Studio One question - Bounce Selection vs. Bounce To New Track for MIDI events?

[antic604]

While working with MIDI & VST instruments, what's the difference between Bounce Selection vs. Bounce To New Track? From my experiments they do exactly the same:

• create new audio material in new track, at the location of MIDI event(s),
• the render includes all the inserts, fader position, panning, etc.
• they mute the original MIDI events,
• if selection spans several separate MIDI events & you use time-based FX (e.g. delay, reverb), the tails will be cut at the end of each event, as if they were rendered separately (so you need to merge the evens prior to bouncing or use Mixdown Selection instead)

So, what's the difference? Even S1's manual doesn't really help here:
https://s1manual.presonus.com/Content/A ... ght=bounce

[Trancit]

I just stumbled over this in a tutorial I´ve seen:

No differences for midi tracks... both commands do the same thing...
There is just a difference for audio tracks... bounce selection renders without insert FX (to render changes to the audio file itself) while bounce to new track renders the insert FX too

[antic604]

I just stumbled over this in a tutorial I´ve seen:

No differences for midi tracks... both commands do the same thing...
There is just a difference for audio tracks... bounce selection renders without insert FX (to render changes to the audio file itself) while bounce to new track renders the insert FX too

Thanks! Yeah, that's what I found, too.

I wish there was an option - for MIDI - to bounce to new track, but with insert FX copied over and not rendered to audio.

[Trancit]

...
I wish there was an option - for MIDI - to bounce to new track, but with insert FX copied over and not rendered to audio.

You are allowed to dream...