Best PC Speakers for retro gaming (in particular, suiting for ZSNES emulator audio), Music and composing?

If you are new here check this forum first, your question may have been answered.
Post Reply New Topic
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

The question more detailed for what I am looking for..
What are the best PC Speakers at 30-40 Watt in 2.0 Stereo for retro gaming (like ZSNES emulator 8 channel sound audio), Music and composing that works well with an internal ESI Maya 44ex soundcard (6,35 in) on Windows 7 SP1 64bit for a maximum budget of 120 Euros? :help: :?: :wink:

Question2) Why did my old Win XP hardware audio setup sound better in retrogames (+ as OS in general) than my current on Win7, although it was way cheaper? -> See comparision below

Old Setup -> Win XP SP3 32bit / Intel Pentium 3: Speedlink SL-8861-SRD 4 channel PCI Audio card (10 Euros) + Quadral SM-240 Stereo Satelite Speakers (100 PMPO Watt / 10 Euros)
Current Setup -> Win 7 SP1 64bit / Intel Core 2 Duo: ESI Maya 44ex Soundcard (150 Euros) + Creative Inspire T10 Speakers (with 10 Watt / 40 Euros) connected over a high quality and 100% suiting 6,35mm cable.

Or do I just need more Watt power, like 30-40 Watt to take advantage of that '150 Euro'-ESI Maya 44ex soundcard? For sure is, that my old 100 PMPO Watt speakers had about the triple amount of power, than my newer ones, although it was just PMPO Watt. (Could mean: 100 PMPO Watt = about 30 W?)

Or may it has something to do with that special X-Large Reverb on Win XP Sp3? Or even with that old EAX support + 4 channel mixing support of these cheap 10 Euro speedlink soundcard, that suits just better for older games, than newer stuff? Curious to hear the answers of 'audio experienced' members with a deep knowledge about these mysterious contextes. :?: :roll: :idea: :help:

The only explanation I had so far, was, that XP SP3 had his own X-large Reverb Sound which obviously suits better for soundcards with no extra reverb adding, when on the other hand, WIn 7 seems to handle soundcards with extra reverb on them better, for the following logic reason..

Reverb in your OS + Reverb of your Soundcard = Worse audio quality in your ears / Too much reverb
Reverb in your OS + no extra reverb or no OS Reverb + extra Reverb of your Soundcard =
acceptable sound in your ears!


Maybe this fact also explains the reason, why the opinions about the question, which OS has better Sound (XP Sp3 or Win7?) are so different in several forum debates over the web. My experience at least was, XP SP3 had clearly the better sound quality and I really tried everything out, in order to improve Win7 Soundquality, but without the wished success of an acceptable satisfaction.

Hope anyone can help me out, getting a better audio setup again...it's so frustrating, listening to bad audio, you know. And I can definitely confirm, that the "Creative Inspire T10" wouldn't have decent sound, if its just a speaker thing, well, anyway, I'm completely openminded to your advices on how to improve my audio setup for better gaming audio like in the good old days with the cheap 10 Euro Soundcard + cheap 10 Euro Speakers (yes, honestly, the 150 Euro Soundcard + 40 Euro Speakers on my Win7 PC gives worser quality in comparision to the old setup although all the setup is 100% correctly configured, only in terms of listening to normal music, I cant see any drawback, but when it comes to Emulator/Retro audio, the XP Setup leads by far in terms of producing better soundquality) Also wonder why it is so complicated to buy decent stuff nowadays for decent money. My personal feeling: They are selling lots of garbage nowadays for huge money.

Post

Budget = 120? KVR or GearSluts is the wrong forum to ask. 5 watts per channel might be enough already. It's bass that needs lots of power. Old games sound alright with midrange only, no subwoofer needed.

As an audiophile that knows fact from fake, the best sound is without added reverbs. Your taste might differ! Windows back then had lots of SoundGoodizers with fantasy names like WOW. I franticly tracked them down and turn them off. Especally for music, it needs to be off. Maybe for games you like it. I recall Realtek had a utility to check you had set the speakers correct, not swapped left & right. Only then I noticed that hard-panned left sound got echoed on right channel some 40ms later. Oh gawd, turn that off. You might actually like that.

ESI converters are without doubt better (less noise, flatter freq response, less distortion) than any built in AC97 ever was. But back then I made some pretty good recordings with two SoundBlasters. They are not the weak link. Speakers are though.

Regarding overpriced crap: that is of all times. I think you can buy something alike a Logitec gaming (then: multimedia) set for half the price. You do pay for the brand. But then, my no-name multimedia speakers went completely dead after some years for no apparent reason. Cheap stuff is just cheap stuff.

Final advice: save up and get a good hifi set. Or don't save and buy second hand. Saves the planet!
We are the KVR collective. Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated. Image
My MusicCalc is served over https!!

Post


Post Reply

Return to “Getting Started (AKA What is the best...?)”