The ability to randomize the phase of NoiseGenerator when rendering? (Feature Request?)

[SeeingInMidi]

Every time you hit a note when using the the NoiseGenerator module in MSF, the phase is random. But when you render or bounce it to audio, the phase of the whole audio file is always the same with every separate render which can be seen here.



Is there a way to randomize the phase of the NoiseGenerator and NoiseGenerator FX everytime when you render? If not, I would like to request this to be added to the NoiseGenerator module in MSF and in MNoiseGenerator.

[MeldaProduction]

Why would you want that? This is actually intentional! When you are using your DAW to make music, you certainly want it to sound the same when you render it. It was actually a hell of a work to make things work like this!

[Jopmanajop]

you certainly want it to sound the same when you render it

Hm, that's a good point actually. Same thing for random modulator, it's better to capture that random pattern, because it won't be the same again. I love randomizers for their unpredictability, but they're unmanageable, always demand recording

[SeeingInMidi]

Why would you want that? This is actually intentional! When you are using your DAW to make music, you certainly want it to sound the same when you render it. It was actually a hell of a work to make things work like this!

I like to create patches and bounce to audio for future use or sample creation. So if I happened to use the NoiseGenerator for multiple patches, and had bounce at the same bar but some renders are shifted a few milliseconds due to editing, I can run into some phasing problems when layering. It's a problem for sample creators like myself. Just a request, hopefully you understand.

Edit: there's a fairly popular synth out there that I will not name that lets you switch between from random phase and re-trigger at the same phase at every note press (stable is what it's labelled). Just another idea.

[MeldaProduction]

For the record, the "same phase at every note press" is there in pretty much all oscillators, but this is different. What I have done is a specific feature (which is imho great), which lets your renders to be (usually) the same every time, which is great imho. But I suppose there could be a global MSF switch for that...

[SeeingInMidi]

Thanks for taking it into consideration! To be clear, when I was talking about "same phase at every note press", it had to do with the noise oscillator. Thanks! What have you done is indeed a great feature by the way!

[MeldaProduction]

Got it, done in 14.05.

[SeeingInMidi]

Thanks a lot for this! Sorry to bother again, but can you also enable this for the NoiseGenerator in the FX section please?

[MeldaProduction]

Thanks a lot for this! Sorry to bother again, but can you also enable this for the NoiseGenerator in the FX section please?

No promises, but I'll add it to todo list. I think there is some problem, that's why I didn't make it like that. Also please note that one usually wants the opposite.