MAutoDynamicEQ - Midi Notes triggering Abletons Undo history

[stekra]

Hi,

I am using MAutoDynamicEQ to HP Filter my Bassline, like the picture is showing.
To shift the HP Filter according to the notes played, I use the Midi Notes function of Melda and that works great.

Screenshot 2023-10-23 173641.png

But....in Ableton, every Midi trigger of each played note leads to an entry of the frequency manipulation in the Undo history while the song is being played. I need to stop playing the song and if I played it for al long time, every midi notes information is a single history entry.

Screenshot 2023-10-23 174017.png

And if I want to edit an automation node value while playing, this also does not work. Ableton is not offering this function while playing the song. If I stop the song, it works again.

Any clue why this happens and how I can get rid of it with different Melda settings? I tried the Pitch follower module but it was not working correct at all times.

Otherwise I will have to blame Ableton for this

Thx, Stefan

[stekra]

Any ideas? Or does the use of Midi Notes generally produce actions that are reflected by the undo history?

p.s. in a former version of this post I suggested I got rid of this problem. Was not the case ;-(

[Held]

The same thing happens in REAPER as well. It looks like the MIDI controller actually changes the parameter instead of modulating it.
I think that behavior is very problematic, since it will fill your undo history with unnecessary changes. Hopefully this can be changed without breaking backwards compatibility.

[stekra]

Thx Held for your reply.
I already thought I am the only one with this problem.
Hopefully there is an "easy" way to solve it, as I really feal very comfortable with this method to " midi modulate" parameters.
Let`s see if Mr. Melda will solve it.
Cheers, Stefan