I did NOT saying "playing in C major and the bass uses the same except that the bass moves from D to D".
I said:
This is completely different because "the white keys" is NOT C major.It could be that the piano and guitar are playing in C major and the bass uses the same tones (the "white keys") except that the bass moves from D to D
I explain that the perception of tonal center is subjective, then you tell me no, it's subjective. WTF?
And so on... your whole post is misquoting.
Is anyone else having difficulty understanding what I'm saying?
You can hear what the original poster was asking about here:
http://www.classicalarchives.com/work/815373.html