Steinberg HALion 6 & HALion Sonic 3

VST, AU, AAX, CLAP, etc. Plugin Virtual Instruments Discussion
Post Reply New Topic

Post

Sampleconstruct wrote:
c_voltage wrote:Damn, although not bad ) difficult situation
:?:
Well, i meant circumstance about autokill licenses for previous versions (and for hypersonic).
As well as some other moments (uncertainty about win7 support, about reactivation soft elicenser etc).
But, i see that really cool new wavetable system, therefore, difficult choice.

Post

c_voltage wrote:
Sampleconstruct wrote:
c_voltage wrote:Damn, although not bad ) difficult situation
:?:
Well, i meant circumstance about autokill licenses for previous versions (and for hypersonic).
As well as some other moments (uncertainty about win7 support, about reactivation soft elicenser etc).
But, i see that really cool new wavetable system, therefore, difficult choice.
About Windows 7: I have been working today building a bunch of programs, trying granular and wavetable synthesis, and everything have been working like a charm. So far, I have no complaints regarding HALion 6 performance in Windows 7.

About licenses: I am waiting for the second reply from Steinberg, but if they send me a HALion 5 license to work alongside HALion 6 (which I believe they will, according to the message posted in their own forum), that for me would be enough. Of course, having also HALion 4 backward compatibility would make me more comfortable, but I think I am ready to give up on that (but not HALion 5). So, admiting that will happen, I will have no more complaints regarding HALion 6. Sure, the content instllation is still messy, but after I went to Options - Library Search Paths and added the customized locations I had, everything have been working OK, and I had no more problems loading programs.
Fernando (FMR)

Post

fmr wrote:About Windows 7: I have been working today building a bunch of programs, trying granular and wavetable synthesis, and everything have been working like a charm. So far, I have no complaints regarding HALion 6 performance in Windows 7.
Yes, i heard it is works ok (that's good), well, i meant the fact by itself, about unclear support win7 by steinberg. (Who know what they will answer if you get any problems with h6 in the learning process). From here the uncertainty. Though not as critical level already, but nonetheless, who know.
fmr wrote: but if they send me a HALion 5 license to work alongside HALion 6 (which I believe they will, according to the message posted in their own forum), that for me would be enough.
Yes, have heard about it, well, it would be enough for me too :lol: .
In general, if it is confirmed, please let know.

Post

As long as it also supports Hypersonic, not actually bothered about H5.

Post

aMUSEd wrote:As long as it also supports Hypersonic, not actually bothered about H5.
So 32-bit is not an issue for you?
Fernando (FMR)

Post

fmr wrote:I am not running Hypersonic 2 anymore (I too started from there, then upgraded to HALion Sonic 2, then HALion 4, then 5, now HALion 6). What I can say is that HALion 6 license, in the current satus, deletes any trace of previous licenses that came before it.

Probably, it's better for you to open a ticket to support in My Steinberg with that question. The more people that raise this question the better. I feel that they should have preserved the information of all the previous licenses that were upgraded, like they do with Cubase and Wavelab.
Wait.. now I'm confused about the current discussion.

Let me try to understand it:
- you had Halion 5, which is definitely x86 (32bit) and x64 (64bit)
- as there is no 32bit/64bit split on the USB eLicenser, it didn't matter which version you started in your host
- you upgrade to Halion 6, which obviously "updated"/over-wrote your existing license
- Halion 6 refuses to install on Windows 7 (32bit or 64bit?)
- Halion 6 did overwrite files from previous Halion versions
- previous Halion versions (Halion 5) can't be launched anymore, since the main engine DLL got "overwritten" (probably also same ID, so a simple DLL change wouldn't help)
- you tried the USB key on another rig with Halion 5 - and the available license won't be accepted


Okay, now my concerns...
Steinberg wrote to me via Twitter DM, that they support "up to three OS versions back", at least for the hosts. Nothing about the plugins. But now I fear the new route they're going here.

