So This Whole AMD/Ryzen Thing Really Kind Of Sucks So Far...
-
Funkybot's Evil Twin Funkybot's Evil Twin https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=116627
- KVRAF
- Topic Starter
- 12514 posts since 16 Aug, 2006
Ugh...now my Roli Seaboard 25 isn't being registered via USB either. Let's call that Issue #6?
This is a joke right? This can't be normal. Maybe the mobo was damaged in shipping? There's no way I have a PCI Firewire card that previously worked, a USB Behringer X-Touch One that previously worked, and a Roli Seaboard Rise that previously worked, all of which no longer work with this new PC on top of all the other issues I'm having. This is insane! I've never had this many problems with ANY system.
That's gotta be an issue with the board itself right? There's no way this much sh*t doesn't work.
EDIT Apr 13 2020
Solution: looks like the issue here is the Roli itself. Tried on my laptop and it's not working there either. Tried on my old PC, no dice there either. Sometime in the last two weeks or so it seems to have just decided to die. It's unrelated to the new PC.
This is a joke right? This can't be normal. Maybe the mobo was damaged in shipping? There's no way I have a PCI Firewire card that previously worked, a USB Behringer X-Touch One that previously worked, and a Roli Seaboard Rise that previously worked, all of which no longer work with this new PC on top of all the other issues I'm having. This is insane! I've never had this many problems with ANY system.
That's gotta be an issue with the board itself right? There's no way this much sh*t doesn't work.
EDIT Apr 13 2020
Solution: looks like the issue here is the Roli itself. Tried on my laptop and it's not working there either. Tried on my old PC, no dice there either. Sometime in the last two weeks or so it seems to have just decided to die. It's unrelated to the new PC.
Last edited by Funkybot's Evil Twin on Mon Apr 13, 2020 10:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- KVRAF
- 3086 posts since 4 May, 2012
I can understand Firewire or Thunderbolt issues but not USB. That's an odd one.
Time to double check your USB drivers? Maybe legacy drivers will solve the issue.
No idea if updates to W10 might have negatively impacted on your system. I made sure my rig never updates as soon as I installed W10 - after hearing from so many friends about various issues. Other than my Firewire adapter not working and having to make the decision to switch, everything else ran smoothly, with a couple of MIDI controllers connected via USB. I'm happy to put Firewire in the past though. USB is much more stable. Well. It should be.
I'd take a break. Step away for a few minutes.
Any chance of starting over from scratch with a fresh install of your OS?
Time to double check your USB drivers? Maybe legacy drivers will solve the issue.
No idea if updates to W10 might have negatively impacted on your system. I made sure my rig never updates as soon as I installed W10 - after hearing from so many friends about various issues. Other than my Firewire adapter not working and having to make the decision to switch, everything else ran smoothly, with a couple of MIDI controllers connected via USB. I'm happy to put Firewire in the past though. USB is much more stable. Well. It should be.
I'd take a break. Step away for a few minutes.
Any chance of starting over from scratch with a fresh install of your OS?
-
- KVRian
- 1031 posts since 15 Feb, 2005
This seems to be a fundamental problem of the PC ecosystem that has emerged over time and increased exponentially with growth. I recently bought a Dell laptop for my mom. Camera didn't work from day one. Great...She primarily wanted it for video chatting with her grand kids. Tons of time wasted troubleshooting a new product which a customer should never have to do, come to find out a Windows update killed the camera. Dell chose a VR camera from Intel. Intel decided to abandon a brand new product as a business decision.Dell blames Intel, Intel blames Windows, Windows blames Intel. Nobody wants to lift a finger for a brand new product that doesn't work as advertised.
Never been a MAC guy, have used them before in labs, but for the first time in my life after that exhausting experience,...I think I understood why some people are willing to pay the markup for MACs closed system.
Never been a MAC guy, have used them before in labs, but for the first time in my life after that exhausting experience,...I think I understood why some people are willing to pay the markup for MACs closed system.
