bugs/glitches with the trkarch system.

Discussion about: tracktion.com
Post Reply New Topic
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

Ok, this has happened to me again after I thought I had a procedure worked out.

here's the scenario.

I put down a few tracks, make a trkarch, and send it to my collaborator. He opens the trkarch, and adds some bits. Now if he sends me the whole thing back, and I unpack it into the same directory I sent it from, it will overwrite the existing files, including the trkedit file.

not an overly big deal, as we don't destructively edit audio files.

Of course I would lose any tweaks I'd made to the edit since I sent it to him, and it's pretty redundant for him to send me all those audio files back again.

So what I'll have him do is create a copy of the edit, and delete all the old tracks from that copy. Then make sure he *saves* that edit before he exports a new trkarch, as it exports the last saved state of the edit.

Now when he sends me this, I can open it into the right directoy, and copy the tracks into the original edit. This works but is an elaborate and fragile system. Say, for example, that he forgets to save before exports the trkarch, and I overwrite my original audio files with copies that have been trimmed with handles. Or that we both have copies, and his copy number happens to overwrite the version of the edit I was working on etc. etc.

So what I'm asking is you could *please* implement the existing incrementing number system when *unpacking* a trkarch, so that at least the edit files are *never* overwritten?

sorry about the excessive *emphasis* but I just lost yet another song to this little quirk, and I'm not the only person this has happened to (iirc it happened to Lunch Money, but I can't remember, it was months ago)

preferably before T2 ;)

Post

ok nevermind, it wasn't even a month ago. wierd, I'm sure there was an older thread about it. What I did turn up was these two:

http://www.kvr-vst.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=55311

http://www.kvr-vst.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=37458

Post

Won't using 'saveas' create a new file to make a trkarch from while still using the same reference to other files?

Select the edit to make an export from instead of the project.
Image

Post

tingle, I am exporting the trkarchs from the edits, sorry if that was unclear. I just fired up tracktion to check the save-as thing, and that should provide a decent work-around (don't know why I never thought of it :roll:)

otoh, I still think that the trkarch system should add incremented numbers when extracting to avoid overwriting files, at least as an option somewhere.

Post Reply

Return to “Tracktion”