I agree that old doesn't need to be bad .I have a 15 year old clavia modular G1 .sounds great .Image-Line wrote:I have started a thread comparing 'old' Filters with 'new' ZDF designs, with audio examples. I don't hear any magic in ZDF filters. Old does not mean bad. New does not mean better. Most advances in DSP have to do with real-time processing efficiency not audio quality. The principles of filter designs have been long established (in mathematics, most of it before real-time DSP was even possible). I invite you to continue the discussion here:gentleclockdivider wrote:Zoom level in song editor is dependent on ppqn = fact , you kept silent about this one for a reason didn't you ?
Could you elaborate as to why the Zoom Level is still ppqn dependent ?
Looptalk ZDF Filter Comparison
Playlist zoom is linked to PPQ because slicing and Automation Clip control-point placement (by design) is quantized to PPQ. The Playlist only Zooms far enough to allow accurate placement of events and slices at the current PPQ. Allowing higher zoom is a false promise and people will wonder why their cursor jumps over so much data.
Will the Playlist always work this way? No.
Regards Scott
Old softies can still sound fantastic ..dsp wizard john hodgson -->oddity V.1 stillsounds great , altough it shows it weaknesses when doing audio rate modulation and maximum resonance .
There is no magic in a zdf when the basic filter algoritm sounds bad , but it's fair to say that if one can understand the math behind the zdf , the person will probably take the time to code a decent filter too .
That said ,the max claster plugins filter sound O.K , you think it's possible to implement those in the sampler instruments ?
Ohyeah , just quickly visited the looptalk filter comparison ....I did the comparison a few years back .
The mango filters sounds pretty identical to zebra xmf ( set to analogue mode and a healthy amount of internal overdrive ).
Comparing it to monark is imho a bit far stretched .
Sytrus filters implemented in the sampler instruments might be a good move .
Peace