Music had a one night stand with sound design.....And the condom broke
-
WatchTheGuitar WatchTheGuitar https://www.kvraudio.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=440193
- KVRAF
- 13256 posts since 30 Apr, 2019
I haven't had any USB issues with my AMD music PC, but then I'm not throwing anything more exotic at it than some MIDI keyboards and an Arturia Audiofuse interface. The only issues I had initially were before I got the Arturia I used a Focusrite Scarlett I'd used with my prior PC and it was an Intel and had the same issue - noise over USB, think it was a known issue with that gen of the interface I had, possible lack of internal shielding.
I was surprised to learn that there is actually an AMD that offers Thunderbolt now - even if you did have to pay £500 for the M/B, I paid £120 for my X470. I'd want to ensure it was actually compatible with gear before I bought anything though and that'd probably involve waiting for confirmation from other people that they had the same setup.
Oh yeah the one bit of weirdness I did get with my AMD board was it came with a USB 3.1 header that no-one seems to ship a part for so I ended up forking out for a PCI-E USB card with a USB 3.1 port just so I could charge my bloody phone in an emergency.
I know people generally just go for Intel in music production, but their current CPUs just aren't bang-for-buck competitive IMO.
I was surprised to learn that there is actually an AMD that offers Thunderbolt now - even if you did have to pay £500 for the M/B, I paid £120 for my X470. I'd want to ensure it was actually compatible with gear before I bought anything though and that'd probably involve waiting for confirmation from other people that they had the same setup.
Oh yeah the one bit of weirdness I did get with my AMD board was it came with a USB 3.1 header that no-one seems to ship a part for so I ended up forking out for a PCI-E USB card with a USB 3.1 port just so I could charge my bloody phone in an emergency.
I know people generally just go for Intel in music production, but their current CPUs just aren't bang-for-buck competitive IMO.
-
- KVRAF
- 3227 posts since 4 Jan, 2005
Might be that your Mobo is a piece sheet ... Id contact AsRock about it or just get with the company you bought the Mobo from and pull that bad boy out . I had to RMA a Mobo one time , 1366intel Gigabyte Mobo with Ti FireWire (internet port went bad) , and was back up and running three weeks later . Still working til this day ... So I bet you got a bad Mobo.
- KVRian
- 1188 posts since 21 Aug, 2017 from Brasil
IF the USB chipset is incompatible there is no other way...Funkybot's Evil Twin wrote: Fri Apr 10, 2020 6:29 pm Issue 3:My Behringer X-Touch One just refused to work.
Solution: None yet. Apparently, this is an issue with multiple AMD X570 boards where the onboard USB doesn't like the X-Touch. Saw some posts suggesting buying a USB3 PCIe card would do the trick. Seriously? I gotta buy another card just to make USB work?
Must to buy a card with compatible chipset...
https://community.musictribe.com/t5/Rec ... rue#M53865
The mentioned PCIe card uses NEC720202 http://www.logilink.com/media/datasheets/PC0054A.pdf
This uses the same chipset, but is cheaper and no need for power connector.
https://www.amazon.com/SEDNA-separated- ... 0779YVWJ7/

This has 4 ports, but uses a different chipset(Fresco FL1100), but it is know
to work well with many audio interfaces and stuff and probably will work well too.
To be sure better ask Behringer support...
https://www.amazon.com/SEDNA-Express-Ad ... 06XKDTYMM/
To avoid some problems/weirdness, I great recommend to
set the motherboard BIOS PCIe to GEN 3, not AUTO or GEN 4
I also make sure to use the latest x570 chipset driver ver 2.04.04.111 dated 4/7/2020
https://www.amd.com/en/support/chipsets ... t-am4/x570
And use the latest GPU driver Adrenalin 2020 Edition 20.4.1 dated 4/2/2020
https://drivers.amd.com/drivers/beta/wi ... 1-apr2.exe
-
- KVRer
- 24 posts since 10 Sep, 2017
Or get the device manufacturers to get their act together... i.e.
Been in contact with support for 2 months now.... first round, not usable at all.
