since 18 Aug, 2003
I'm not sure I follow. Excluding the sidechain gating try this: Load a simple synth with a white noise generator. Adjust the ADSR, filter to taste and hit a key.
Here's what it sounds like. I was just using xhip with the oscs turned off.
The resultant sound will be the exact same as your experiment, the only difference would be that instead of an internal envelope generator, you'd be using an envelope follower.
Is there more to it?
Here's what it sounds like. I was just using xhip with the oscs turned off.
The resultant sound will be the exact same as your experiment, the only difference would be that instead of an internal envelope generator, you'd be using an envelope follower.
Is there more to it?
-
- KVRAF
- 12235 posts since 18 Aug, 2003
Regarding frequency affecting the envelope, here's a demo I made of the Audio Damage 907a filterbank a while back. It's just white noise and the filterbands automated.
Kind of what you had in mind? If so, it's a fairly common technique in sound synthesis.
Kind of what you had in mind? If so, it's a fairly common technique in sound synthesis.
-
timo at artsacoustic timo at artsacoustic https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=69547
- KVRist
- 55 posts since 24 May, 2005 from Germany
Hi greendoor,
the idea is good, but not new...
There even are reverb algorithms out there which produce white noised IRs!
With "white noise reverbs" I found always a few problems:
- they don't sound natural. Natural rooms have resonances, a lot though, but not lots enough to produce a white noised IR
- they don't set right in the mix. Means, they sound smooth, however they tend to sound muddy in a way
- they have no character...
- Stereo reverberating with two white noised IRs leads to a completly uncorrelated reverb signal, which brings a wide, but not a spatial reverb. For a good spatiality the reverb signal has to be corellated in some way
So, in my opinion, a "white noise reverb" isn't ideal at all! Just my 2 cents
the idea is good, but not new...
There even are reverb algorithms out there which produce white noised IRs!
With "white noise reverbs" I found always a few problems:
- they don't sound natural. Natural rooms have resonances, a lot though, but not lots enough to produce a white noised IR
- they don't set right in the mix. Means, they sound smooth, however they tend to sound muddy in a way
- they have no character...
- Stereo reverberating with two white noised IRs leads to a completly uncorrelated reverb signal, which brings a wide, but not a spatial reverb. For a good spatiality the reverb signal has to be corellated in some way
So, in my opinion, a "white noise reverb" isn't ideal at all! Just my 2 cents
-
Music Engineer Music Engineer https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=15959
- KVRAF
- 4387 posts since 8 Mar, 2004 from Berlin, Germany
yes, i tried that too and i liked the sound. as for the frequency spectrum - one could apply (time-varying) higpass/lowpass filtering to the noise - especially when creating it with a subtractive synth. the idea could be taken further by comb-filtering the noise in such a way, that the spectral peaks match the key-tune of the track. seems to me, that this could be very musical (didn't try it yet).greendoor wrote: I suspect this would sound remarkably like a dense smooth reverb, and might be very musical. Especially if the frequency spectrum was also factored into the envelope control. Maybe like a multiband compressor.
Been done?
-
- KVRian
- 1128 posts since 3 Aug, 2004
so like a mixture of
Elevayta Clone Boy
to sculpt the appropriate frequency out of the white noise and
Amplitude Imposer by ndc or
MIDI-Controlled ADSR by ndc
or similar
to apply the the adsr settings of the say snare to the white noise??
wouldn`t this come close to using a resynthesis plugin on a send?
or am i way off
Elevayta Clone Boy
to sculpt the appropriate frequency out of the white noise and
Amplitude Imposer by ndc or
MIDI-Controlled ADSR by ndc
or similar
to apply the the adsr settings of the say snare to the white noise??
wouldn`t this come close to using a resynthesis plugin on a send?
or am i way off
-
- KVRian
- Topic Starter
- 769 posts since 2 Apr, 2005
Thanks for the comments everyone. Yes, I know this is a common synthesis technique - and if using sampled drums it would be logical just to sample or synthesis it and shape with adsr.
I'm getting into recording real snare now, and I kind of like those explosive '80's white noisy snares. I believe some of those were done with gated white noise.
I also know you can use white noise in convolution reverbs, but that gets repetitive and boring.
My idea of two free running white noise generators is to get some (very) subtle differences between left and right, and avoid the perfectly sampled repetitive sound.
I could probably just create a synth patch for free-running white noise, and a gate with sidechain (or use a stereo-ganged gate and send the snare down the left hand side to open it, and the white noise down the right hand side. And then duplicate this to get a left hand version.
I'm getting into recording real snare now, and I kind of like those explosive '80's white noisy snares. I believe some of those were done with gated white noise.
I also know you can use white noise in convolution reverbs, but that gets repetitive and boring.
My idea of two free running white noise generators is to get some (very) subtle differences between left and right, and avoid the perfectly sampled repetitive sound.
I could probably just create a synth patch for free-running white noise, and a gate with sidechain (or use a stereo-ganged gate and send the snare down the left hand side to open it, and the white noise down the right hand side. And then duplicate this to get a left hand version.
-
- KVRian
- 534 posts since 18 Mar, 2002 from france
from your description, the smothness in particular it sounds a lot like something autechre might use on their minimal stuff... would be nice to have something that generates that... tried messing with white noise a lot myself to get that sound but couldnt get close... sampling it then pitching it up, passing it through lots of different filters...
sounds cool to me anyway.
sounds cool to me anyway.
galaxy rayyys! powerful.
-
- KVRAF
- 2208 posts since 13 May, 2005
had this idea, two! I've also been using white noise as impulse responses for years, you can get very reverb effects.