Meaning... Windows 10 is now considered like OSX, so the next update of Windows 10 will be 10.2 or something, and "three OS versions back" would mean Windows 8.1 support absolute max. Unless they ignore the "maintenance updates" and say "Win10, Win8.x, Win7" - but unless they're clear on that it's only a guessing game. I have Win7, but I skipped Win8 and still refuse to install Win10 unless it's "more cleaned up and stable running", not to mention less of an internet "hog".

I however now fear that any future CubEndo/Wavelab/Dorico/Sequel Updates will also refuse to "lauch" parallel installed hosts for backwards compatibility sakes and force users to new versions. Even if they're inferior or sluggish running (early adopters, etc).

And since there is no day-1-demo for their tools still(!!!)....

Receipt for disaster IMO...



Unless I'm missing something crucial here. Like "HDD/Soft eLicenser only", or a certian tool combination that triggered the "license loss". Either way - definitely not a cool move and I do understand the frustration.
[ Mix Challenge ] | [ Studio Page / Twitter ] | [ KVRmarks (see: metering tools) ]

Post

Compyfox wrote: Wait.. now I'm confused about the current discussion.

Let me try to understand it:
- you had Halion 5, which is definitely x86 (32bit) and x64 (64bit)
YES
Compyfox wrote: - as there is no 32bit/64bit split on the USB eLicenser, it didn't matter which version you started in your host
- you upgrade to Halion 6, which obviously "updated"/over-wrote your existing license
- Halion 6 refuses to install on Windows 7 (32bit or 64bit?)
NO, it installed and is running OK (but just 64-bit, of course)
Compyfox wrote: - Halion 6 did overwrite files from previous Halion versions
Well, I uninstalled, reinstalled, messed things up, deleted, etc. In the end, I got HALion 5 and HALion 6 both installed, and both CAN run. BUT...
Compyfox wrote:
- previous Halion versions (Halion 5) can't be launched anymore, since the main engine DLL got "overwritten" (probably also same ID, so a simple DLL change wouldn't help)
As I explained above, after installations, uninstallations and reinstallations, I ended with both installed.
Compyfox wrote: - you tried the USB key on another rig with Halion 5 - and the available license won't be accepted
Actually, I tried in the same system, and also in another system, but yes, HALion 5 didn't recognize the license, tehrefore, I had to abort launching.
Compyfox wrote:
I however now fear that any future CubEndo/Wavelab/Dorico/Sequel Updates will also refuse to "lauch" parallel installed hosts for backwards compatibility sakes and force users to new versions. Even if they're inferior or sluggish running (early adopters, etc).

And since there is no day-1-demo for their tools still(!!!)....

Receipt for disaster IMO...

Unless I'm missing something crucial here. Like "HDD/Soft eLicenser only", or a certian tool combination that triggered the "license loss". Either way - definitely not a cool move and I do understand the frustration.
Well, upgrades always have to be installed where the previous license is. So, I don't see how they can change from the eLicenser to a Soft eLicenser during an upgrade. But yes, I agree. Next time they launch a new product, I have to ask previously if the upgrade will delete my previous licenses (unless they learn their lesson and don't do that again). As I said, Steinberg always respected previous licenses, and the upgrade license was always "incremental" allowing to run everything that was previously authorized. It was like this with previous licenses of HALion, as well as with Cubase and Wavelab. What happened with HALion 6, however, is frightening.
Fernando (FMR)

Post

fmr wrote:
aMUSEd wrote:As long as it also supports Hypersonic, not actually bothered about H5.
So 32-bit is not an issue for you?
Not at all, Hypersonic is one of the few 32 bit plugins I have left that's worth keeping but the fact that it is 32 bit is kindof incidental, I just think it's a great plugin and that I've been cheated out of it.

Post

btw anyone know how to share ratings made in Halionsonic or Halion between them? I just rated a whole bunch in HS3 only to find in Halion 6 they are all back to 3 stars each which is a pain.

Post

After a good mess about with this I must say that the supplied Anima and Skylab presets are completely uninspiring and the pdf manual might as well be written in serbo croat.