Icon blamed ASRock (X570-Phantom-Gaming-ITX-TB3 in my case) for 'underpowered' USB ports, pointing to issues with x570 boards generally (another angle could be that manufacturers have/had soso drivers/firmware, and never needed to run on anything other than intel for the last 5+ years...) and suggested the only fix to get the Platform to run again would be to get an additional PCI USB card...
Low and behold though, after a few more emails, I then got a beta driver / firmware, which at least made the Platform M+ recognized as a USB device again on the x570 system; but then started to act erratic (buttons were not staying lit, etc,) so Icon released another firmware (2.11 beta) which has also fixed the button light issue (and is now available through iMap...), and after 2 months+ the Platform M+ now also works on an x570 based system as intended.
Just some anecdotal bits that it's not necessarily the x570/AMD combo's fault...
c.
Had the same issue as the X-Touch mentioned here with the Platform M+ (but, all other USB device do play fine with the AMD/x570 ccombo so far, among them a RME Babyface Pro. No UAD or Roli though..).Unaspected wrote: Fri Apr 10, 2020 11:56 pm Might be a good excuse to get a Platform M+. I was contemplating one of those for myself. Sold my Behringer BCF 2000 a little while ago and am missing the tactile interaction.
Been in contact with support for 2 months now.... first round, not usable at all.
Icon blamed ASRock (X570-Phantom-Gaming-ITX-TB3 in my case) for 'underpowered' USB ports, pointing to issues with x570 boards generally (another angle could be that manufacturers have/had soso drivers/firmware, and never needed to run on anything other than intel for the last 5+ years...) and suggested the only fix to get the Platform to run again would be to get an additional PCI USB card...
Low and behold though, after a few more emails, I then got a beta driver / firmware, which at least made the Platform M+ recognized as a USB device again on the x570 system; but then started to act erratic (buttons were not staying lit, etc,) so Icon released another firmware (2.11 beta) which has also fixed the button light issue (and is now available through iMap...), and after 2 months+ the Platform M+ now also works on an x570 based system as intended.
Just some anecdotal bits that it's not necessarily the x570/AMD combo's fault...
c.
-
- KVRAF
- 3222 posts since 23 Dec, 2002
USB 3 pcie card recommendation: I'd try another USB 3 card - that is a cheap solution the card that I bought for my Intel 3930k after one of the USB 3 ports failed. I used a Startech and it worked with everything that I have in my studio. I don't have the Behringer controller that you mention but this works with all my synths and controllers here (close to 30 connected devices using hubs) . I do have the Behringer BCR2000 and it is working fine. I have run it for a few years now. The card was about $16.00 USD so it is worth trying even if it doesn't work out for you. Edit: I humbly defer to Pictus' comments regarding USB 3 chipsets.
StarTech PEXUSB3S23 2 Port PCI Express PCIe Super Speed
Ryzen with Pre Octo-UAD-2 CARDS (Bios Update and Generation 2 Tweaks)
Regarding the UAD-2 card issues I almost went with ASROCK for my Ryzen build (for a friend) because I read some people got those older quads, duos and solos working but I went with Asus x570 Prime Pro motherboard.. I updated the Bios.. put my two UAD-2 quads below the top slot for the GPU and they worked. (I also tested a duo and solo card and they also were detected and loaded and unloaded their plugins perfectly).
I read on forums that some people got pre OCTO UAD-2 cards working by changing the PCIE port designation to generation 2 or 3 using BIOS settings. I didn't have to do that with the ASUS board as the UAD-2 cards were supported out of the box following the BIOS update. This issue isn't specific to AMD motherboards as I understand it ... some new Intel builds are also having issues recognizing the older UAD-2 cards.
Hopefully this is helpful information.
