Echo Voodoo wrote:People evaluate music subjectively? I am shocked. Shocked and appalled.vespers75 wrote:Hmmm, what was that I said about "subjective" earlier in the thread?
Fortunately, that's *never* happened in a KVR music contest before.
November Contest: Gossip
- KVRAF
- 2975 posts since 18 Sep, 2006 from Rosehill Cemetery
"a confession without need of absolution, without need of redemption"
-
- KVRAF
- 3008 posts since 2 May, 2006 from Liquor store
I WILL NOT BE OUTDONE!!!!!
This blonde and brunette are watching the 11 o clock news and see a man standing on the ledge of a building ready to commit suicide. The brunette decides to make a bet, "Hey, I'll bet you twenty bucks the guy jumps" The blonde replies, "You're on"!
5 minutes later, the guy plummets to his death.
The blonde grudgingly hands the brunette a crisp twenty dollar bill, "Congrats".
The brunette grabs the bill but quickly hands it back to the blonde, "I-I can't accept this"?
BLONDE "Well why not"?
BRUNETTE "Because I cheated. I actually watched the 5 o clock news and they had already shown the man jump to his death".
BLONDE "Well, I saw the 5 o clock news too, but I didn't think the guy would jump twice"!
SO HA!!!! BEAT THAT!!!!!
This blonde and brunette are watching the 11 o clock news and see a man standing on the ledge of a building ready to commit suicide. The brunette decides to make a bet, "Hey, I'll bet you twenty bucks the guy jumps" The blonde replies, "You're on"!
5 minutes later, the guy plummets to his death.
The blonde grudgingly hands the brunette a crisp twenty dollar bill, "Congrats".
The brunette grabs the bill but quickly hands it back to the blonde, "I-I can't accept this"?
BLONDE "Well why not"?
BRUNETTE "Because I cheated. I actually watched the 5 o clock news and they had already shown the man jump to his death".
BLONDE "Well, I saw the 5 o clock news too, but I didn't think the guy would jump twice"!
SO HA!!!! BEAT THAT!!!!!
-
- D.H. MOD
- 17945 posts since 21 Jun, 2008
Does the S in S.HUSH stand for Shecky?
No longer a moderator.
- KVRAF
- 1818 posts since 5 Apr, 2002 from Seattle, WA, USA
I deviated.
-
- KVRian
- 756 posts since 21 Sep, 2006 from Kranj, Slovenia
LOL thanks for that pinballistic missileMax el Belga wrote:Holly BimBam ! Bingo ! Tilt ! Wowwy, wowwy, whaaa !A second top song !
Outstanding !
You're putting constantly lots of colour on the image we have of Slovenia.
![]()
LauraMichelJarre wrote:Aziraphal has great skills. His song is superb. And funny. I heard all sorts of things there that made me laugh. But the quality was amazing.
You mean you weren't pissed off by Indy 4 and Star Wars 2/3 prequels??vespers75 wrote:The Indiana Jones/Star Wars theme melody bits at the end were funny too (Have a thing for Harrison Ford, do you?) Funny indeed, which didn't feel angry to me.
Cheers Matt
Every time you use autotune, God kills a kitten.
Please, think of the kittens.
Please, think of the kittens.
- KVRAF
- 8498 posts since 18 Apr, 2004
Well, occasionally I do vote for entries I don't actually like but that I think are really good and/or fit the theme really good.Echo Voodoo wrote:People evaluate music subjectively? I am shocked. Shocked and appalled.vespers75 wrote:Hmmm, what was that I said about "subjective" earlier in the thread?
Fortunately, that's *never* happened in a KVR music contest before.
I'd even vote for entries by people I don't like, imagine that
-
- KVRAF
- 2828 posts since 31 Dec, 2004 from Canarias
Aziraphal, the 'typical' people you refer to aren't the ones that put colour onto something; they're rather grey.
See ya,
Max... .. .
See ya,
Max... .. .
Carpo diem ergo sum !
-
- KVRAF
- 21348 posts since 26 Jul, 2005 from Gone
That's how I look at it too.farlukar wrote:Well, occasionally I do vote for entries I don't actually like but that I think are really good and/or fit the theme really good.
I'm going to consider everything based on the theme and vote accordingly. I think this one has produced a few entries that to me just don't seem relevant to the theme. Just my opinion.
- KVRAF
- 2975 posts since 18 Sep, 2006 from Rosehill Cemetery
Man, that sounds rather objective, eh?farlukar wrote:
Well, occasionally I do vote for entries I don't actually like but that I think are really good and/or fit the theme really good.
I'd even vote for entries by people I don't like, imagine that
Seriously though, I agree. I've known some fantastic musicians that I personally thought were c**ts, but I wouldn't rag on their skills simply for that reason.
"a confession without need of absolution, without need of redemption"
- KVRAF
- 2975 posts since 18 Sep, 2006 from Rosehill Cemetery
True, which is what I meant earlier when I mentioned things being subjective, particularly with a theme such as this. Its almost as if there are two themes this month. One interpretation is to make music that portrays anger, the other is to make music that is supposed to annoy or anger the listener. So naturally, the way one decides to look at it when creating a song for it, will likely be the same way they look at it for voting as well (Personally, my choice of votes would look entirely different depending on which "view" I went with). It doesn't make it any easier that some of us are from different "musical worlds", so to speakrobojam wrote:I'm going to consider everything based on the theme and vote accordingly. I think this one has produced a few entries that to me just don't seem relevant to the theme. Just my opinion.
"a confession without need of absolution, without need of redemption"
-
- KVRAF
- 1931 posts since 14 Aug, 2006 from Winnipeg
You must be new here.vespers75 wrote:I imagine that considering next month is to be some sort of genre theme, things will be a bit less confusing next time.
Differing theme interpretations and differing ideas about how one should vote are pretty standard. Even very direct themes like "3/4 time" or "less than 60bpm" resulted in some discussion and interpretation.
-
- KVRAF
- 21348 posts since 26 Jul, 2005 from Gone
But at least those get resolved to the point where entries to the contest eventually sound relevant.Echo Voodoo wrote:You must be new here.vespers75 wrote:I imagine that considering next month is to be some sort of genre theme, things will be a bit less confusing next time.![]()
Differing theme interpretations and differing ideas about how one should vote are pretty standard. Even very direct themes like "3/4 time" or "less than 60bpm" resulted in some discussion and interpretation.
- KVRAF
- 2975 posts since 18 Sep, 2006 from Rosehill Cemetery
New to participating in these contests, yes.Echo Voodoo wrote:You must be new here.vespers75 wrote:I imagine that considering next month is to be some sort of genre theme, things will be a bit less confusing next time.![]()
"a confession without need of absolution, without need of redemption"
-
- KVRAF
- 1931 posts since 14 Aug, 2006 from Winnipeg
Yeah. You caught the little winky face in my post, right? I suppose the "you must be new here" meme is more popular on Slashdot than on KVR.vespers75 wrote:New to participating in these contests, yes.Echo Voodoo wrote:You must be new here.vespers75 wrote:I imagine that considering next month is to be some sort of genre theme, things will be a bit less confusing next time.![]()
You must be new^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^H^Hrobojam wrote:But at least those get resolved to the point where entries to the contest eventually sound relevant.
Sometimes.

