That's pretty much a given with me...Mike777 wrote:So I hope the composition is considered over the production.
August Contest: Gossip
-
- KVRian
- 637 posts since 5 Sep, 2001 from Hollywood, Ca. one block East of the Jack in the Box

- KVRAF
- 2841 posts since 23 Feb, 2004 from Planet Earth...for now
Sleek Month wrote:1-2 Many~Skin Job-'80's again. Cooks along nicely. The lead synth was ALARMING. I will thank you to never use that sound again.
At any rate thanks for the forthright review(s) - refreshin!
-
- KVRAF
- 2828 posts since 31 Dec, 2004 from Canarias
Hi folks, I've got 2 news items, hot from the needle :
- I'm back home, just in time to vote.
- I don't have cancer !
Yeehaaa !
CU lators, Ali and the Gators,
Max... .. .
- I'm back home, just in time to vote.
- I don't have cancer !
Yeehaaa !
CU lators, Ali and the Gators,
Max... .. .
Carpo diem ergo sum !
-
- KVRAF
- 2828 posts since 31 Dec, 2004 from Canarias
And I'm foocking/enormously curious to listen to what you guys have made this month and how many and what new plugins appeared here on KvR and etc...
See yous,
HappyMax... .. .
PS : A very important advice, never trust a Doctor who's standing behind you !
BTW, when you see of part of your inside on the flat-screen in front of you means : to late ! (check the line at the beginning of my "PS")

See yous,
HappyMax... .. .
PS : A very important advice, never trust a Doctor who's standing behind you !
BTW, when you see of part of your inside on the flat-screen in front of you means : to late ! (check the line at the beginning of my "PS")
Carpo diem ergo sum !
-
- DASH Guy
- 8159 posts since 20 Sep, 2001
-
- DASH Guy
- 8159 posts since 20 Sep, 2001
Thanks for the all the thoughful reviews, I agree with you about 90%,Sleek Month wrote: Liqh~Aquarius Ghostbusters-Cover mashup...I don't really hear the Aquarius theme presented so well. Confusingly '80's sounding, which seems to be a common thread in many of this month's entries.
The theme was :
"You are asked to create a Movie Theme..."
Any genre, it didn't mention Hollywood or anything else. So your take on how
it should be carried out is your own interpretation.
Actually stated as it was one could have been presenting anything or as extreme even pure silence.
Since there are movies with no soundtrack at all.
Said what was, common sense makes us thinking that Scoops meant a fairly commercial movie.
Therefore some kind of melodic theme was required. But even a sound FX "theme" as rachmiel
could be the recognizable mark for a movie, ever seen Stalker or Forbidden Planet?
About my entry I wrote "an episode of the Ghostbuster series", so the main theme is that.
The Aquarius people are meant to be the ghosts themselves. <wink>
my 2c, sorry for the poor english.
-
- KVRian
- 637 posts since 5 Sep, 2001 from Hollywood, Ca. one block East of the Jack in the Box
Unforgivable!liqih wrote:
... sorry for the poor english.

- KVRian
- 1328 posts since 7 May, 2005 from Haifa, Israel
Today (in Europe, where it's technically a new day already, at least :p) I'm 25 years old. :p
Thanks for the reviews, all. But I must admit, I really disagree with Sleek Month here. :p
For reference, I played some casual game that is entirely a chase/running away scene (called Canabalt) with my theme as a backing. Now whenever I hear my theme song, I can see that unknown character running away from the apocalypse occurring behind him. And I truly believe it qualifies as a leitmotif, and in my view, the main theme music of a film should be a leitmotif.
I really don't understand how you couldn't find a "clear melodic theme", I don't see how my piece can be anything but that.
Lastly, wouldn't the part where you say it sounds more like "background music" support the theme's qualifications as a leitmotif? Unless you view it as an idiosyncratic piece of background music that would be shoved anywhere, without relation to anything else in the soundtrack. :s
Sorry, I'm usually not that thin-skinned about the criticism, but you're not saying you didn't like it (difference in taste and all), you're saying I failed the challenge.
Thanks for the reviews, all. But I must admit, I really disagree with Sleek Month here. :p
For reference, I played some casual game that is entirely a chase/running away scene (called Canabalt) with my theme as a backing. Now whenever I hear my theme song, I can see that unknown character running away from the apocalypse occurring behind him. And I truly believe it qualifies as a leitmotif, and in my view, the main theme music of a film should be a leitmotif.
I really don't understand how you couldn't find a "clear melodic theme", I don't see how my piece can be anything but that.
Lastly, wouldn't the part where you say it sounds more like "background music" support the theme's qualifications as a leitmotif? Unless you view it as an idiosyncratic piece of background music that would be shoved anywhere, without relation to anything else in the soundtrack. :s
Sorry, I'm usually not that thin-skinned about the criticism, but you're not saying you didn't like it (difference in taste and all), you're saying I failed the challenge.
https://melodyklein.bandcamp.com/
Creativity is a drug I cannot live without.
Cecil B. DeMille (1881 - 1959)
Creativity is a drug I cannot live without.
Cecil B. DeMille (1881 - 1959)
-
- KVRian
- 570 posts since 30 Jul, 2006
Thanks for the review and suggestions. My inspiration came from that old french silent movie Happy Anniversary (1962 oscar winner)An excellent example of movie music where the characters get identified through the music.The leitmotif keeps repeating at well structured slots/moments.Music plays an extremely important role of the narrator without making its presence felt overwhelmingly. Hollywood has destroyed the fine art of movie music with heavy orchestration.(IMHO) Mine was an idea for a short film. As you rightly said it is a sound set. For later evolution and development of these bits into longer appropriate versions in consultation/collaboration with the "client"Sleek Month
shirkant~cherry- Dude, it's mastering compressor time.You don't gotta crush your track, but I couldn't tell this was even playing after the other tracks. An odd little tune with an interesting soundset.
Thanks
shrikant
-
- KVRian
- 637 posts since 5 Sep, 2001 from Hollywood, Ca. one block East of the Jack in the Box
It sounds like some arpeggios without a "lead" line in the beginning, then when the strings come in, the line is so understated that after several listenings, I still could not remember it.Psy-T wrote: I really don't understand how you couldn't find a "clear melodic theme", I don't see how my piece can be anything but that.
Let's use something that sounds like your piece as example:
It starts very similar, with arpeggiated piano, but then around :26, a well definted lead line kicks in.
Your piece is kind of the same, but with no lead line. Backing without a "voice".
Well, you described it as such (background music) yourself. I'm thinking a movie's theme, as opposed to a character's theme or whatever, is a "trademark" piece of music that DOES draw attention to itself and functions without action behind it, like over a credit sequence or setup shot.Lastly, wouldn't the part where you say it sounds more like "background music" support the theme's qualifications as a leitmotif?
I am not saying leitmotif itself makes something a "theme", but I am saying that FOR ME, a theme necessarily has a strong melodic hook stated succinctly, a defining motif that personifies the film you are about to see, a statement of both intent and purpose.
This theme can and usually is brought back in different permutations throughout the film, but typically is never stated as strongly as it is when first introduced.
...as has been said, ANYTHING can be a theme, but when people think of a movie's theme, they really don't start thinking of the electronic tonalities from Forbidden Planet, (Bastard! I got drawn into watching the whole movie again by your post!
...and, if I was hiring somebody to score a film, that's what I would be hoping for.
Yes, you COULD hook a cart to a Tiger, but when you say "beast of burden", that isn't what people think of.
Just sayin. Please don't take offense, and happy birthday. Mine was Wednesday.


