VSTis as good as hardware? Similar to Access Virus Quality?

VST, AU, AAX, CLAP, etc. Plugin Virtual Instruments Discussion
Post Reply New Topic
RELATED
PRODUCTS

Post

I just got my hands on the analogue I had told you guys about. It's the first portable Roland Synth, model is the SH-1000

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roland_SH-1000

Not sure if it's considered to be any good, but I'll post some sound samples soon, this thing is DIRTY ! lol

Cheers
Fots

Post

soundpalace wrote:I just got my hands on the analogue I had told you guys about. It's the first portable Roland Synth, model is the SH-1000

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roland_SH-1000

Not sure if it's considered to be any good, but I'll post some sound samples soon, this thing is DIRTY ! lol

Cheers
Fots
Who cares if it's good? It's dirty as hell and gives you a unique sound and hopefully it's fun to use. Way more important than making "proper" sounds. :D

Post

oh man, it is SO fun to use, but it needs a serious clean, some notes are a little cooky lol :D I'll be posting a sample of it's sound in about 30 mins :D

Fots

Post

Sorry this is TOTALLY rough, I was too busy screwing with the knobs...

http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.php?a ... 12de2a97e9

This thing is totally unstable, some notes start warbling n stuff, needs a good clean I think :D

The filter on this thing is HUGE and incredibly fat !

Fots

Post

Jep.. that's the typical roland vcf. I like it.. :)

Notice how a big part of the raw sound is actual noise in the background during each note on and that 'click' that happens every now and then.

I've said this the first time many years ago when the VSTi concept came alive and I'll say it again: Developers, STOP removing the NOISE from oscillators, filters and other circuits, it's one of THE biggest things in old analogue synths. Ironically it was one of the biggest marketing points of early VSTi and Virtual Analogue synths "buy brand xxxx now! all the punch without the noise!". It's like removing the "wooden frame" sound from a piano (building one out of plastic).

Cheers!
bManic
"Wisdom is wisdom, regardless of the idiot who said it." -an idiot

"They don't ban hate speech; they ban speech they hate." -an oracle

Post

bmanic wrote:Developers, STOP removing the NOISE from oscillators, filters and other circuits, it's one of THE biggest things in old analogue synths.
It's actually the other way around and the reason it's often not seen (the uncontrollable noise mod type things): the noise has to be *added* there, since it isn't a byproduct of any of the bread and butter algorithms we're used to... this in comparison to the noisy and somewhat unstable circuits we are also used to. It just has to be added in.

Post

bmanic wrote: I've said this the first time many years ago when the VSTi concept came alive and I'll say it again: Developers, STOP removing the NOISE from oscillators, filters and other circuits, it's one of THE biggest things in old analogue synths. Ironically it was one of the biggest marketing points of early VSTi and Virtual Analogue synths "buy brand xxxx now! all the punch without the noise!". It's like removing the "wooden frame" sound from a piano (building one out of plastic).

Cheers!
bManic
incidently this is one of the reasons i like a bit of aliasing, as you can see in my highly successful thread. of course some nice noise would prob be better, in fact i find its using a noise gen on many vsti thats makes them alias so much at filter sat stage.
Last edited by martian on Sun Aug 13, 2006 2:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Post

i think it's the same for mixing itb. there is a lack of noise. you have to add it really really low in level and things will sound 'better' to our ears.

Post

martian wrote:
bmanic wrote: I've said this the first time many years ago when the VSTi concept came alive and I'll say it again: Developers, STOP removing the NOISE from oscillators, filters and other circuits, it's one of THE biggest things in old analogue synths. Ironically it was one of the biggest marketing points of early VSTi and Virtual Analogue synths "buy brand xxxx now! all the punch without the noise!". It's like removing the "wooden frame" sound from a piano (building one out of plastic).

Cheers!
bManic
incidently this is one of the reasons i like a bit of alaising, as you can see in my highly successful thread. of course some nice noise would prob be better, in fact i find its using a noise gen on many vsti thats makes them alais so much at filter sat stage.
Aliasing? Aliasing has nothing todo with analog sound, infact it's impossible for an analog circuite (ie synth) to alias (exept if you use some kind of discrete sampling in the audio chain)

Post

bmanic wrote:Jep.. that's the typical roland vcf. I like it.. :)

Notice how a big part of the raw sound is actual noise in the background during each note on and that 'click' that happens every now and then.
also the note on click and thump sounds like 'dc burst' on zeta, i think the only vsti ive found that emulates this.

Post

martian wrote:
bmanic wrote:Jep.. that's the typical roland vcf. I like it.. :)

Notice how a big part of the raw sound is actual noise in the background during each note on and that 'click' that happens every now and then.
also the note on click and thump sounds like 'dc burst' on zeta, i think the only vsti ive found that emulates this.
triangle has this also!

Post

snooky wrote: Aliasing? Aliasing has nothing todo with analog sound, infact it's impossible for an analog circuite (ie synth) to alias (exept if you use some kind of discrete sampling in the audio chain)
i know, but..
soundpalace wrote:Sorry this is TOTALLY rough, I was too busy screwing with the knobs...

http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.php?a ... 12de2a97e9

This thing is totally unstable, some notes start warbling n stuff, needs a good clean I think :D

The filter on this thing is HUGE and incredibly fat !

Fots
i hear an almost slight dissonant harmonic to some of the notes, sounds like a thin metal plate being hit, and very similar to aliasing when you go up high at 0.10s. can you do a 320, so i can see if the noise is still there? i love the filter reso, sounds like it gets a bit saturated instead of being overly powerful and 'popping out' as you sweep like on many vas.
Last edited by martian on Sun Aug 13, 2006 5:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Post

Why haven't I heard anything about Reaktor (5) ? I know its used professionally all the time, and it offers all you want (cause its infinite modular)? Does anyone know if its worth to buy a Clavia Modular G2, if you have Reaktor 5?

-Victor

Post

vvanrij wrote:Why haven't I heard anything about Reaktor (5) ? I know its used professionally all the time, and it offers all you want (cause its infinite modular)? Does anyone know if its worth to buy a Clavia Modular G2, if you have Reaktor 5?

-Victor
All the NI products have the worst manuals, especially Reactor! (I consider as best the GMedia's Minimonsta Manual). It's quite difficult to understand how exactly this monster (Reactor) works and then program it by only reading its manual.For this reason, i believe that hardware like G2 is better because it's easier to handle it even if you have it for 2 hours. Except this, i don't believe that Reactor is worst than a G2.I could say that it's better..It depends on your programming a lot. On the other side, you can use other people's patches which i personally found good only for modern production techniques and experimental music. With G2 you can quicker get "into the point". I'm not a fan of Clavia though..they sell steel at the price of gold... :x
It's more fun to compute..

Post

Hey guys,bManic I completely agree, even without any oscs on, this thing produces some tone, a click is always heard when you hit a note and the waveforms produced do indeed have some noise, especially heard in the lower notes.

This does not alias guys, not even the tiniest bit of digital aliasing can be heard on this thing, the high end (treble) of the oscs is absolutely crystal clear, I even analysed it with an FFT to confirm. So far, the closest VSTi I've heard to this synth is the Minimonsta, although that synth is still lacking the dirty sound this analog offers.

I'll try get it cleaned tonight, some notes are doing strange ... alien-like things :D

Cheers
Fots

Post Reply

Return to “Instruments”