Ok, I was at work before and didn't want to be wasting too much time on KVR, so I'll be more descriptive now. The high end sounds "crunchy" but not in a good way (think Zoom). Most amps distort way too easily (take the Vox AC15 model for example) and unnaturally, and the dynamics don't respond well at all compared to even the Pod XT, let alone AT2. The low end and mids also seem generally unresponsive and just not "there" to me. Also, the way to select (or create) cabs, is just counter intuitive, and it just generally takes way too long to get anything halfway decent sounding setup. I mean, really, there's a lot there I don't like.Lunch Money wrote:"funny" IS definitely lacking in terms of descriptive words.
Each person will find the tool they're happiest with, though. Nothing wrong with that.
AT2 on the other hand is easy as plug-in, select the amp and play. Then maybe tweak a few knobs, audition a few mics and cabs, then bang I'm ready and it sounds great (all of this takes two minutes tops). Revalver may be capable of great sounds (again, I really like the high-gain stuff Dimitar has done), but I just for the life of me can't get them out of it. AT2 feels and acts a lot closer to a real amp IMO. My poor Fender ("Evil") Twin Amp, is going to be getting less and less use, I've already all but given up on my Guitarport for most things.
Here's a test, load up the demos of both programs, create two sends: 100% Pre-volume, and throw AT2 on one and Revalver Mk II on the other. Don't use a preset, but load up an AC30/15 w/ a corresponding 2x12 cab on each, and record some arppeggios. Then try to get the best sound on each and approximate the volume of each. Then just A/B. Ask yourself, 1) which sounds better, 2) how much better, and 3) how easily it was to obtain that sound. Then do the same with a Fender sound, and even load up a Marshall and try out the Sweet Child O' Mine riff or whatever. AT2 takes the cake for me on this test, but others may disagree.
But your right LM, different strokes for different folks. I've heard good things come out of Revalver, and it might just be the perfect unit for some people (I wish I could say the same).