StarTech PEXUSB3S23 2 Port PCI Express PCIe Super Speed
Ryzen with Pre Octo-UAD-2 CARDS (Bios Update and Generation 2 Tweaks)
Regarding the UAD-2 card issues I almost went with ASROCK for my Ryzen build (for a friend) because I read some people got those older quads, duos and solos working but I went with Asus x570 Prime Pro motherboard.. I updated the Bios.. put my two UAD-2 quads below the top slot for the GPU and they worked. (I also tested a duo and solo card and they also were detected and loaded and unloaded their plugins perfectly).
I read on forums that some people got pre OCTO UAD-2 cards working by changing the PCIE port designation to generation 2 or 3 using BIOS settings. I didn't have to do that with the ASUS board as the UAD-2 cards were supported out of the box following the BIOS update. This issue isn't specific to AMD motherboards as I understand it ... some new Intel builds are also having issues recognizing the older UAD-2 cards.
Hopefully this is helpful information.
-
- KVRian
- 1360 posts since 4 Aug, 2004 from Ain't tellin' ya...
Does anyone know how these systems play with RME Babyface Pro interfaces?
I use one in an older 6700K system and recently got a 3900X system built. Hope it works.
I use one in an older 6700K system and recently got a 3900X system built. Hope it works.
Little Black Dog - 2008-Present
-
- KVRian
- 1360 posts since 4 Aug, 2004 from Ain't tellin' ya...
I think the problem comes down to the USB chipset manufacturer. I heard that some ASMedia chipsets have caused problems for certain interfaces but haven't heard anything else.
My motherboard is a X570 Auoris Master and they use a Pericom chip for the USB 3 and GL850S for USB 2.
My motherboard is a X570 Auoris Master and they use a Pericom chip for the USB 3 and GL850S for USB 2.
Little Black Dog - 2008-Present
-
- KVRian
- 1360 posts since 4 Aug, 2004 from Ain't tellin' ya...
That's great news!traz wrote: Sat Apr 11, 2020 11:01 pm I have the Babyface (not the pro) with 3900x and x570 aurous master and it works great so you should be fine! cheers
Little Black Dog - 2008-Present
-
- KVRist
- 177 posts since 18 Oct, 2019
I have BF pro with Ryzen 5 and working as intended since day 1. Even Access Virus TI2 (which is usb 1.1) works perfectly.benjamind wrote: Sat Apr 11, 2020 10:35 pm Does anyone know how these systems play with RME Babyface Pro interfaces?
I use one in an older 6700K system and recently got a 3900X system built. Hope it works.
{"panic_string":"BAD MAGIC!
(flag set in iBoot panic header), no macOS panic log available"} "Apple did not respond to a request for comment."
-
- KVRAF
- 2648 posts since 20 Jun, 2012
Asrock as a mobo supplier is very decent. I'd take them over MSI and some other such makers any day. They have generally very good boards. Their support, on the other hand, might suck. Once had to ask them something, but don't think I ever got the any response back. But this might have been an one off thing, so take it with a pinch of salt.Vee Nee wrote: Fri Apr 10, 2020 7:22 pm ASRock, DriverBooster... lolI would not even touch both of it. That is a first lesson i got since my first days in IT. I don't get about RME Fireface 800 and USB described in issue 1. Fireface is a 1394 interface. It is known that firewire interfaces are very picky about the firewire chip installed. In my expirience TI chip is the only one that worked well wherever i put it. But i don't understand what about USB, what did you connected to a USB port at issue 1?
Issue 4 - you have to configure fan profile. It is better to do it manually than to select a preset.
DriverBooster, on the other hand, is pure garbage. Never use such utilities as they will always make things worse.
Overall this is the reason why I still (As)rock with my old Extreme4 G3 Z68/i7-3770K/Antec P193 as the main DAW. Obviously it has seen upgrades over time to SSD's, new fans, RAM, a new GPU (just a month a go) and some other bits. After the GPU upgrade, I'm sure I can get at least 2 years out of this system still. Even though I will eventually switch to modern Ryzen based system, it will also mean replacing all my PCI based audio interfaces. But at the moment, I'm just not yet ready let go of my Delta cards and OmniStudio.
Last edited by robotmonkey on Sun Apr 12, 2020 12:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.
No signature here!
