Also being able to play bookmarked regions out of sequence.jplanet wrote:Be able to create a play order of marked regions, so if you want to hear your song with the chorus going an extra time, half-length verse, or without the bridge, etc.
Discuss:
FR: Create a play order for marked regions and bookmarks.
-
- KVRAF
- 4644 posts since 28 Nov, 2002 from Chicago
From jplanet in another thread:
Discuss:
Discuss:
Someone shot the food. Remember: don't shoot food!
-
- KVRAF
- 1615 posts since 28 Mar, 2005
My own view is A: cut and paste are easy and B: this idea violates T's wysiwyh paradigm.
Some details: What happens when you render? will the playlist be implemented or will it render whats in the linear view? then reimported renders won't "line up". And of course all sorts of issues would arise regarding behavior across the seams.
Some details: What happens when you render? will the playlist be implemented or will it render whats in the linear view? then reimported renders won't "line up". And of course all sorts of issues would arise regarding behavior across the seams.
-
- KVRAF
- 2028 posts since 18 Mar, 2004 from New York, N.Y.
I don't understand why you would come in and tell people not to want a feature. I don't need to quantize anything because I actually play an instrument, but I won't ask Jules to remove the feature.semiquaver wrote:My own view is A: cut and paste are easy and B: this idea violates T's wysiwyh paradigm.
Some details: What happens when you render? will the playlist be implemented or will it render whats in the linear view? then reimported renders won't "line up". And of course all sorts of issues would arise regarding behavior across the seams.
Cut and paste is not easy if you have 20 tracks of midi and audio.
I see people posting FR's all the time that I don't need. Who am I to tell them not to want it?
As for how to implement it, that's just like a feature in Cubase. It will render the linear view until you execute the command to render the playlist order.
-
- KVRAF
- 2028 posts since 18 Mar, 2004 from New York, N.Y.
Just to point out, it seems that a lot of people really do want this feature:semiquaver wrote:My own view is A: cut and paste are easy and B: this idea violates T's wysiwyh paradigm.
Some details: What happens when you render? will the playlist be implemented or will it render whats in the linear view? then reimported renders won't "line up". And of course all sorts of issues would arise regarding behavior across the seams.
http://www.kvraudio.com/forum/viewtopic ... highlight=
It really would help promote the view that Tracktion is a great tool for songwriters who want to hear ideas take shape quickly.
Cutting and pasting is also a big bummer if you have any automation, or parts that do not easily snap into a grid. And an even bigger waste of time if you're experimenting and want to hear a few variations before you start cutting things up.
-
- KVRAF
- 1615 posts since 28 Mar, 2005
don't be mad jp - its just my own view! I don't want it because I know that I'll lose track of the toggle and render stuff "wrong" and not know why the cursor is jumping around etc etc.
As far as cut and paste not being easy with 20 tracks etc -- it is as easy w 20 as it is w/ 2! you mark the region "copy marked region or copy clips within marked region, then insert at cursor. Not happy? multiple levels of undo. Not sure? save a copy of the edit - remember you can have multiple edits per project and edit files are small.
As far as cut and paste not being easy with 20 tracks etc -- it is as easy w 20 as it is w/ 2! you mark the region "copy marked region or copy clips within marked region, then insert at cursor. Not happy? multiple levels of undo. Not sure? save a copy of the edit - remember you can have multiple edits per project and edit files are small.
-
- KVRAF
- 2009 posts since 9 Apr, 2003 from Cornwall, UK
seems fine in principle but I have to say I'm not terribly impressed with the changing tempo function (it clicks at the cross over) or freeze function or render function or loop function, so I'm not too hopeful of a robust implementation.
If it was seemless then a big thumbs up. what would be cool would be that you could compose sections of the song at any point in the edit.
I would scrap the overall view of the edit in the top left of the edit screen (there are better ways to navigate your edit) and have this as a place you could drag and drop the yellow markers from the main screen. Then shuffle them about and use shift click to duplicate.
If it was seemless then a big thumbs up. what would be cool would be that you could compose sections of the song at any point in the edit.
I would scrap the overall view of the edit in the top left of the edit screen (there are better ways to navigate your edit) and have this as a place you could drag and drop the yellow markers from the main screen. Then shuffle them about and use shift click to duplicate.
