I don't mean to be pedantic, but I think "continuous" is a better way to describe it, MTS-ESP always works in realtime! But yes indeed, only some synths will change the tuning of an already sounding note and others don't (the list I linked makes note of which do, to the best of our knowledge).tumface wrote: Tue Jun 10, 2025 4:01 amI know. The reason we're on this topic is because u-he synths currently do not support real time retuning. You can't retune notes that are already playing or have just started playing, making the MTS-ESP JI thing not workable on u-he synths.Andreya_Autumn wrote: Mon Jun 09, 2025 1:55 pm Indeed many synths don't support MTS-ESP. But also many do! This is the most comprehensive list we know of and it is getting pretty long (all the U-He synths are on there for example):
I make JI music with the note-on version all the time! I understand that this probably means my exact musical goals are different than yours. I just don't want any passers-by to think that MTS-ESP and U-He synths are unsuitable for Just-Tuned music in general, that's (pun intended hehe) just not true!
For the record, "They" is me.tumface wrote: Tue Jun 10, 2025 4:01 amThe way Scale Breaker handles this is much more convenient and is a better design. They should just copy that. (In my opinion, anyway!)Andreya_Autumn wrote: Mon Jun 09, 2025 1:55 pm CC messages can be used to move the mapping around on the lattice yes. The purpose of that is more for real-time playing. Map a few MIDI buttons or footswitches to shift the territory around and you can play JI music with more than 12 notes on a 12-note keyboard. But the location on the lattice is also controlled by DAW parameters, so for timeline arrangement that's way more convenient.
