MuTools + u-he, + a few gigabytes of loops, could be marketed towards Bitwig and Ableton.
You guys, if you actually did it, would simply have to include sample data, loops, many gigabytes - because everone just expects it and that is that.
Urs said in a post awhile back, talking about Hive if I recall...like it should have high quality effects built in, because "everyone expects that now".
Also sample packs, loops... everyone expects that. Of course there are plenty of sounds available, but I still need another synthesizer.
Could such a product compete? With some advertising, word of mouth, forum posts like this...
Maybe...