Post

wickfut wrote:After a good mess about with this I must say that the supplied Anima and Skylab presets are completely uninspiring and the pdf manual might as well be written in serbo croat.
I agree about Anima, the presets are really awful, mostly too aggressive and crude for me. I have only found one that I rated 4. But Skylab has lots of patches I love and many rated 4 and 5.

But anyway - that's just presets, good thing there is so much scope for making our own :)

Post

aMUSEd wrote:
wickfut wrote:After a good mess about with this I must say that the supplied Anima and Skylab presets are completely uninspiring and the pdf manual might as well be written in serbo croat.
I agree about Anima, the presets are really awful, mostly too aggressive and crude for me. I have only found one that I rated 4. But Skylab has lots of patches I love and many rated 4 and 5.
So what's the difference between Skylab and Auron apart from the GUI?

Post

Okay, so let me summarize once more (fmr):

- Halion (whichever version) works in x64 (Steinberg started to drop 32bit)
- you could install and run both Halion 5 and 6 in parallel
- it didn't work "prior" due to reasons unknown, but now it works (even without a special re-addressed license)

So it's a hiccup, albeit understandably not a good one.

fmr wrote:Well, upgrades always have to be installed where the previous license is. So, I don't see how they can change from the eLicenser to a Soft eLicenser during an upgrade.
This is what I try to understand here as well.

I mean... didn't Steinberg have a hiccup during the first 2-3 days of the C9 release with their license server (updates were rolled back)?

fmr wrote:But yes, I agree. Next time they launch a new product, I have to ask previously if the upgrade will delete my previous licenses (unless they learn their lesson and don't do that again). As I said, Steinberg always respected previous licenses, and the upgrade license was always "incremental" allowing to run everything that was previously authorized. It was like this with previous licenses of HALion, as well as with Cubase and Wavelab. What happened with HALion 6, however, is frightening.
I definitely agree on the frightening part.
But we know Steinberg and their way of communication.


I think, after additional hiccup (again, see the license roll-back of C9), Steinberg needs to(!) address a couple of things. Mainly reintroducing day-1 demos again, then covering the License Handling and it's corresponding problems. This is adding up throughout the years (somebody still remembers the "C7.0 needs to download the installer first" thing?)

I'm a beta tester for various companies, I am hesitant on new versions of any host... So if there is no demo, and I "upgrade anyway", I want a transition period. If the "future" is to completely nuke prior versions in favor to only use the most recent one...

...well, this is not how you keep your customers "happy" - and no survey will help improve that.
[ Mix Challenge ] | [ Studio Page / Twitter ] | [ KVRmarks (see: metering tools) ]

Post

wickfut wrote:
aMUSEd wrote:
wickfut wrote:After a good mess about with this I must say that the supplied Anima and Skylab presets are completely uninspiring and the pdf manual might as well be written in serbo croat.
I agree about Anima, the presets are really awful, mostly too aggressive and crude for me. I have only found one that I rated 4. But Skylab has lots of patches I love and many rated 4 and 5.
So what's the difference between Skylab and Auron apart from the GUI?
Not much, tbh I wish they had just incorporated Padshop into it (but with multsamples) then I could share patches

Post

Compyfox wrote:Okay, so let me summarize once more (fmr):

- Halion (whichever version) works in x64 (Steinberg started to drop 32bit)
- you could install and run both Halion 5 and 6 in parallel
- it didn't work "prior" due to reasons unknown, but now it works (even without a special re-addressed license)

So it's a hiccup, albeit understandably not a good one.
It's not a hiccup, it's a complete choke. I managed to have HALion 5 installed, but it doesn't run, because currently I have no license for it - just for HALion 6. What I said is that it is ready to run, because it starts OK, but when it reaches the part where it would open the main screen, I get an error message telling me that no valid license was detected and asking me to cancel :x

I am waiting for Steinberg to give me a solution (based on what was written in their forum, that will be an extra HALion 5 license - if that comes, then yes, the current choke will become a "quite long" hiccup).

Anyway, besides that choke, everything is working, and I am quite happy with HALion 6 :)
Fernando (FMR)

Post Reply

Return to “Instruments”