Why I'm going to pass on T2 upgrade

Discussion about: tracktion.com
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

Breakpete wrote:I've installed software before which installed some additional stuff I never wanted. And I can't remember wheither I had a choice of installing the MDA plugs or not in T1.
That was available in T1... it's called the minimal install. :wink:
ModuLR / Radio

Post

ModuLR wrote:
Breakpete wrote:I've installed software before which installed some additional stuff I never wanted. And I can't remember wheither I had a choice of installing the MDA plugs or not in T1.
That was available in T1... it's called the minimal install. :wink:

er.. nevermind my post
Image

Post

Oh you bet I'm going to upgrade. I think Tracktion is excellent, and v2 will be even better. I don't mind the plugins at all if they are not forced on me.

For me, the new features in T2 justified the upgrade before the plugins were ever announced.

Post

Great, it looks like the one concern I had can be put to rest.

The good news just keep coming :D

Post

BLAH BLAH BLAH :x :x :x :x :x :x

Post

koolkeys wrote:WHY DOES NOBODY GET THIS!?!?!?!?!?! The plug-ins for T2 are NOT all freebies! And they are NOT demo versions!
Where's your proof to back up those two statements? How do you know 100% for sure that say, RMIV has all the drumkits and samples of the full version? You don't.

Don't confuse your idle speculations for reality. The reality is that the product hasn't been released yet so
we don't know what state the plugs are in.

Post

Breakpete wrote:Montana, there is a free version of Acid available for download. Acid Xpress I think it's called. Don't know if it will sort you out, but it may be worth a try.
ACID Music Studio, approx $70.

Post

Breakpete wrote:I too strongly hope installing the included plugins is optional on a per plugin basis (e.g. install RMIV but not Sampletank SE). At least we should be able to delete the dlls.
Me too, I'll only be installing Amplitube LE (unless there are some other non-freeware gems included!) I've spent months now trying to streamline my plugin folders and get rid of everything I don't use. I spend far too much time playing with new VST's :hihi:

Shif.

Post

db wrote:
Breakpete wrote:Montana, there is a free version of Acid available for download. Acid Xpress I think it's called. Don't know if it will sort you out, but it may be worth a try.
ACID Music Studio, approx $70.
www.acidplanet.com

click acid xpress
Image

Post

koolkeys wrote:Really people, if you don't like the upgrade, and don't plan on doing so, then don't upgrade. But stop blaming it on things that aren't even true. People around here jump to conclusions too easy, like they are just TRYING not to be happy.

Sheesh!!!

Koolkeys
100 % ACK

Post

Montana wrote:""Your choice of course, Montana, but I bought Live 4 back in the autumn and I have to say it sucks compared to Tracktion. Visit the Ableton forum and check out what the users are saying - lots of anger at present.
Put in that context, I would definitely recommend reconsidering your next move... and I hope that helps!""


Thank you for the heads up! What do you like, dislike about the program other than this?
Well first off, there's lots I do like about Live 4:

- I like the clip paradigm
- I like the simple mixer
- I like the drum sampler "Impulse"
- I like most of the effects
- I mostly like the routing, but prefer the way Tracktion handles ReWire
- I like the way that MIDI files load in the browser rather than auto-connecting to tracks
- I like the pretty GUI :wink:
- I like the automation (which is identical to Tracktions, mind you, but without curved fade-in/outs, so a bit limited... Tracktion's automation is better)
- I like the general simplicity
- I like the "scene" approach to arranging

...but then again:

- I dislike the CPU hit, to the extent that I can only use it either by ReWiring in Reason's mega-CPU-friendly devices instead of VSTs, or bounce everything straight away
- I dislike the Arrange view in general; Tracktion is way better environment when it comes to linear work
- I dislike the timestretch, which is nowhere near as good as is sometimes made out, and can be disastrous if you don't select the correct one of the four algorhythmic choices most suitable for each clip's material
- I dislike that some important features are actually hidden away
- I dislike the fact that once the CPU hits around 65% audio breaks up. This doesn't happen in Tracktion til more like 85-90%, even at lower latencies than Live seems able to handle
- I dislike the quality of recordings, which clip even at low levels on my system. I think that the meters are probably broken :wink:
- I dislike the sound quality in general, as previously mentioned

Most of all I dislike the fact that it isn't what it claimed to be, i.e. a full-on DAW. I'm not a live DJ, and while it may be the dog's do-dahs for that fraternity, it simply doesn't work for me.

And to those who keep saying "why is Live compared to linear DAWs..." the answer is that in their marketing Ableton made claims to that effect, and in their rave reviews all the magazines stated it was capable of replacing your traditional DAW. It's not. End of story.

So there's the full run down for you, and I hope that saves you the hassle of forking out for something and then regretting it... or alternatively confirms that Live 4 is the program for you :wink:

Post

DB,
The statement you made is exactly right, which is why I keep telling people to stop griping about things until they know.

But I'll stand by my statements. I did not say that the versions won't be cut down in any way. I said they wouldn't be demos. And the ones that are cut down, it says. Like Amplitube and Sampletank. The others don't say that. And I highly doubt that Mackie would throw a bunch of demo plugs into their new software. Yeah, that would be smart.

So yes, I KNOW that these won't all be demos or whatever. Kits may be missing, or some features disableed on a couple, but other than that, it will be as it says. Besides, there are more than 70 plugs included, and we don't even know half of them yet.

I go by what the print says. I'm not speculating. If it said demo version or SE or LE or something, than that's what it is. If not, than it's not. That's just what it says.

So go ahead, complain. It's ok, wet your pants over it ya'll if you want, but wait to start griping about stuff you don't even know to be true.

Koolkeys

Post Reply

Return to “Tracktion”